Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutR-90-0239J-90--43( a) 3/22/90 RESOLUTION NO. !_)0-0Z-39 A RESOLUTION DENYING THE APPEAL AND AFFIRMING SUBJECT TO ADDITIONAL LIMITATIONS AS SET FORTH HEREIN, THE ZONING BOARD'S REVERSAL OF THE ZONING ADMINISTRATOR'S OCTOBER 27, 1989 ORDER TO REMOVE COOKING FACILITIES FROM THE PREMISES LOCATED AT 3328 SOUTHWEST 23 TERRACE, MIAMI, FLORIDA, (MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIIBED HEREIN), USED BY A CATERING SERVICE KNOWN AS "SARA SHARPE CATERING", WHICH IS OPERATING PURSUANT TO A CLASS C PERMIT ISSUED BY THE PLANNING DEPARTMENT; ZONED RG-1/3 GENERAL RESIDENTIAL. WHEREAS, the Miami Zoning Board at its meeting of December 18, 1989, Item No. 1, adopted Resolution ZB 130-89 by a nine to zero vote (9 - 0), granting the appeal and reversing the Zoning Administrator's October 27, 1989, order to remove cooking facilities from the premises located at 3328 Southwest 23 Terrace, Miami, Florida, (more particularly described herein) used by a catering service known as Sara Sharpe Catering, which is operating pursuant to a Class C permit issued by the Planning Department; and WHEREAS, a neighbor has taken an appeal to the City Commission from the Zoning Board's decision; and WHEREAS, the City Commission, after careful consideration of this matter, deems it advisable and in the best interest of the general welfare of the City of Miami and its inhabitants to affirm the decision of the Zoning Board subject to additional limitations as set forth hereinbelow; NOW, THEREFORE, RE IT RESOLVED BY THE COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI , FLORIDA: Section 1. The appeal from the Zoning Board's decision to allow the cooking facilities used by a catering service known as Sara Sharpe Catering, which is operating pursuant to a Class C permit issued by the Planning Department, at the premises located at 3328 Southwest 23 Terrace, Miami, Florida, more particularly CITY COMMISSION MEET114C OF MAR 22 1990 (('jja�r BOWDON No, —�✓X EMBARKS: described as Lot 54, Block 9, MIAMI SUBURBAN ACRES AMEND., as recorded in Plat Book 4, Page 73, of the Public Records of Dade County. Florida, as per plans on file, zoned RG-1/3 General Residential (One and Two Family), is denied and the decision of the Zoning Board is hereby affirmed subject to the additional limitations that there shall be at least five on -site parking spaces and that there shall be no deep fry cooking on the Premises. PASSED AND ADOPTED this 2?nd day of March , 1990. XAVIER L. SU R , MAY R AT MA TY HIRAI CITY CLERK PREPARED AND APPROVED BY: % NV W-r--\0\ QA Ck��AI'RIAR MAER CHIEF ASSISTANT CITY ATTORNEY APPROVED AS TO FORM AND CORRECTNESS: OR E L . FE ANDE Z ^~ CITY ATTORN _J GMM/ra/M1322 - 2 - 90-023f) Lj Ll ZONING FACT SHEET LOUTIONMEGAL 3323 SW 23 Terrace Lot 54 Block 9 iiIAMI SUBURIW; ACE: S A.4END (4 - i 3) P . R . D . C . APPEL_L_eNT David W. Gillis cio Sara Sharpe Cateri=g 3328 SW 23 Terrace Miami, FL Lucia Dougherty, ES q . 1ZZ1 Brickell Avenue Miami, Z 33131 Phone 579--0603 ZONING RG-1/3 General Residential (Qne and I::o Fa:ily). REOUEST Appeal of Zoza= A,a=;L=strator's aecisloa _t nis letter of October 27 , 1989 elimir.atz:.2 cooriag on premises for the catering sepvice aliowea on above site. RECOY2TUHDA'1:ONS ZONING _CZ=T& ON RECMSEND DENTAL. Jraerea cook.i; g f ac:_llties removea oa Octooer '", 1989 attar _..tormea by Planning Department that the Class C per- t was approvea with the unaerstar di-g that no cooic.ing for the catering was to be aone on site. At its M--tina of Decmmr 18, 1989, the Zoning board anooter' Resolution ZB 130-89 by a vote of 9 to 0, crrantina the aomai. reversina the cecision of the Zorn ng Aam nistrator. APPEAL Letter gated Decemoer ";, 1989 from Arujro :. Caraoallo. CITY COMMISSION At its meeting of January 25, 1990, the City Commission continued consideration of the above. CITY COMMISSION At its meeting of February i":, 1990, the.City Commission continued consi- deration of the above. SO--0239 Arturo G. Caraballo To t .e Eu~ildiniv end Zoning Department of the City of ism; I, A_rT=o G. Ca.racailo, au 3,34-2 'S"N 23rd. :,err. in '%pis City of =y r:..Fhts do AFEEA.L the ::e- cision of the Board cf December 18, 1;3101, i _ t^e case N= Sara Sharpe Catering Service with reference to a cateri.-.- Service authorized at 3324-2E-28 3'-. 23rd Terrace. December 23, 198c. cc! J. G enuardi. , Z o ra. ,r A dmini s t rati o r �.il. Fuentes, r�Z Director G. CLedi'i.o, Dem. Directii of rlar=L:I All J emC�!of t. e card jGG .','Y FL. 33145 DEC 7- 9 1989 office at' r ,3 CO (40 -0239 LA LJ .Ts. I b A M0raIes of fered ch? Iol.Ioaing RpsoL11ti.on. and moved its adoption. RESOLUTION ZB 130-89 RESOLUTION TO GRANT APPEAL, REVERSING THE DECISION )F THE ZONING ADMINISTRATOR'S DECISION IN HIS LETTER OF OCTOBER 2.7, 1989 ELIMINATING COOKING ON PREMISES FOR THE CATERING SERVICE ALLOWED FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 3328 SW 23 TERRACE ALSO DESCRIBED AS LOT 54, BLOCK 9, HIAMI SUBURBAN ACRES AMEND (4-73) P.R.D.C. AS PER PLANS ON FILE; ZONED RG-1/3 GENERAL RESIDENTIAL (ONE AND T140 FAMILY). Upon being seconded by Mr. George Bar.ket, the motion was passed and adopted by the following vote: AYES: Ms. Basila, Morales and Cruz Messrs. Sands, Luaces , :Moran-Ribeaux Alonso--Poch, Dunn and Barket NAYES : 'lone. ABSENT: None Ms. Fox: `lotion carries 9 to 0. 90- 0239 December 18, 1989 Icem # 1 Zoning Board \,--3 kA n :,1: • :41 LAW orricEs GRBl Macion,'TRAURiG, HOFFMAN, (. porr, RoseN & C)UENTEL. P. A. I�tj�n111V 1221 ®RICKELL. AVENUE iA 1. FLORICA 33131 C SROWARO OFrtf C •QQ ( Cgf"J9 300 9FiOWARO 130...1 523.8111 .PEST PALM SEACM OFr'C£ !00 EAST 15ROWAR0 SOULEVARO VJ rELKX 80. 3124 601 FORUM PLACE • S,IrE 3C' SUITE +350 F.L.CC0PV 13031 879-0717 -EST PALM BEACH. VLOMOA 334C, CRT LAUGEROALE. FLCRIOA 33394 4071 683-661: ;3051 765 -0500 *ELECOP. 