Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutR-95-0227J-95-234A 3/16/95 RESOLUTION NO. 95- 227 A RESOLUTION, WITH ATTACHMENT(S), AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO ENTER INTO A COLLECTIVE BARGAINING AGREEMENT ("AGREEMENT"), IN SUBSTANTIALLY THE ATTACHED FORM, BETWEEN THE CITY OF MIAMI AND THE EMPLOYEE ORGANIZATION KNOWN AS THE INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF FIREFIGHTERS, LOCAL 587, AFL-CIO, FOR THE PERIOD OF OCTOBER 1, 1995 THROUGH SEPTEMBER 30, 1998, UPON THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS SET FORTH IN THE ATTACHED AGREEMENT. BE IT RESOLVED BY THE COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI, FLORIDA: Section 1. The City Manager is hereby authorized to enter into a Collective Bargaining Agreement ("Agreement"), in substantially the attached form, between the City of Miami and the employee organization known as the International. Association of Firefighters, Local 587, AFL-CIO, for the period of October 1, 1995 through September 30, 1998, upon the terms and conditions set forth in the attached Agreement. Section 2. This Resolution shall become effective immediately upon its adoption. �AT7AC1,1PAE.- N T ti a 9 u Gu CITY COMMISSION MEETING OF MAR 7 7 1995 Resolution No, 95- 227 PASSED AND ADOPTED this 27th day of March , 1995. S PHEN P. CLA , MAYOR PREPARED AND APPROVED BY: RAMON IRIZA I ASSISTANT ITY ATTORNEY APPROVED AS TO FORM AND CORRECTNESS: At QU NN J I I CITY ATTO Y Rl:osk:M5003 95- 22'7 i -2- i AGREEMENT BETWEEN CITY OF MIAMI, FLORIDA AND INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF FIREFIGHTERS, AFL-CIO LOCAL 587 OCTOBER 1, 1995 THROUGH SEPTEMBER 30, 1998 95- 227 4 AGREEMENT . . . . . . . AGREEMENT IN.EVENT OF TRANSFER . APPENDIX A . . . . . . . . . . . . APPENDIX B . . . . . . . . . . . . BLOOD DONORS . . . . . . . . BULLETIN BOARDS. . . . . . . . . . CALL BACK PAY . . . . . . . . . . . CONSTANT STAFFING. . . . . . . . . DEATH IN FAMILY . . . . . . . . . . DISCRIMINATION . . . . . . . . . . EARNED PERSONAL LEAVE (FH TIME). . EDUCATION . . . . . . . . . . . . EMPLOYEE RIGHT TO REPRESENTATION . FAMILY LEAVE AND LEAVES OF ABSENCE GRIEVANCE PROCEDURE. . . . . . . . GROUP INSURANCE. . . . . . . . . . HOLIDAYS/VACATION/SICK TIME. . . . HOURS OF WORK . . . . . . . . . . . LINE OF DUTY INJURIES. . . . . . . LOSS OF EQUIPMENT. . . . . . . . . MANAGEMENT RIGHTS. . . . . . . . . NO STRIKE . . . . . . . . . . . . . NOTICES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . OVERTIME . . . . . . . . . . . . . PARITY . . . . . . . . . . . . . PENSION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . PERSONNEL ALLOCATION . . . . . . . PHYSICAL EXAMINATIONS. . . . . . . PREVAILING BENEFITS. . . . . . RECOGNITION. . . . . . . . . . . . REPRESENTATION OF THE CITY . . . . REPRESENTATION OF THE UNION. . . . RESIDENCY . . . . . . . . . . . . . REVENUE INCENTIVE PAY. . . . . . . SAFETY COMMITTEE . . . . . . . . . SAFETY SHOES . . . . . . . . . . . SAVINGS PROVISION. . . . . . . . . SHIFT EXCHANGE . . . . . . . . . . SHIFT STRENGTH . . . . . . . . . . SPECIAL MEETINGS . . . . . . . . . STATION COMMANDERS . . . . . . . . SUBSTANCE/ALCOHOL - PERSONNEL SCREENING . . . . . . TERMINATION AND MODIFICATION . . . TOTAL AGREEMENT. . . . . . . . . . TRANSITION . . . . . . . . . . . . UNION BUSINESS . . . . . . . . . . UNION REPRESENTATIVES. . . . . . . VACANCIES - PROMOTIONS . . . . . . WAGES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . WORKING OUT OF CLASSIFICATION. . . .W, 1 . . . 41 67 80 . . . 81 . . . 30 48 11 13 21 34 . 36 59 . . . 27 45 . 4 6 . . . 24 40 . . . 26 43 . . . 34 60 . . . 25 41 . . . 15 19 . . . 17 26 . . . 23 36 . . . 32 57 . . . 12 13 . 29 47 . 6 7 . 2 1 . 8 8 . . . 20 32 . . . 19 32 . . . 43 68 . . . 33 59 . . . 28 47 . 5 6 . 1 1 . 39 66 . 40 66 . 35 63 . . . 44 73 . . . 13 16 . . . 16 25 , . . 42 67 . 9 9 . . . 36 63 . . . 14 17 . . . 37 65 . . . 31 48 . . . 46 77 . . . 38 65 . . . 45 76 . 3 2 . 7 8 . . . 10 10 . 18 27 . 22 35 95- 227 AGREEMENT THIS AGREEMENT is entered into by the CITY OF MIAMI, FLORIDA, a municipal corporation, hereinafter referred to as the City, and the INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF FIREFIGHTERS, LOCAL #587, hereinafter referred to as the Union. It is the intention of this Agreement to provide for wages, fringe benefits and other terms and conditions of employment. It is further the intention of this Agreement to prevent interruption of work and interference with efficient operation of the City of Miami and to provide for an orderly, prompt and just manner of handling grievances. ARTICLE 1 RECOGNITION 1.1 The City hereby recognizes the Union as the.sole and exclusive bargaining agent for all persons in the Fire Department within the following classifications Firefighter, Fire Lieutenant, Fire Captain, and Chief Fire Officer. Excluded are all other employees and classifications, and specifically excluded are: Fire Chief, Assistant Fire Chief, Director of Training, Chief of Fire Prevention, Chief of Rescue, Battalion Chief, and Executive Assistant to Fire Chief. ARTICLE 2 NO STRIKE 2.1 "Strike" means the concerted failure to report for duty, the concerted absence of employees from their positions, 95- 22'7 _1_ the concerted stoppage of work, the concerted submission of resignations, the concerted abstinence in whole or in part by any group of employees from the full and faithful performance of their duties of employment with the City, participation in a deliberate and concerted course of conduct which adversely affects the services of the City, or picketing in furtherance of a work stoppage either during the term of the Collective Bargaining Agreement or after the expiration of a Collective Bargaining Agreement. 