14071 683 - 8,147 'EL[COPY 13031 765• 1A77 LUCIA A. OOUGN[RTY 579.0603 November 6, 1989 Ms. Gloria Fox Hearing Boards Chief City of Miami Building and Zoning Department 275 N.W. 2nd Street Miami, Florida 33128 Re: Appeal of Decision of Department of Planning 3328 S.W. 23rd Terrace Dear Gloria: PLEASE REPLY TO: MIANI OP'R'ICC Zoning Administrator and/or regarding Catering Service at Please consider this letter an appeal, pursuant to Section 3000 of the Zoning Code of the City of Miami, of the decision as reflected in the attached October 27, 1989 letter from Joseph Genuardi (Exhibit "I.")- The basis of this appeal is as follows: 1. It is alleged that cooking is a violation of the attached Class "C" Permit No. 89-1204 (Exhibit 11211). However, no such prohibition is contained in such Class "C" Permit. 2. It is clear that the use for which the Class "C" was issued is a catering service. Catering requires the preparation of food on site to be cooked in the home of the ultimate consumer; however, some cooking is required in the preparation of food. 3. Cooking is not the main use of the premises, but, instead, preparation of food is the main use. 4. There is no requirement under the law for the removal of any range, stove, hood, accessory chimnr�v or exhaust stack, regardless of what use is permitted on the premises. 5. The applicant has received permits for the installation of the range, stove, hood, accessory chimney or exhaust stack and has relied, to his detriment, on the issuance of such permits. 90--1 239 Ms. Gloria Fox November 6, 1989 Page 2 6. The appellant herein has expended approximately $30,000 in reliance upon such permits and decisions by the various City inspectors and/or permit processors. It is, therefore, requested that you set this matter before the Zoning Board of Adjustment as an appeal of the interpretation of the Zoning Administrator and Planning Department in this matter. A January hearing dace would be convenient for my client. His check in the amount of $550.00, made payable to the City of Miami, is enclosed. Sincerely, LAciaDougherty LAD/ j hd enclosures cc: Mr. Joseph Genuardi Mr. Guillermo almedillo 90- 0239 GREENBERG. TRAURIG, HOFFMAN, UPOFF, Rosem tk OUENTEL. P. A. EDITH M. FUENTES 0irector ".r. :avid W. Gillis c/o Sara Sharpe Catering :328 —W- 2? Terr Miami.=Iorida �ESXR H. 0010 Or City Manalter •I� co Fdo�\C. _ ^' Yam- —. / October 27, 1989 Re: Catering Service at 3328 S.W. 23rd Terr wear 7,illis : _t has come to my attention that unaer ?uilding Per;c,t 'lo. 89- 5757, you naal installed a range, stove and hood and are cooking on t:.e premises. ':his is in violation of your Class C Permit No. 89-1204 fcr change of a non -conforming use from a Print Shop to a --'at8t-,-na Cervice. I , have been informed ty .he ?Ianning :eoar.:menc that `he catering service as a00rovea is only for the .reoarati:;n of :•ooa and any cookcing required is to be core at the custcmer's site at wnic:1 the food is being provided. You are nerefore directea. within two (2) weeks of receipt of this notice, to obtain a permit to remove the range, :.cove, hood ana any accessory chimney or exhaust stack which was required f:,r ne equi-N ent . do so '.Jill necessitate taXinQ enforcement action and possiz-1 a cancei'_aticn cf your Cass C Permit cnd Certificate d: Use. Very truly yours, 0 ERA A. GENUARDI Ch-ef; Code Administration *AG/ � 7 ,c : rcio Rodr:. guez . Assistant City Manager veGuillermo 01meaislo, Deputy Director. Planning Dept. Edith M. c uentes, Euilding & Zoning Director• -3ntiago „urge-d.antura, Ass't . Director, Sldg. Zoning Connor Adams, Chief, Mechanical Section, Bldg & Zoning File 90° 0 39 BUILDING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT 5 N A'. Ind Streevry 0.601K 3307Otl miamt. Fan 33Z33.07 /0051 350.7*951 e 2 Arturo G. Carabatlo Edith.M Fuentes, Director Building and Zoning Department City of Miami Me Fuentes: Reference is made to a communication that at 7 pm, December 18, 1989 the Hearing Board Division will held a Public Hearing in .relation, to an Appeal of tha Zoning Ad- miastrator' s decision of eliminating cooking on premises of a Catering Service allowed at 3328 SW 23 Terr. This letter is issued in substitution of the card that was supposed to be included with the above mentioned Communicatiion, but that was not. My property is located at 3320-22 SW 23 Terr, therefore I have a direct interest in this case. I am oppose to the appeal against the Octuber'27 1989 Zoning Administrator's decision eliminating the cooking on the premses, which never has been complied with, up to this moment. But the most important thing, which I am repeat- ing here, is: there is no valid right o a non -conforming status, whatever, for the owner of the prove= of this case, since said rixht was extinrui.shed in accordance to 2104.6 ru- le of the Zoning Ordinances, for being vacant and empty in excess of 180 days. The inspection that supposedly was practiced in June 10, 1988, to an.open and operating printing shop is ab- solutely false. At said time the place was empty for months. That Public act is a felony. And to include it in the Public Records is another. To cover it up is also another felony. Miami, December 119 1989. 3322 SW 23 Terr. Mia=i, FL 33145 R CdiVI''3 ULU 1 2 1989 Office;,; dhe Director 90 L.39 CITY OF MIAM1. FLORIDA INTLrR-OFFICE MEMORANDUM Sergio Rodriguez, Director November 8, 1989 ° Planning Department OATS n�E: Joseph Cenuardi, SUBJECT. Appeal of Class C Zoniag Administrator Permit 89—IZ04/ Zoning Administrator's cRUM ,b.l�"j6L 4EFE�ENQj:C i s i o n of 1 0/ 2 7/ 8 9 i Fox, Chief hearing Boards Division ENCL0SU;m4;ter of Appeal. dated Building & Zoning Department 11/6/89 Attached is a copy of the appeal received of the above mentioned Appeal. Please submit all materials which constitute the record upon which the decision was taken. Also please include the names and mailing addresses of all parties who have expressed interest or opposition in this natter. 90-0239 C!? NNE r, CITY OF MIXI.N FLOiNRIDA INTER -OFFICE ME RAVDW p 4 ;20 Gloria Fox, Chief Hearing Boards Division Josd1 A. Genuardi, P.B. -fiiefl Code Administration 7ATE November 13, 1989 = _= 5UEUECT Appeal of Decision to Remove Cooking Facili- ties at 3328 SW 23 Terr Sara Sharpe Catering REFERENCFSrlass C Permit No. 89-1204 =-NCL05UAES Attached are copies of documents in my file pertaining to the appeal, other than those already in your file, and which entered into my decision. i. Letter from Sheila Wolfson to Guillermo 01medillo, dated April 18, 1989. 2. Letter from Sheila Wolfson to Mayor Xavier Suarez, dated July 19, 1989. SAG/jg Tc file 90-0`239 .CrrME- P AGaON rraNANO0 C. >LCNSO __SAP L a-.AREZ V=AC ANOMEWS r aAAGCN •CART SAgs. - _aPlf 9+SS BAUMGAATCN -;.IYAN 8CNrOPO SA 3E-GEM .0 VARQO r 9-'TO raANC15 B BROGAN _a 5-RI B-U-=N _-*vt SUJ -:JCK ar SEPT - AURLIMG-CN __dERT.-3 A :AROENAS .,C...MO G :•.CRR- €. • :CBS •ENOAL-4 _Crrf- .NC '+ -NN1rr . _I, C 7tCAPLO .-=AP :[.. GVAAOIA :t. :AsT - . _av :,-ONO --_ A nr.,uO.MCWIT _-APLES -`/ fuSiAR u 5-3AN .7 C-SC- -CVRr +. 3I,CM." rCx .=BCRT - TRIEON." R�eEPr_ :ANG > r..•atl d ..►PRfT. _REEL - Its •LE'N " ..STD ..,.AENCE ::C :rS.. _AW OFrICES GREENeERG. TRAURIG. HOFFMAIN, LIPOFF, ROSEN & WUENTEL. R. 4. •LAN S GOLO STCVEN C S3ClOwAN iTCVEN IA GOL7s MITY _OSERr G GOL75T['N .AwR[NCC S. GCROON •.AT: MCW !� GORSON :IAMNC GRCLNeE RG �ELVIM NGPELNB[mG �OBCRT L. oROSsMAN :AgMCN Y r.CAMANOEZ _ SA A I'.,ASC- •CNNCTN C-Orr..M -ARMY J -01r-AM vAMCOS O.-I-C-CZ vAR71N •ALB _,. RI [ IIIL®CMG "NQTNT C .IIS., 3-C'�CN J •R.VIr2 ¢-rVEN A -ANOT .LAN S I.L CRYAN ;AMT A LEVINSCN VURYAN .. vPOrr ]APLOS E _OuI+•C- IANCT LUP1A •CC--C V 3auCE C ••.CCCNCUG- aOBCRT R r CIN• ANOR[W L VANN RCOMO J --.RTINCZ 1-.GA _JAN J •.A-OL .� NILLIAM LEE 4!G,NNCSS _OwN T-r'2GC- .7UI% M •-ONTEL-- -A +_.CIA ..OR.LES .ANCT Z 9RICM oESCC_A A O.-MJ BY HAND° -DELIVERY �LBSIC !,. ORSN[esAr STEVAN J. PAA00 OLGA E. PARRA MAR$NALL R 0ASTCRMAC- STRON G PETLRSEN >LB[RT O OUENTEL -."..EL RCINSTEIN ..ARK J RC;S.AN JIs REITER CONSTANCE - NIOOCM +MORES 0—ER0 -ENNETM a ROBINSOM N.CMOLAS ROCKWEL� -AOUCL A 11OORIGUEZ A, -AN .. ROLNICK ..ARVIN S ROSEN RICMAMO A POSCN11IALI- MONALO M MOSCNGARTCN 1AV.O L. ROSS aLOEM E RUOOLP- ; &nv • SALIL • ARLENC . SILVERYAN STUART - SINGER -OLLT P SAOLNICA :aV.O R SOrINCSS _AUMA R STEP-ENSCN ZAV10 J 'AMET _AURA N TMQYAS :SVALOO r 'DARES QOBRRT -. r.AURIG .ERROLO • .-Sl. -OBERT w - OLr -IYOTN- 0 wOLrC SMCILA WOLrSON .OAa. S ZIPPER ZACMAP♦ r. M.OLrr .-"-COI Mr. Guillermo Olmedi'_'_o Deputy Director City of Miami Planning Department 275 N.W. 2nd Street Miami, Florida 4 MIAs I OrrICIZ '221 BRICKELL AVENUE -IAYI ­-ZCIQA 33131 -TLCo-'ONES 579'05C0 9ROWAPO1.3051 523 8•11 _. EX dO 3184 -CSr --L/ aCACM Orr1Cr .0 AV gTI.A I'AM A.CNLIE . S..-TE 2'^ •wLST RALr RE.C-. r1.a RIOA 3311-e !_ECOP- 0", BB3 e"r 94OWAMO O'r'CC 500 CAST 8*0w 0O OOULE~00 - 5.. '! J•_: rCRT LAVOCROALE, r..0010A J3394 3cs1 7e5 ODOO -C-CCC•- JC51 'ea +r- April 18, 1989 Re: Class C Permit, 3328 S.W. 23rd Terrace Dear Guillermo: n PITrol S 71RCC- NO (305) 579-0581 PLEASC PC PLY TO .'.I AIM4 c�rrlCE ~o o _. This firm has teen retained by Sara Sharpe with :ecard to her application for a Class C Permit to allow the operation of her catering service at the above address. You have indicated your intent to deny this Class C Permit and a conference on this matter is scheduled for 2:30 p.m. on Thursdav, April 00, 1989. Prior to that time, I would like to submit for your consideration the Fallowing additional information that I believe addresses the concerns expressed in your Notice of Intended Decision. The applicant wishes to locate her catering service, Sara Sharpe Catering, Inc., in a small commercial building '-that pre- sently !souses a print shop operation. Ms. Zharpe, er !:usband and child would live in the residence located on the rear of this property behind the commercial structure. The subject property is located in the RG-1/3 zoning classification and is therefore a non -conforming use, originally established :n approximately 1936. As an existing non -conforming use, the print shop, of 90-0 :39 Mr. Guillermo O lmed illo April 18, 1989 Page 2 course, has the right to continue in operation, while a different use would have to secure approval through the special permit process. We believe such a permit for the proposed catering service would be in the public interest because it would replace the more intensive use of the property as a print shop with one that produces less impact on the neighborhood because it will generate much less noise, have fewer employees, not require the use of any hazardous materials, have no customers visiting t-he site, have only a handful of deliveries per week, and have a very limited need for parking that can be adequately satisfied by the existing parking on the site. The proposed catering business is one that, by its nature, operates on an intermittent basis. Unless there are orders to be prepared for a particular party, there is no activity. Unlike a restaurant, the catering business only purchases supplies and provisions when there is a forthcoming event; therefore, there is no daily delivery of provisions. Moreover, the owners of the business purchase many of the items themselves, thus also mini- mizing deliveries. ':his is a small Family operated business, with Ms. Sharpe and her husband as the principals. There is only one full-time employee, a chef. Other employees, such as a pot washer, work only part-time and in most instances walk or use public transportation. The owners use no trucks in the operation of the business, only their two personal vehicles, a van and a station wagon. With regard to the specific zoncerns regarding this tusiness raised in your Notice of Intended Decision, we would note the following in response: 1. Ingress and Egress. Ingress and egress to the property, which will be minimal due to the small number of deliveries and no customer visits, will be accomplished in exactly the same way as that for the residences located up and down the street, where the driver is required to back out into the street. Moreover, there are no trees or other obstructions blocking the view for vehicles exiting from the driveway to the street. 