2.2 Neither the Union, nor any of its officers or agents, nor members covered by this Agreement, nor any other employees covered by this Agreement, will instigate, promote, sponsor, or engage in any strike, sympathy strike, slowdown, concerted stoppage of work, picketing in support of a work stoppage, or any other activity which prohibits an employee from reporting for duty. .ARTICLE 3 UNION BUSINESS An employee organization time pool is hereby authorized subject to the following; 3.1 The City agrees to establish a one time pool bank of three thousand six hundred (3,600) hours per fiscal year to be used in accordance with the provisions of this Article and during the term of this Agreement. All unused hours will be carried over to the following fiscal year. 95- 22'7 -2- 3.2 For each bargaining unit member, except the Employee Organization President, who is authorized to use time from the time pool, the President or his designee shall fill out the appropriate form as provided by the City. This form shall be processed through channels of the bargaining unit member who is to use the pool time. The form will be processed as soon as possible and when possible will be in the office of the Fire Chief seven (7) calendar days prior to the time the employee has been authorized to use the pool time. 3.3 Bargaining unit members shall be released from duty on pool time only if the needs of the service permit, but such release shall not be unreasonably denied. If because of the needs of the service a bargaining unit member cannot be released at -the time desired, the Employee Organization may request an alternate bargaining unit member be released from duty during the desired time. 3.4 Employee Organization Time Pool hours will be used on an hour for hour basis, regardless of the hourly rate of the bargaining unit member using Time Pool time. In reporting a bargaining unit member's absence as a result of utilizing the Organization Time Pool, the daily attendance record shall reflect: "John Doe on EUP" (Union Time Pool) 3.5 Any injury received or any accident incurred by a bargaining unit member whose time is being paid for by the Employee Organization Time Pool, or while engaged in activities paid for by the Employee Organization Time Pool, shall not be 9 5 - 227 -3- ;19., considered a line -of -duty injury, nor shall such injury or accident be considered to have been incurred in the course and scope of his employment by the City within the meaning of Chapter 440, Florida Statutes as amended. This section shall not include benefits attainable through F.S. 112.181. 3.6 Upon written request through channels, only the Employee Organization President will be released for the term of , this Agreement from his or her regularly assigned duties for the City of Miami Fire Department. The terms of this Agreement for such release are only to be implemented if the following qualifications are met by the Employee Organization: (a) The Local 587 President will reasonably be available at the Local 587 Office currently located at 2980 N.W. South River Drive, Miami, Florida, 33125, for consultation with the Management of the City. (b) The Employee Organization President shall be the only Bargaining Unit representative released on "EUP" time to appear before any City Board or Commission. In the absence of the President, the President's designee may represent the Employee Organization; however, the designee must comply with Section 2 of this Article. (c) The Time Pool will be charged for all hours during which the Employee Organization President is on off - duty release except that absence due to use of vacation leave, compensatory leave, sick leave, or holidays will be charged to the President's employee 95-r 227 -4- P911 accounts. The Employee Organization President shall not be eligible for overtime or compensatory time, unless performing work in excess of the normal work week for the Fire Department in his/her civil service classification. 3.7 All applicable rules, regulations and orders shall apply to any bargaining unit member on time pool release. Violations of the above -mentioned rules, regulations and orders shall subject the bargaining unit member on pool time to the regular disciplinary processes currently provided for in the Miami Fire Department. 3.8 The City reserves the right to rescind the provisions of this Article in the event any portion of the Article is found to be illegal. Cancelling the Article shall not preclude further negotiations of future employee pool time. 3.9 Each bargaining unit member covered by this Agreement may voluntarily contribute vacation time to the Time Pool in 12-hour increments. 3.10 Each bargaining unit member who wishes to donate time will use a time pool donation form which will be provided by the City. This form shall include language releasing the City from any and all liability to pay for vacation time contributed by the bargaining unit member to the Time Pool. 3.11 The Union will be allowed up to three (3) bargaining unit member representatives who shall be permitted to participate in labor contract negotiation sessions while on duty with no loss of pay or emoluments. 95— 22'7 min for, ARTICLE 4 DISCRIMINATION 4.1 No employee covered by this Agreement will be discriminated against with regard to any job benefits or other_ conditions of employment accruing from this Agreement because of race, creed, national origin, union membership or sex. 4.2 All references in this Agreement to employees of the male gender are used for convenience only and shall be construed to include both male and female employees. 4.3 The Union agrees to support the City's current Affirmative Action Programs and any other similar affirmative action programs affecting Fire Department personnel which may be developed by the City in negotiations with the Union. 