2. Off -Street Parking and Loadinc. Although your "notice of Intended Decision indicates that there is no off-street parking and loading facilities, several doors are located on Lhe side of the building dizectly adjacent to the driveway, which have always served over the past fifty years for parking and loading. Please keep in mind that there ` 0-0239 GREENbERG. TRAURIG. HOFFm^m. LiPafrF, ROSEN Bc OUENTEL. P. A. / J 4 Mr. Guillermo olmed illo April 18, 1989 Page 3 will be no large Mucks such as tractor trailers entering cr exiting the property, and the largest vehicle that will be on the premises is a standard size van. The existing loading area is quite adequate for such a vehicle, and parking is available in the driveway. 3. Refuse and Service. Nil refuse will be neatly packaged and stored in waterproof and vermin -proof containers at the rear of the building. Col- lection will occur at least twice weekly and more frequent arrangement for collection can be made if necessary. In sum, we believe that the proposed use of the existing commercial structure as the site of a catering service will rep- resent a reduction .n the intensity of the use from that cf the existing printing shop, that the site has adequate parking and loading for the proposed use, and that the proposed use will not adversely affect the neighborhood. In light of these facts, we -_ _espectftally request your reconsideration of your Intended decision to deny a Class C Permit. Sin c rely yours, 1 Sheila Wolfson � cc: David Gillis 9 LJ 00`%!3 iJ GACrNHERG. TRAURiG, Horrm N. UPOIrr, ROSEN & oUENTEL. P. A. % �} E _Aw Crr'ICES 3ReetieERG. 'gAURiG. HorFMAN1 L parir. ROSEN a ©UENTEL. 3 4 .rrraE♦ C AGXoN ALAN S G.7LD CCe11IC - oP3wCrSA• rCaNAMCC C ALQN50 V'rvtN E Gam.-u aN STEVAN J DANDO :ESAa L .LYAPCZ S_rv[H M SOLOS-"- 3LGA E "AONA Y .0A C ANOAews .OSEP" G G _ZS-t N MaPgr.ALL Q AASTCnNACN a'APAI Crr'PE __COLRr r .4AGON ..•wN[NCE S LZ0004- 8•wgN G DIC"EnSEN 22' SPIC-E­ AVENUE .ra01 •. gang" -AT?-ew a :CQSCN +.6[P1 J OL.E' --. -AMI o _3gIOA 33131 - _AQIE MASS : ANNIC GREENaE"G _CEt ACINSTC'N - Pw _.SSA " aA-iMGAPrCN '+CLYIN " GArr"!r RG •.AAN , QEIS.A. 9ENrONO DOA[AT L :DCSSMAN - -1s ACITtN afaO[w CAPMCN •-CQNANOEZ _INSTANCE - AIOCEP snowARo 13C_' S23 3^' -APN O SLOCM - SA • ..1QSCw ANoNes a1YICwo -.Ex 90 3 26 ,:hAn00 r "QITO .ICNNETN C -1:rr A" aENN[-M 0. PC911.90N •L ' _EC :'J. C: _S. 'DANCIS 0 BROGAN �R _AAPT .�-Or,..N I C-OLAS ROCKWELL a-PT sOU-oN +AACOs O - �ENCZ °AOUCL A 000wIOUEZ .'CVC 8%I =:K wAPTtN KALQ n. NVIN aoQ NICK S OSC ..EST ..L-OC ACC prr'C( aCgcgl a SUaLINGTCN .,; PI C .1LgLAG Q1C"AN0 A NOSENSAUM .O auSr O•L•+" aYt Nv[ 4V'•C t- +_ScgE C O CAAOIC NAS `.•L7T•'a. [ weg.. -0N11J M OOSE "GAP T[N ^'EST ..p1 R►L� ![AC.. �, iA 0A �+C --•LLR �AAVICA S�rV[NJ aAA V11j :AVIGL Ross n.- $aar ea•' _ .-Po G C-Caw. 5-EVE141 A _ANOT +,.JEN C nOCCLP" •.tCC A. ep" !91 aN' "- . COb L.N g .E,^.EQMAN �Aw♦ • SAVL . „vALr S C, r,r- :AA. A _C.•N$QN _-;rrOPo A SCMULMAN =NNIrr NONMAN M ,.ROrr MANLENC K SILY90Y rrrg[- 3 OCCAPLO :AOLQS C STUART " SINGER a.ow..o orr.ee .SCAN C :[.a •:w AaG1A .-AN P LQU-IET -0"r Q SNCLNICK .:Q CAST daa, .ao sc".EV.AQ S•.' -.SIEaT A *t. CASTILLO N.NCT LU"IA•C=e C-d =AVID P SOrTN[SS 1='°T --�OENOAL[ r.�•10A ]]]9+ +.an' 0'MOI'10 aPUCE E `+ACZCNOUGI+ _AURA O STEDMENSON �C5!'65 ctco .-Z. A .70UGMICNTY QOG[PT 0 MACINA iAVIA J 'ANCT r_E��Rv 7031 'ISM •)^ _-.PLCS w EDGAR 1.1 ANOwEw L wANN .AURA " r"O"As t. iLD[T Dt ono J +. .TINtZ INAGA ZSVAL00 r -CONICS -4NP. w DLLCATI rCx _J[1. O --Sea 009[NT " InAUNIG .YPIrr. S Z1P[c� "O DOlpEar J rwI(O".N ...AN ., M 0L. -A A w1S" T .CSCPC ZANG «IL LIAM LEE-COIN D[PLEWROLO 09T M wOr .5%9�'0581 a CMa'a0 G :.APAt_T _,:MN r MC-ZGEA -1MOTMT O wOLrt ja•AN A GAMY _J01y N -0Nr EL.7..A Sr VLA WoLrSON wLlwA4C PC�LT TO, - SA.CE ^'LCb'.LE'" ..C'.A M-00ALES •CIA" g tlPw(w MIAMI CrrICC a•_wAaQ .-'VSTo ..NET L C sale" -ac"CE GODOr4K. SESCCCA Ia CQANO :AC"APY " wOLrr .r.1NC pl July 19, 1989 SAND -DELIVERED The Honorable Xavie. Suarez Mayor, City of Miami 3500 Pan American Dr. Miami, Florida 33133 Dear Mr. Suarez: This letter is in response to Arturo G. Caraballo's letter to.you, a copy of which is attached for your convenience. ^he undersigned represents Sara Sharpe and her husband, David Gillis, who operate Sara Sharpe Catering, Inc. in a small commercial building at 3328 S.W. 23rd Terrace, which is located next door to Mr. Caraballo. On behalf of nay clients, I would like to respond to the concerns expressed in Mr. Caraballo's letter to you. The catering service is operating in a commercial building originally built in approximately 1936. The property has an RG- 1/3 zoning classification and therefore the commercial building is a nonconforming use. On the rear of the property behind the commercial building is a residence, which, since Ms. Sharpe and her husband have an infant, was one of the attractive features of this property, allowing their child to be nearby and under the supervision of his parents while they operate the catering service. The prior business locaced on this property was a 90-0239 /119 CA The Honorable Xavier Suarez July 19, 1989 Page 2 printing shop, a nonconforming which of course had the right to catering service had to secure permit zoning process. Contrary to Mr. Caraballo's not authorize the catering use; Code a Class C permit for a diffc by the Planning Department. rn Class C permit occurred after Olmedillo, Deputy Director of Teresita Fernandez of the Plar proposed use of the property wa owners of the property and th 3rodeur, and Ms. Sharpe and revealed that the catering servi of the property than th.e printinc the neichborhood. Facts wp use established some years ago, continue in operation, while the approval through the special statement, Mr. Joe Genuardi did ender the City of Miami's Zoning rent nonconforming use is issued this instance, issuance of the a meeting with Mr. Guillermo the Planning Department, and ning Department, in which the s thoroughly discussed with the printing shop, Mr. and Mrs. ier husband. This discussion :e would be a less intensive use shop and produce less impact on re ❑resented sunnnrI-i m,; ih i a conclusion including the following: (1) The catering service would have fewer employees than the printing shop. Ctrs. Brodeur states that the print shop had 23 employees, whereas the catering service is limited to 2 full-time employees; (2) The catering service generates less noise than the operation of the printing presses; (3) The catering service would not require the use or any hazardous materials such as the chemicals used in printing; (4) The catering service has no customers visiting the site, unlike the printing shop, thereby presenting a lower volume of :_affic; and (5) The catering service has only a handful of deliveries per week and has very limited need for parking that could be adequately satisfied by the existing parking on the site. The catering business is cne that, ty its nature, operates on an intermittent basis. Unless there are orders to be prepared For a particular party, there is no activity. Unlike a restaurant, the catering business only purchases supplies and provisions when there is a forthcoming event; therefore, there is no daily delivery of provisions. Moreover, the owners of the business purchase many food supplies themselves, thus also mini- mizing deliveries. This is a small, family -operated business with Ms. Sharpe and her husband as the principals. There are only two full-time employees. Other employees such as a pot - washer, work only part-time and in most instances, walk or use public transportation,. Ms. Sharpe and her husband use no trucks in the operation of the business, only their two personal vehicles: a van and a station wagon. 90-02w) GR[CWfdeRG, TRAURIG, HOOT AN, UP0rF. ROSEN a durNTEL. P. R. IrA The Honorable July 19, 1989 Facie 3 Xavier Suarez With regard to the specific fears concerning this business raised in Mr. Caraballo's Letter, we would note the following In response: 1. Air pollution. There is no deep-frying or .any kind occurring on the premises, accordingly, "the grease floating in the air" and grease filters feared by Mr. Caraballo do not exist. Catering involves food preparation rather than cooking. Cooking is done at the customer's home immediately prior to serving the food. Food preparation, on the other hand, consists of preparing the ingredients which will later be cooked at the site of the party. For example, hot hors d'oeuvres would be prepared at the catering service location, however, they would be baked and served at the site of the party. At the present time, there is not even an oven on the catering service premises that is used for baking. Moreover, the building is fully air- conditioned and therefore even if there were extensive cooking, minimal odors would be carried to the outdoors and the surrounding neighborhood. 2. Noise pollution. As previously stated, the catering business is one that operates on an intermittent basis. On manv days, there is no activity whatsoever. Deliveries are also minimal, and certainly not daily, since the owners of the business purchase many of the supplies themselves. rn addition, there are only two full-time employees, and a handful of part- time employees. On most days of operation, the employees all leave by 4:00 o'clock since they need to set up their equipment and prepare the food at the site of an evening event. There are no trucks used in the operation of the business, only a van and a station wagon that are the personal vehicles of the owners, thus, these vehicles prods:ce no more noise than any other residential •vehicle in the neigi.,)orhood. Finally, the noise generated by the food preparation activities in this fully air conditioned building is certainly no greater than that of the average family preparing dinner. 3. Pests. Although all refuse is required to be neatly packaged and stored in water -proof and vermin -proof containers at the rear of the building, in fact, since the catering service began operation, most of the wastes have been deposited in a commercial dumpster presently available at another location some blocks away. This is simply a matter of convenience for the owners, since some of the large cardboard boxes fit more easily in the dumpster. Therefore, there are no food wastes to attract rodents and insects, and, in the event wastes are stored on the property, they will be packaged as described above. GREENBERG. TRAURIG. NOFPMAN. LIPOFfr. ROSEN & OUENrEL. P. A. ` 0-OZ 39 0 KI The Honorable July 19, 1989 Page 4 Xavier Suarez 4. Traffic and Parking. Trucks loading food to be delivered, as stated in Mr. Caraballo's letter, -do not exist; the only business vehicles are a van and a station wagon. Deliveries are infreuuent and do not Involve tractor -trailer size trucks, but mostly vans. Deliveries- are intermittent and certainly not a daily occurrence. In