4.4 The City and Union agree to support Affirmative Action programs and any mandates of a court of proper jurisdiction that are designed to bring minority candidates up to the standard required for the Fire service or other such programs which are consistent with applicable law. ARTICLE 5 PREVAILING BENEFITS 5.1 Job benefits heretofore authorized by the City Manager, continuously enjoyed by all employees covered by this Agreement and not specifically provided for or abridged by this Agreement, shall continue upon the conditions by which they had been previously granted. 95- 22'7 M 5.2 This Agreement shall not be construed to deprive any employee of benefits or protection granted by the laws of the State of Florida, ordinances of the City of Miami, or resolutions of the City of Miami in effect at the time of execution of this Agreement. 5.3 The City and the Union will meet at the request of the City to negotiate any proposed changes in those rights and benefits not specifically covered by the Agreement, provided however no changes shall be made in the language or intent of this Agreement except by mutual consent. 5.4 However, nothing in this Article shall prevent the City from implementing the terms of the current Consent Decree or any future legal mandates placed upon the City by applicable laws. ARTICLE 6 MANAGEMENT RIGHTS 6.1 It is understood and agreed that the City possesses the sole right to operate the Fire Department and that all management rights are expressly reserved to the City of Miami, but that such rights must be exercised consistent* with the provisions of this Agreement. These rights include, but are not limited to, the following: discipline or discharge for just cause; direction and supervision of all personnel; the hiring, the assignment or transfer of employees; determination of the mission and objective of the Fire Department; determination of the methods, means, and number of personnel needed to carry out 95- 22"7 -7- the Fire Department's missions and objectives; introduction of new or improved methods or facilities; and scheduling of operation and shifts. ARTICLE 7 UNION REPRESENTATIVES 7.1 Representatives of the Union who are not employees of the City shall be certified in writing to the City Manager. Certified representatives may be allowed to meet with individual employees on City property during working hours to carry on normal business of the Union, if the Fire Chief has prior knowledge of such activity and such visitation does not interfere with efficient operations. ARTICLE 8 NOTICES 8.1 The City agrees, to make available to the President of the Union the following notices or bulletins: City Commission Agenda; changes or additions to the City Administrative Policy Manual and the Personnel Policy Manual; Budget Estimate as distributed by the City Manager to the City Commission --which shall include the Fire Department estimate. Such notices or bulletins will be picked up by a Union representative at the Labor Relations Office during normal work hours, or be transmitted through the interoffice mail to a Fire Station designated by the Union President. 95- 22'7 ARTICLE 9 SHIFT EXCHANGE 9.1 Employees shall have the right to exchange shifts under the following circumstances: A) He may owe up to five (5) shifts at any one time including "R" days. B) He may be owed up to five (5) shifts at any one time including "R" days. C ) Employees may exchange time but in no event will an exchange of time result in the employee working in excess of two consecutive tours of duty. D) Trading of time must be done voluntarily by the employees. E) The reason for the shift exchange is not related to City business. F) The period during which time is traded and paid back does not exceed twelve months. G) The City incurs no overtime obligation as a result of the shift exchange. H) 1) Exchange of time shall not occur between firefighters and officers. 2) Exchanges of time between officers within the Emergency Response Division may occur at the same rank, at one (1) rank below, or at one (1) rank above, the officer's rank. 3) With the restrictions set forth above, personnel assigned to Advanced Life Support positions may 95- 22'7 exchange time with personnel who are state certified paramedics. ARTICLE 10 VACANCIES - PROMOTIONS 10.1 When a classified permanent promotional vacancy occurs in any position it shall be filled within a reasonable period of time after the official severance of the vacating Fire Department member. Filling of all vacancies shall be in accordance with the Civil Service Rules and Regulations, so long as they are not inconsistent with provisions of this Agreement. All vacancies shall be filled from the promotional register in effect at the time the vacancy occurs. If a promotional register is -not in effect, vacancies will be filled from the next promotional register. Promotions will be to the effective date of vacancy for the classified position.. For pay purposes, if the City fails to promote within thirty (30) calendar days from the effective date of the vacancy, retroactive pay shall be paid beginning thirty one (31) days from the effective date of the vacancy. 10.2 This provision shall not apply when a 'freeze is declared by the City Manager or the position is abolished. Once a freeze is lifted, vacancies shall be filled as outlined in 10.1. 10.3 The Department of Personnel Management will keep the members of the bargaining unit covered by this Agreement advised as to promotional opportunities to positions within Article 1 -- Recognition . 