addition, since there are only two full- time employees, parkins on the premises is adequate. There are no visiting customers at a catering service business because the catering service comes to the customer, not vice -versa. Moreover, it should be noted that any parking and loading occurs on the western side, of the building, away From Mr. Caraballa's residence on the east. 5. Fire Hazard. Due to the minimum amount of cooking that occurs on the premises, it is unlikely that the catering service operation provides any more fire hazard than if this property was used as a residence. In sum, we believe that the catering service represents a reduction in the intensity of the use of the property `_om -_`:at of the previously existing printing shop, and that the fears of Mr. Caraballo concerning the operation are not justified based on the past two months of its actual operation. In fact, Kr. Caraballo has never complained of any problem to Ms. Sharpe or her husband, nor has Mr. Caraballo even come over to meet his neighbors. We appreciate the opportunity to address Mr. Caraballo's concerns, however, and would welcome the opportunity to -meet with him and intend to attempt to do so. Youjrs very tzul"4, , Stheila Wolfson cc: Mr. Victor de Yurre, Commissioner Ms. Athalie Range, Commissioner Mr. J. L. Plummer, Commissioner Mr. Miller J. Dawkins, Commissioner Mr. Cesar adio, City Manager Mr. Guillermo Olmedillo, Deputy Director of the City of Miami Planning Dept. Mr. Joseph Genuardi, Zoning Administrator sFw/ajc GREENBERG. TRAURIG. HOFFMA.N, LIPOFF, ROSEN & QUENTEL. P. A. ` 0-02,39 / L KA 4 To Whom It May Concern: I am an owner of pry located at and have no objection to the use of cooking facilities for the catering operation located at 3328 S.W. 23 Terrace. :fir. Gillis and Sara Sharpe Catering have been good neighbors and the use is totally compatible with our neighborhood. KA To Whom It May Concern: , I am an owner of property located at and have no objection to the use of cooking facilities for the catering operation located at 3328 S.W. 23 Terrace. Mr. Gillis and Sara Sharpe Catering have been good neighbors and the use is totally compatible with our neighborhood. LA a WEAVER & WI~AVEh GENERAL CONTRACTORS 8425 SW 96th Street MIAMI. FLORIDA 33156 (305) 271.5489 TO Mr. David Gillis 23 Te:.%yce iiiami. ''or;ca r 12n4 OAM OF 26 S r-=-)t 1, 9e9 X! DAY WORK _ CONTRACT . EXTRA J7Y p7Q4 � ]fMTNpIWi — QTY. = AAArTEPJAt. ._•�..._ ...1 . ! DESCa1PTION QF WGM . .;.. .. ; — - e z p ., .. i i - Sav-on Enterprises 1404100 , OTHER CHARGES -. a o,i i 11'*i. I Ri..-c l Aiic.utiT ..T. 7.i(ill?�_ ?ussc'1 �$ T 1 JC;. vU _ I I i TOTAL I.ABOR j a 0 00 TOTAL MAI Ei;,ALS 1 4 7 5 i 4 H `� "—� TOTAL MATERIALS 1475, 48 sjgrw". - I - _. - - ---- -- - --.— I M,IA." .IA;&..J.r.Wjwo ri. •OOr ..Y�i)YiYiiYi W Y1F ..OG..e •'..a.J .tyJ Mw4 TOTAL OTHER r TAX llll TOTAL In WEAVER & WEAVER GENERAL CONTRACTORS 8425 SW 96(n Street MIAM1. FLORIDA 33156 (305) 271.5489 -v )avid Gillis _ -- -328 S . SJ. 23 r errace .-.iami, Florioa 33145 cRMzi. CITY. +rUIEFAL i PIECE i AAAOU tT "c.,Unnev- -�:1JD1Y co. 398 177 Lankford Eauioment Co. ! 60 131 I 52 1262 1Q Seotert4er ` - �� oaoa l"m e. — aTat+t�w ors N.Ars, — i OAY WORK _ :CONTRACT --- - EXTRA �w wia,kuwv i STAKfVQOM. DgSK;FUPTiON OF WORK �I I ff � _.-..RJR MR& RAT; .�..� I 1 t_r .tEAVRR _ _ 10 ! -- - - TOTAL LABOR •tk .fir• c - 1 —. _ _ _ . _ _ .._ iou.. ht.:,.r,..t_ 5 Q —� — —"�`` (`�(ALM#%TMALS }=. I OTAL OTHER TAX ` TOTAL h i - -M'.a*qi'R WEAVER & WEAVER GENERAL CONTRACTORS 8425 SW 96th Street MIAMI. FLORIDA 33156 (305) 271.5489 70 1266 wra+ � onnaranoa� 2 October :lag Czorofim oCe xasn DAY WORK _; CONTRACT Q EXTRA I _Q= "MC AC' . tip''"'" 1 pp �g .ouhm, _ 1'�'-`_ r 1 •. I _ '0 60 ,aundarg Tnteriaxs,I 500100 �ncs porn Z 1 5 7 I I I 914 1 15 i� i � t♦ c7 r YC I � I �- �_iCorp I 276 '50 288116 I ! �nicf nr.7 E;; Hsme d r I 178!40 _ •• L' • �' "` i't� rr�� __ ®THER CHAAGES7 • -- 2 n d o t : , rn j , n.. ., 1' 0 0 1 81 I OVAL UTHE.H I --- — -- --- � .—.. _—•.- � r.., •„,;L. uCtl HAS. I RATE I ' <eAOUho r i iialt:C.. M. _aver 21) 30 63UI James 162� 18 � I ! 1 2`?71 .J I ! I 1 ! I Sri c w,zv—ui — 1'OTAL LA5OR l 927 - �FUTk- bsA (E: i h u i 19 ' — — —. —�-- TOTAL MATERIAL, a i r - -ww vr«x «a.r,w or �. _ � TOTAL OTHER i' tU TAX WrAL j y9 El WEAVER & WEAVER GENERAL CONTRACTORS 8425 SW 96th Street MIAMI. FLORIDA 33156 (305) 271.5489 -0 David Gillis 3328 S .;;. 23 terrace uiami, Florida 33145 .w 1270 �. wku 17 0 tober '_989 DAY WORD CONTRACT EXTRA QTY. MATER AIL I Aft Wff p �tON OF WORK V ! • '7 , — Palmetto metal Fabricators 2561 7 OTHER CHARGES ... iOTALODIER — — TOTAL LABOR .,�,c+ec• n —. _._-- _ —~ TOTAL MATERW4 5 f 1 .�._ - -- -r^ —_TG f AL MAl ERtl64 J TOTAL OT! awitcnwwaY TAX TWAL / •a 4a!I .�j i nprWiW �CwtAWrwV{M gar a+wM�t GWNGNrN�i q if wl wr.-. w s..•M+ ..r. INVOICE LAVIGNE ELECTRIC ASSOCL�TES, INC. - ELECTRICAL CONTRACTORS 2781 S.W. 92nd CT. / Miami. Florida 33165 (305 ) 226-0210 - 1 SARA SHARPE CkTEMG n7C. W. G • 9 9692 -_ 3328 SW 23 Ter=cae Kumi.FL PATE 10/12/89 = - A=1: David; r4 I I i YOUR OROER NO: .wOIIR OONt - PFCWMSS BII=G: - Material and Labor to 10/12/89 =ITR = $2,300.00 LESS DRAW #1 1,485.00 BALANCE $ 815.00 AMOUNT DUE OPM #2 - $8U.00 TERMS: NET • DUE UPON RgClklr'T .0- 0239 AOL INVOICE L.AVIGNE ELECTRIC ASSOCIATES, INC. ELECTRICAL CONTRACTORS 2781 S.W. 92nd CT-1 Miami. Florida 33165 (305) 226-0210 W. O. 9 _ l89?•. Sal SE.U?! CI"F°:IG DATE 3321 SW 23 ?IAAICF SIaI. P:. YOUR ORDER NO: 442-1823 .awK ooti[ :110LIlI03 OF OLO MIIG AID II51IL11ID ODtrF!S !OA ICF IIIC1I11. 31SIll 110 '311R. :ISt1LLFD SWIM AID !L0911SCFIt — ::"�plS. HPSIR'..2' !2) SI IU!S AND CCIDCI'::! all ^.t 19 COISTRQC!IOI. MULLIt SWITC? AID ICF:FI 3FCFPtICLE :I 3Ffi 11!HM. i!!OVED FIPOSFD AIRIIG OI S`M :C:.CIl1. P1.1111SIED -130 I13TILLFD CUMG MIMI :I HT1100K. _ 41 TERMS. NET . DUE UPON RECAUPT �.. 