9 5 _ 227 -10- 10.4 Further, the Personnel Management Department Director will advise eligible applicants for promotional opportunities of the general area to be reviewed for preparation prior to the exam. 10.5 The Fire Department Book Review Committee will review and discuss books and technical publications they deem worthy of consideration by the Personnel Management Department for testing purposes. The Personnel Management Department and the Book Review Committee or its representative shall meet and discuss the books, materials, scoring procedures, weights of books, etc. to be used in the promotional examinations for all positions covered by this collective bargaining agreement. Such input from the Book Review Committee will be received and considered by the Personnel Management Department, but should not be binding on its usage by the Personnel Management Department. 10.6 All promotional registers for Lieutenant, Captain and Chief Fire Officer shall -remain in effect for a period of two (2) years from the date the register becomes effective, unless the register is exhausted. 10.7 Promotional examinations for classified bargaining unit positions shall be given as soon as possible after the expiration of the previous promotional register for the classified position. The cutoff date to determine seniority and eligibility for the examination will be the first day the examination is administered provided the examination is administered within thirty (30) days of the expiration of the previous promotional register. If_ the examination is 95- 227 -11- administered later than thirty (30) days from the expiration of the previous promotional register, the cutoff date for seniority and eligibility shall be thirty (30) days from the expiration date of the previous promotional register. The effective date for new promotional registers will be thirty (30) calendar days from the expiration date of the previous promotional register for the classified position, regardless of when the test was given. 10.8 Promotional registers for Lieutenant, Captain and Chief Fire Officer taking effect after the ratification of this Agreement, shall have ties broken using seniority credit that was not previously used in calculating the seniority score for the exam. If a tie still exists, it shall be broken in favor of the highest ranking Firefighter on the Department seniority list for the -Lieutenants, register, or the highest ranking Officer on the appropriate seniority in grade list for the Captains' or Chief Fire Officers' register. 10.9 Effective upon, ratification of this Agreement, except where prevented by Federal law or Federal mandate, qualified applicants who are State certified as a Firefighter or State certified as a Paramedic, may be given consideration before other applicants for employment as determined by the Fire Chief. 10.10 The parties intend to include in the next collective bargaining agreement, a requirement that firefighters be a State certified Paramedic and pass the Fire Department driver/engineer course to be eligible to take a Lieutenants promotional examination. 95- 227 WPM ARTICLE 11 BULLETIN BOARDS 11.1 The City shall furnish at each Fire station, Fire Prevention Bureau, Fire College, Fire Central Information Office, Headquarters Building, and Fire Chief's Office, space for bulletin boards for the purpose of Union notices. Material posted shall be subject to review by the Fire Chief or his designee. Any notice placed on the bulletin board shall bear on its face the legible designation of the person responsible for placing such notice or item on the board. 11.2 Notices shall not contain anything reflecting adversely on the City or any of its officers and no material, notices or announcements which violate the provisions of this Article shall be posted. 11.3 Notices posted must be dated and bear the signature of the Union President or his authorized representative. ARTICLE 12 LINE OF DUTY INJURIES 12.1 The City agrees to pay all medical and hospitalization expenses incurred by any employee covered by this Agreement who is found to have sustained a compensable line - of -duty injury as provided for by the Worker's Compensation Law of the State of Florida. 12.2 The City agrees that any employee covered under this contract who is disabled as a result of any accident, injury or illness incurred in line of duty shall be granted supplementary 95- 227 -13- salary of which a part thereof is Worker's Compensation as provided by Resolution No. 39802, provided however no supplementary salary will be paid to anyone injured while performing an act intended to injure or hurt one's self or another. Supplementary salary shall only be granted for a period of one hundred fifty (150) consecutive days from the date of injury. Said supplementary salary may be extended up to an ' additional sixty (60) consecutive days for serious injuries upon approval of the City Manager and the Fire Chief. The one hundred fifty (150) days being when the employee is actually placed on "D". While the employee is on "D", such time will be calculated consecutively including days off, "R" days, etc. If the employee is removed from "D", the non-"D" time will not apply to the one hundred fifty (150) days period. 12.3 If an accident has been declared compensable by the City and the employee brings litigation without having first discussed with personnel of -the Claims Division of the City of Miami, concerning any controversy arising out of the declared compensable accident, then the supplementary salary, as provided by Resolution No. 39802, shall cease. 12.4 In the event that litigation is filed by an employee following his return to work without having first met with and discussed with personnel of the Claims Division of the City of Miami, concerning any controversy arising out of his declared compensable accident, it is agreed between the parties that the previously described supplementary salary shall be recouped from the employee's current salary by way of payroll deductions, the 95- 227 --14 -- extent of subsequent payroll deductions shall not exceed 25% of the gross pay per pay period. If the Claims Division of the City of Miami, does not resolve any controversy arising out of a compensable injury to the satisfaction of the injured employee, then the supplemental salary as provided by Resolution No. 39802 shall not be jeopardized if litigation is subsequently filed by the employee. 12.5 In the event an employee desires the presence of an attorney to discuss a controversy with representatives of the Claims Division of the City of Miami, the parties agree that the attorney shall receive a token fee for his presence of $75.00 per hour, not to exceed $150.00. 12.6 The City agrees to notify and confer with the Union prior to any official action regarding the discontinuance of any supplemental salary benefit related to a. line -of -duty injury. 12.7 Any condition or impairment of health caused by Acquired Immunity Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS), Hepatitis, Pulmonary Tuberculosis, or Meningococcal Meningitis shall be presumed to have been accidental and to have been suffered in the line of duty unless the contrary be shown by satisfactory evidence. Effective upon ratification of the labor 'agreement, any employee covered by this agreement who refuses to take the pre -employment (post conditional offer of employment) medical examination and all of its components relating to the presumptions within this article, shall not be entitled to the presumption outlined in this section and Florida Statutes 112.18. -15- 95- 227 jig:. The presumption in favor of employees referred to in this section shall not apply to any other contagious diseases which may be contracted by employees. Furthermore, the presumption shall only be applicable to worker's compensation and disability pension benefit determinations. Nothing in this section shall be construed as a waiver of the City's rights under , applicable state law. :ARTICLE 13 SAFETY COMMITTEE 13.1 There shall be a Safety Committee in the City of Miami Fire Department which shall consist of nine (9) members. Four (4) members shall be appointed by the Union and four (4) shall be appointed by the Chief of the Fire Department. A member from the Risk Management Department shall be appointed as the ninth non -voting member by the Chief of the Fire Department upon confirmation by the Union President. The ninth non -voting member may be replaced upon a 50% vote of the voting members of the Safety Committee. 13.2 The Safety Committee shall meet bimonthly, or more or less often by mutual consent, and such meeting' shall be scheduled at the time established by the Chief of the Fire Department. The Chief of the Fire Department, or his designee, shall preside at all meetings. 13.3 The purpose of these meetings will be to discuss problems and objectives of mutual concern, concerning safety and health conditions of the Fire Department, but excluding -16- 95- 227 j,s:. grievances or matters which are the subject of collective bargaining negotiations between the parties. 13.4 Meetings shall be conducted on a semi -formal basis following an agenda which shall include items submitted by any member of the Committee to the Chief of the Fire Department at least five (5) working days prior to the meeting, together with such information as may be helpful in preparing a meaningful meeting agenda program. The agenda shall be provided each member of the Committee. The Chief of the Fire Department shall arrange for minutes to be taken of each meeting, and for distribution of copies to each member of the Committee. Recommendations of the Committee may be sent to the City Manager or his designee if requested by a member of the Committee. 13.5 Agended issues and subsequent discussions on the subject of safety and health shall not limit or preclude the right of the Union to seek enforcement of safety requirements under the Occupational Safety. and Health Act, if applicable. :ARTICLE 14 SPECIAL MEETINGS 14.1 The City and the Union agree to meet and' confer on matters of interest upon the written request of either party. The written request shall state the nature of the matters to be discussed and the reason(s) for requesting the meeting. Discussion shall be limited to matters set forth in the request, but it is understood that these special meetings shall not be used to renegotiate this .Agreement. Special meetings shall be 95- 227 -17- 0. held within ten (10) calendar days of the receipt of the written request and shall be held between 8:00 a.m. and 5:00 p.m. at a time designated by the City. The Union shall be represented by not more than four (4) persons at special meetings. 14.2 Employee representatives of the Union at special meetings will be paid by the City for time spent in special meetings if on duty, but only for the straight time hours they would otherwise have worked on their regular work schedule. For the purpose of computing overtime, time spent in special meetings shall be considered as hours worked to the extent of the regular work schedule hours which they otherwise would have worked. 14.3 No special meeting shall be held unless the Fire Chief is notified in advance and approves the arrangements made for• releasing any on -duty Firefighter who is to attend such meeting. 14.4 The parties agree to participate in the Labor/ Management process as currently established. The Labor/ Management process is an ongoing tool for addressing and solving issues and problems concerning the Union, the Department and the City. Issues are dealt with as they arise and do not require the formalities of reopening negotiations. Any agreements made that have an economic impact on the City must be approved by the City Manager or his designee. It is agreed this process complies with and is an extension of Article 14, as the Labor/Management process applies to collective bargaining. 