6 '90-0239 INVOICE LAVIGNE ELECTRIC ASSOCIATES, INC. ELECTRICAL CONTRACTORS 2781 S.W. 92nd CT. / Miami, Florida 33165 (303) 226-0210 1 ` W. O. # S A HIM CA".:3:35 GATE YOUR ORDER NO: r; •owx ooH� t !IlBd :C :C5'RAC'.. LO�II:CJA;, i:?:ZG AJ:.�S,RCb :F E000 PASS. 3EP?AC:.:...:AS'. ::! ::prls ;! TERMS. NET . DUE UPON RECEIPT .. MIAMI-DADE VV :R AND SEWER AUTHORITY DEPART ~ NT I NEW BUSINESS OFFICE . AVO I CE 4 : 3840 = P.O BOX 330318 DATE 06/ 12/89 I WANII. FLORIOA 33233.0316 CUSTOMER COPY -44MOUNT OF BILL (per detail below) - �►*#**�173.55 "iNACCOUNT WITH BRIAN BRODEUR 5685 S.W. 85 ST. MIAMI , FL 33143- REFERENCE : 332S S.W. 23 TE. INSTALLATION DESCRIPTION 293-105-36-000 AMOUNTS WATER & SEWER IMPACT FEE. j INC. OF 89 GPD 1 M'At b4ORfl'tel j i i i rWN:,QFFICra WATER CONNECTION CHARGE (GAL.) 293-110-36—,D00 1 SEWER CONNECTION CHARGE (GAL.) 293-110-34-000 i� s93.45 j Torai_ �+ REQUESTED aY : BEVERLY �iUSSANQS PNEPAPED :sY : AR ` 0 -0239 U Pages NO. LAVIGNE ELECTRIC ASSOCIATES, INC. ELECTRICAL. CONTRACTORS 2781 S.W. 92nd CT. / MLAML FLORMA 33165 226-0210 1 of l Pages o suaMtTTEO YO Catm Inc. S,m ari. 443-4399 =6/16/89 ,oe ntAs& 3328 SW 23 Terrace Kitdun . ^T. STATE COOS XW LOTION ��Mjj��,..10MP ACMTECT DATE OF FLMA Jos ArOpl Arh.tects studio I 6/6/89 — . t_ta�..a_tt,ttttat. na note" suamit saeatig.4ans am estimates teu: Inamllation of e1tac= rn1 as per meeting and t�1� =Wer3at2= With mr. David Gillis on 6/15/89. Alan, sheets Alt P1, El, AC1 Wd AC2, d4ted 6/6/89. Quote is are area labeled on sheet Al as *ntd=8 only. 'his includes: 1) Pensi.t. 2) One (1) tmo head battery pack 3) one (1) exit light with batter pack 4) Fight (8) 2 x 4 lay in fixtiues with 1a ops, whips, fuses 1) Lnstallation of supply and exhaust fans by otters 2) lnstailatiaz of hood and an.sul, syst an by ottis Wr f rapusC here" to furnish material ano latx,r — complete in accoraant.e with above specifications. for the gum of: T Thousaw three hur4red dollars and no cents dollars:$ yment to t* mach a► follows: A& twMWWN �f /tWttMiKa to tr d4 *jwau1L AM w iL to ue cwnawws in a .wwn*nb"w NM&# it &"jX6+Ae to rtarVAM" pf"tcCftl. AAy wtMCA+0w oT o..wtww t1QM nnn.. &0"6 "- 41004 tw.+7lnAe "US CMAS .RV O..setV6" WAJV VPPA 9t414110 Y.:Kii. 0" WW 6MCOwH CA aqua Cnafftt am WA iGeM tat e%% ."*. AY *Sreeo .wtl G..wTW/MH wtww ptt.k.r, 6"4" .t. a o.ygt b"b" W'ff wawa. oww ra ca+v, kw. torwso swa DO W wrc.re.:T, .wwtar G. Out wr*M*.re ttw to I** tr, wwwww a CirweCwO&AMW 4^6WA Tt.. Authonftd Signature Note, rtui prapasat may De rn�C..y�y�.�,y` (30) withdrawn by us tl nil) aGl:.Otefa wttNn pays. / Aarpta It of froposai -- Th. at.. arias. apectttcatwns - a+ut t�rrOMr i tirtl tat�stactilry ano am rwrttwf iccatit.til. You ars aWrwra w to 04 tt'te wool& as specwted. Piyrnrww wN be atw" 7asy' nww►w .Ovwe. � _ ..-.....MIAIA .fit.-AC1 Qa§0Kx.-,. S�gnatwe :.� Vic.• -r =•-cam- .., �.... - 0-0239 S+gnaatYtr a. f L IIZ OG tj 0• G• 5GG•C:G� 5G0• C,O� 1.�vG• r;;.. tJG�C�• f G+ 3G- 1 7 3 5 > + :t•3u,• w C • D � +o tJZ 3v•5_ 2,L7C. cc.3rt— 26C- G7+ c�C 36 530• 5- r.15•LC�w t. � L L Ot . / r fM - o 00 tE o• 5CU•CC, 5C0•GO- 3C14 J L 173•:5► , y:.3:�,. 4 • f G 4 t • b y v � G 1 L � ► �i 1,54,7t- LS Ir4 ;� • b t ► 1r1 3C, Z,L7C. .v+ :••4 5C _C:Ect• 260 C i* ? :C • 36 ; 3 t; r 1 5. CC,► �t•CC. t� i LL t- ----------------- -- 10 ............ M, --44 I -A L-T roll," z: 7 14 i I f ��t I I I ��� I� i�� �' � �ib 't4 T'N jo I �NfiRtr rlaUn¢t, r{ n •t)iueronw PURCHASER ;ERVICE FoUirMENT COOO MERG1•oANOISING EOUIPMENT 1300 N. MIAMI AVENUE • MIAM1, FLORIDA 33138 PHONES: I30511 374-7169 •— 374.-3361 MECHANICAL CONTRACTORS STATE LICENSE No..�CAACC.A 083M DATE .S�.f'f,✓� L' � N���l .✓ : /lam ��/ /! f RAt¢if air•..wrirt� cep ar,++• �t li ri�i�lrt.' iup It -At SUPERMARKETS ADDRESS '-�0��7` �2RJ'G - �'o�•g'� ,� ci"J" a -- roe LouTlar, 23,1 aatNferes /��Gf�.,�` hOfOltf iR "PING LATE CUSTOMEflS ORDER NO. i SHIP VIA =0L0 2Y I TERMS NET ^TREK AS P01, QWE DESCRIPTION _,[AV 17 ev/ 1 i% e77- NO ELECTRICITY, CONNECTIONS OR INCLUDED. 1 IfY.I'I.1 �al.l.I�f .•. NO PLUMBING. 6AS FIRE EXTINGUISHING Mt to ., :. I r .. — - L t ul t., ., •.. �f ,f n .•n .Acm....J ....n...r n.,11.. .qJ Ir• I.. o� , :.. n .. .,� ., _. .. fNrr nor,m•u. CGurpn.t e,r .rrau n.•. •.•�^te I.�I ...nl..e I Curl.A4ki • ru(,crly —i c, b1 rt,r,•. — -ft—t� 11• 1' a.J (liam" III ..IJGr Iu 1r:•..,ac., Intro •CCLP'T 6 U SUBJECT TO TERMS ON REVERSE 510E OF C:ONTRA,CT SALES, uSE jr d OTHER TAKLS 5 i FREIGHT & INST+LLATION T I I f ESS DU.: nitN l -•�i l - �a j �.__ Nt r ea,..-f r 1j1.1t (, EIY- AUTHCW"LW iK 444AGNTAnve OA.TB .40-0239 f---�=�=::m.�..3 �~ _ j � f j r r' l R',PC>'r t. r<NT 5f r<:f': PIi r11��1 i1 �311-tt: r� I<=; Sala Dt: 71,ne i'a��� F�ri.cP: 1-64,900 Change Datc-,_ 07/0';89 O )i.��l ( Y.- e_ ,e NarI1Ft '� hiCC 1 �'^`� .___.._ Sharpe, Sara E 1.110 Madrid St. Previous Owners Name Curtis, R 5alisbUl y Fw Clara Land De: c:r i pt ion- --- t..at ~_e: .,100 �,,QFTG Adj Sq Ft: 1,944 `fate Use: 001 Residential, Single Family Zone: 05 -- Single family, 1.201-- Assessriient Land 62,163 Bedrooms 3 Lot : 22 Value Building: 35,250 Bathrooms' 01, Block: 51 Year 1988 Total 97,421 BLIi It - 1925 ___-___._------___--------____------__-.