95- 227 ARTICLE 15 GRIEVANCE PROCEDURE 15.1 A grievance is defined as a dispute involving the interpretation or application of the specific provisions of this Agreement, except as exclusions are noted in other articles of this Agreement. 15.2 A grievance shall refer to the specific provision or provisions of the Agreement alleged to have been violated. Any grievance not conforming to the provisions of this paragraph or that contains non -identification of a specific article(s) of this agreement shall be denied and not eligible to advance through the steps of the Grievance Procedure including arbitration. Grievances involving Workers' Compensation are not subject to this Agreement, except that a question concerning supplemental salary may properly be processed as set forth in the Article entitled "Line of Duty Injuries." 15.3 To simplify the. Grievance Procedure, the number of "working days" in presenting a grievance and receiving a reply from the different levels of supervision shall be based upon a forty (40) hour, five (5) day, work week, Monday through Friday, except for personnel assigned to a twenty --four (24) hour shift, in which case a work day for the filing of a Step 1 grievance shall consist of twelve (12) working hours. 15.4 All employees covered by this Agreement shall be required to make a written Election of Remedy prior to filing any grievance at Step 2 or higher steps or initiating action for redress in any other forum. Such choice of remedy will be made 95- 22'7 -19- wg., in writing on a form to be supplied by the City. Any employee electing a remedy other than this grievance procedure shall be denied the use of the Grievance Procedure for the resolution of this specific grievance. The Union and its members agree that the appeal to any other forum to resolve an issue that would otherwise be subject to this grievance procedure under this Agreement would preclude the use of said Grievance Procedure to resolve such alleged grievanle issues. 15.5 Nothing in this Article shall prevent the Union from appearing before the City Commission or other City boards on matters concerning the terms and conditions of employment or on any matter affecting the welfare of its members, and such shall not•be considered as an election of remedy under this Article. However, such appearance by the Union shall not be in violation of Florida Statutes, Chapter 447.501 (2), (a), (b), (c). 15.6 Grievances shall be processed in accordance with the following procedure; Step 1. The aggrieved employee shall discuss the grievance with his immediate officer within five (5) working days of the occurrence which gave rise to the grievance. The Union representative may be present to represent the employee, if the employee desires him present. The immediate officer shall attempt to adjust the matter and/or respond to the employee within five (5) working days. 95- 22'7 -20- Where a grievance is general in nature in that it applies to a number of employees having the same issue to be decided, or if the grievance is directly between the Union and the City, it shall be presented directly at Step 3 of the Grievance Procedure, within the time limits provided for the submission of a grievance in Step 1 and signed by the aggrieved employees or the Union representative on their behalf. All grievances must be processed within the time limits herein provided unless extended by mutual agreement in writing. Any grievance not processed by the Union in accordance with the time limits provided in each step of the Article shall be considered conclusively abandoned. Any grievance not processed by the City within the time limits provided herein shall be automatically advanced to the next higher step in the Grievance Procedure. Step 2. If the Grievance has not been satisfactorily resolved, the aggrieved employee or employees shall meet with the Union Grievance Committee on non -City time and non -City property and the Union Grievance Committee shall determine if a grievance exists. If the Grievance Committee decides to advance the Grievance, a Union representative shall reduce the grievance to writing on the standard form provided by the City for this purpose and present such written grievance to the Fire Chief within forty (40) calendar days from the date the Step 1 answer was given to the grievant or the Union. The Fire 95-- 227 -21 V-419• Chief shall meet with the Union representative and shall respond to the Union in writing within five (5) working days from receipt of the written grievance. Within the forty (40) calendar day time frame as outlined above, the Union shall notify the Fire Chief in writing of the nature of the grievance; what specific provision(s) were allegedly violated; whether the Union will advance the grievance; and the date on which the grievant was advised of the Committee's decision. If the Union decides not to advance the grievance, the grievant must submit a written grievance to the Fire Chief within three (3) calendar days of the date on which he was advised by the Union of its position or the grievance shall be considered abandoned. The panties agree, however, that nothing in this section shall be construed to prevent a member of the bargaining unit from presenting his grievance to the public employer and have such grievance adjusted without the intervention of the bargaining agent, if the adjustment is not inconsistent with the terms of the Collective Bargaining Agreement then in effect. The bargaining agent will be given a reasonable opportunity to be present at any meeting between the grievant and the City representatives for the resolution of said grievance. All of the above must be consistent with the time frames described in the various steps of the Grievance Procedure as outlined herein. 95- 22'7 -22- Step If the Grievance has not been satisfactorily resolved in Step 2, the Union may present a written appeal to the City Manager within seven (7) working days from the time the response was due in Step 2. The City Manager or his designee shall meet with the Union representative and he shall respond in writing to the Union within ten (10) working days from the receipt of appeal. Step 4. If the Grievance has not been satisfactorily resolved at the Step 3 level of •the Grievance Procedure, the Union or an individual bargaining unit grievant may request a review by an impartial arbitrator provided such request is filed in writing with the City Manager no later than fifteen (15) working days after the City Manager's response is due in Step 3 of the Grievance Procedure. 15.7 The parties to this Agreement will attempt to mutually agree upon an independent Arbitrator. If this cannot be done, one will be selected from a panel or panels to be submitted by the American Arbitration Association. The cost of said panel(s) shall be shared equally by the parties. Alternatively, the parties may mutually agree to select an Arbitrator from a panel(s) submitted by the FMCS. 15.8 The arbitration shall be conducted under the rules set forth by the American Arbitration Association on this subject except that Rules 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 (b) , 8, 9, 12, 14, 15, 16, 21, 25, 42, and 43 shall not be applicable or utilized by the Arbitrator. Subject to the following, the Arbitrator shall have jurisdiction and authority to decide a grievance as defined in 95- 227 -23- this Agreement. The Arbitrator shall have no authority to change, amend, add to, subtract from or otherwise alter or supplement this Agreement or any part thereof or any amendment thereto. The .Arbitrator shall have no authority to consider or rule upon any matter which is stated in this Agreement not to be subject to arbitration or which is not a grievance as defined in ' this Agreement, or which is not specifically covered by this Agreement; nor shall this Collective Bargaining Agreement be construed by an arbitrator to supersede applicable laws in existence at the time of signing this Agreement. 15.9 The Arbitrator may not issue declaratory or advisory opinions and shall confine himself exclusively to the question which is presented to him, which question must be actual and existing. 15.10 It is contemplated that the City and the Union mutually agree in writing as to the statement of the matter to be arbitrated prior to hearing.. When this is done, the Arbitrator shall confine his decision to the particular matter thus specified. When the parties are unable to agree, the Arbitrator shall decide the issue or issues to be arbitrated. 15.11 Each party shall bear the expense of its own witnesses and of its own representatives. The parties shall bear equally the expense of the impartial arbitrator. The party desiring a transcript of the hearing will bear the cost of same. 15.12 Copies of the award of the arbitration made in accordance with the jurisdiction or authority under this Agreement shall be furnished to both parties within thirty (30) 95- 227 -24- days of the hearing and shall be final and binding on both parties. ARTICLE 16 SAFETY SHOES 16.1 The City shall reimburse bargaining unit employees up to $75 for the purchase of an initial pair of safety shoes or the replacement of same due to job related wear and tear or accidental destruction. To receive this allowance, the employee will present the purchased shoes and the bill of sale to a management representative. Safety shoes paid for by the City shall only be worn when on Fire Department business, including reporting to and from work. 16.2 The Chief of the Fire Department or his designee shall determine when, in his judgment, a pair of safety shoes shall be issued as replacement. Safety shoes shall be issued on the basis of need and not on -an automatic basis. Any bargaining unit member requesting the replacement of more than one (1) pair of safety shoes during a calendar year shall satisfactorily demonstrate in writing on a form provided by the City that the replacement of said safety shoe is necessary due to job related wear and tear or accidental destruction. 16.3 Employees who work in positions of which safety shoes are not required shall not be eligible for a shoe allowance. 16.4 The shoe standard as administered in the past must be met to qualify for the reimbursement. 5 ` 22 7 --25- �:. ARTICLE 17 GROUP INSURANCE 17.1 The City agrees to pay $5.26 per pay period for the cost of life insurance coverage and accidental death and dismemberment coverage as currently provided by the IAFF, Local 587. 17.2 Effective as soon as possible after ratification of this Article, employee premiums shall be tax exempt under Section 125 of the IRS code. In the event this exemption is eliminated in the IRS code during the life of this agreement, Article 17 shall be reopened and the parties shall meet to negotiate any changes necessitated by the loss of the tax exemption. 17.3 The pay period in which the payment of health insurance premiums on a pre-tax basis is implemented, employees will contribute $18.00 per pay period toward the cost of employee health coverage or $88.00 per pay period toward the cost of family coverage, where the employee elects to take such coverage for point of service plan. 17.4 The pay period in which the payment of health insurance premiums on a pre-tax basis is implemented, employees shall contribute $10.00 per pay period toward the cost of employee health coverage or $50.00 per pay period toward the cost of family coverage, where the employee elects to take such coverage for the closed HMO plan. 1.7.5 Plan design and all plan benefits shall be those outlined within the employees benefits handbook and shall not be changed without mutual agreement of the City and the Union. 