__ Extra F(-:!dl.ure::3 2 - CENT A/C T Sales History Sale Date Price Type Owner Name Current: June 1989 $1614,900•= 1 Sharpe, Sara E Frev1ous: June 1986105,000 1 Earlier: June 1.084 80,000 1 Taxes & Assessment Information ------_--------------- Assessed Value Exemptions District Tax Amounts Land: 67,814 Homestead: Bld : 35,258 Widow Tot - 103,072 Veteran Year: 1988 Disabled: Senior F'rev: 79,870 School Millacge Rate: Exempt Amt: Legal Description Water : 000 Road : 000 Sewer : 000 County: 1,732.83 City - 531.53 Waste : Non -Ex 97 ,421 Lot Size: 2,100 S®FTC; Lot: 22 Block: 51 Coral Gables Granada Sec Lot 2� & S20ft Lot 21 Blk 51 pb 8-1]_3 Lot Size irregular Or 14140-2891 0689 1 ------- •-------------------------- 8 Curti; Salisbury &w Clara Harold Hershenson &w Paula Or 11643--1745 0882 1 Robert Atcherson &w Marjorie Or 11711-82 0283 1 Harold Hershenson &w Paula Or 12137-386 0484 1 Lindsey D Pankey Jr &w Nancy Or 13034--3017 0986 1 Submitted into the public reCOT(I ill cci1jlecti.on vM item l;ic Ly Hirai City Clerk 90-0239 a El L i � 1 7 1 Y } 1 " q a 1 i 4 g i Submitted into the public record in c3nnection vvith matty Hirai City Clerk �10--0131") t r t t AML Submitted into the public iecord in corjj-jccjir_)-j itern l'-' tj oil 1\1 C, t t. Y 1-11 �, a i city Clark 4 Submitted into t1le pul:�lic record in Musty ciiy Clark the P recwd IT . i4f - ? " 7 oll A .�0-0239 0 Suhmitt---d into the pLjjDjlc ioO-ord 'Lll CC-ainection llloflnk�-LL.- on 4 0-0,'�II ,1,39 E 10 �--0'2' 39 Subrnit!c:d into the pul)i' ic record item 90-02k, It ----------- AML M a. F ILO1 "f qvi ?W IBM At k � -0"w) , . 0 06- iw , it'T`1 F OL) MAKE NO A.TTEHtq TO INFLUENCE THE DECISION EXC`FPT TAY DISCl.USSION AT T 4E MEETING: uihould disclose ovally the nature of your conflict in the me"ore before participating. u should eomp4ete the form and file It within 15 days titter the vote occurs with the person reapon%ibie for recording the minutes of the meeting, who should incorporate the form in the minutes. WSOLO SURE OF LOCAL OFFIOER1 IMRIST ,. Miriam Alonso herby disclose that on March�22 19 9O ; (a) A treasure came or will come before my agency which (check one) inured to my special private gain; or inured to the special pin of ._ . by whom I arty retained. W The measure before my agency and the nature of my interest in the measure is as follows: Because Arturo G. Caraballo is the cousin of my deceased father. PZ-4 (R-90-239): Appeal by Arturo G. Car_aballo of Zoning Board's decision to approve the appeal, thereby reversing the decision of the Zoning Administrator, which eliminated cooking on the premises at 3328 S.W. 23 Terrace. Dtte Filed NOTICE: UNDER PROVISIONS OF FLORIDA STATUTES 1112.317 (1915). A FAILURE TO MAKE ANY REQUIRED DISCLOSURE CONSf[TUTES GROUNDS FOR AND MAY 8E PUNISHED BY ONE OR MORE OF THE FOLLOK'ING: _ INIPEACHMENT. REMOVAL OR SUSPENSION FROM OFFICE OR EMPLOYMENT, DEMOTION, REDUCTION IN a SALARY, REPRIMAND, OR A CIVIL PENALTY NOT TO EXCEED 53,000. ({ idltM IB {aN, Signature PAGE ��... FORM OB MEM0( COUNTY, MUNICIPAL LAV MARE-riRST NAME-M1Dulk MANE Alonso, Miriam MAILI$*% ♦DORES% 3500 Pan Hmeri_can Drive = CIT1 C'0VNT Miami Dade DALE ON M HICH VOfE O('t IMED March 22, 1,990 NAME CIF I!( ARLQ COUNCIL, C`iOMMISSrQN, AUTHORITY, OR CQMvl1TTEE City of 14i-ami Comtnissioll THE ROAR01 COI1NCIl CO�AMISSION, AUTHORITY. OR COMMITT wHIC'H I SERVI: is A t1N11 Of: X city :. c'Ovwy • orHER IDC'A1 AGENCY NAML Of POLITIC'A1. 919VIVISJON. - ComI(lissioner MY POSITION is ELECTIVE A�PiDINTIYE 1 X WHO MUST FU FORM This form is for use by any person serving at the county, city, or other local level of government on an appointed or bltcted board, council, commission, authority, or committee. It applies equally to members of advisory and non -advisory bodies who are presented with a voting conflict of interest under Section 112.3143, Florida Statutes. The requirements of this WA amandatory; although rt the use of this particular form is not required by taw, you are encouraged to use it in making the disclosure required by law. —y Your responsibilities under the la% when faced with a measure in which you have a conflict of interest will vary greatly depending on whether you hold an elective or appointive position. For this reason, please pay close attention to the instructions on this form before completing the merse side and filing the form. ;sue INSTRUCTIONS FOR COMPLIANCE WITH SECTION 112.5143, FLORIDA STATUTES ELECTED OFFICERS: A person holding elective count)', municipal, or other local public office MUST ABSTAIN from voting on a measure Nhich inures to his speoal private gain. Each local officer also is prohibited from knowingly voting on a measure which inures to the special gain of a principal (oiher than a government agency) by whom he is retained. In either case, you should disclose the conflict: PRIOR TO THE VOTE BEING TAKEN by publicly stating to thr assembly the nature of your interest in the measure on Mhich you are abstaining from voting; and WITHIN IS DAPS AFTER THE VOTE OCCURS by completing and filing this form with the person responsible for Mcording the minutes of the meeting, who should incorporate the form in the minutes. APPOINTED OFFICERS: A person holding appointive county, municipal, or other local public offset MUST ABSTAIN from voting on a measure which inures to his special private gain. Each local officer also is prohibited from knowingly voting on a measure which inures to the special gain of a principal (other than a government agency) by whom he is retained. A person holding an appointive local office otherwise may participate in a matter in which he has a conflict of interest, but must disclose the nature of the conflict before making any attempt to influence the decision by oral or written communication, whether made b) the officer or at his direction. IF YOU INTEND TO MAKE ANY ATTEMPT TO INFLUENCE THE DLCISION PRIOR TO THE MEETING AT WHICH THE VOTE WILL. BE TAKEN: • You should complete and file this form (before making any attempt to influence the decision) with the person responsible for recording the minutes of the meeting, who will incorporate the form in the minutes. • A copy of the form t hould be provided immediately to the other members of the agency. * The form should be read publicly at the meeting prior to consideration of the matter in which you have a conflict of interest