95- 227 -26- 4., 17.6 A standing committee will be created called the Health Insurance Committee. It shall be made up of five (5) City of Miami employees, one member appointed by the IAFF, one member appointed by AFSCME, two members appointed by the City Manager and one picked by mutual agreement of the IAFF, AFSCME and the City Manager. The Group Benefits Administrator shall serve as a technical advisor to the committee, but will not be a member nor have a vote. The committee shall meet monthly or as needed to review employee complaints, suggestions, etc. The committee shall have the authority by majority vote, to remedy situations concerning claims, so long as the decision does not change the current benefits. The committee may make recommendations on benefit changes that would save the plan(s) money, to the City and the Union for immediate consideration of the parties. The committee is intended to reduce the need for the grievance procedure and to, suggest new ideas in providing a better and more efficient health insurance system. The parties agree, however, that employees bringing complaints to the committee shall be entitled to use the grievance procedure if the committee's remedy, if any, is not satisfactory to the'employee. ARTICLE 18 WAGES 18.1 The City agrees to increase the wage rates in accordance with the following schedule. The increases will be effective on the first day of the first full pay period following the dates indicated. 95- 227 -27- January 1, 1997 - 4% October 1, 1997 - Reopener 18.2 Those employees hired after September 27, 1993, who are not rehired firefighters as outlined in this Article, shall be hired at 10% below Step 1 and shall remain at 10% below the Step 1 rate for a period of six (6) months. Upon completion of the six (6) month period, the Fire fighterfprobationary employee shall be paid as reflected in Step 1 of the appropriate appendix, whichever is applicable. 18.3 A sixteen (16) and twenty one (21) year longevity half step of 2.5 percent each, will be implemented effective the first full. pay period following October 1, 1994. The sixteen (16) and twenty one (21) year longevity will be granted in the same manner as the ten (10), fifteen (15) and twenty (20) year longevity steps. 18.4 In lieu of an across-the-board pay raise for fiscal year 1993-94, and continuing thereafter, employees shall upon retirement (all kinds, including vesting), receive a retroactive salary increase of five percent (5%) for the employee's last or highest one (1) year's salary. The five percent (5%) salary increase' shall be reflected in the hourly pay rate for the purpose of calculating leave balance payoffs. The five percent (5%) salary increase shall not be applicable to overtime. 18.5 Effective the first full pay period following October 1, 1993, active bargaining unit members shall receive Fire Prevention pay in the amount of $76.92 biweekly. Fire 95- 227 Prevention pay shall be subject to pension deductions and applicable federal taxes and shall be included in calculating an employee's average earnings for pension purposes. All hours of leave of absence without pay shall be deducted from the Fire Prevention payment on the basis of $.96 per hour for forty (40) hour employees, $.92 per hour for forty two (42) hour employees, $.80 per hour for forty eight (48) hour employees and $.74 per hour for fifty two (52) hour employees. 18.6 Effective the first full pay period following October 1, 1993, the EMT pay supplement and any pay supplements not equivalent to a five percent (5%) pay step shall be paid to the eligible employee as a separate pay item. 18.7 Effective September 27, 1993, any City of Miami employee, unless a former fire bargaining unit employee as specified in 18.8, that transfers or is hired as a firefighter into the Fire Department as a uniformed bargaining unit employee shall be placed at the firefighter wage rate as specified above in Section 18.2. 18.8 Former fire bargaining unit employees who left the employ of the Fire Department under honorable conditions and who have been approved by the Fire Chief shall be placed on a reemployment list, provided the former firefighter is a State certified firefighter. The reemployment list shall be considered separate from the eligibility list for new hires. Those on the rehire list may be hired by the Fire Chief as openings occur without regard to the eligibility list for new hires. In addition the following shall apply; 95- 227 -29- u�r•. A) In accordance with State certification requirements, eligibility shall be limited to three (3) years following the effective date of resignation. B) Under conditions set forth above, any former permanent fire bargaining unit employees having one (1) to four (4) years, and eleven (11) months of previous continuous service as a firefighter will be placed at Step 1 of Salary Range 24 (48 hour shift) of the Firefighter classification. Former permanent fire bargaining unit employees having five (5) or more years of previous continuous service will be placed at Step 3 of Salary Range 24 (48 hour shift) of the Firefighter classification. 18.9 Leaves of absence without pay or suspension of any duration shall cause the effective date of the longevity and anniversary date to be deferred by the same number of calendar days embraced by said leave., 18.10 Any bargaining unit employee upon normal retirement from City service, or separating under honorable conditions, who has served for a period of twenty five (25) years or more, shall be granted, at the time of his/her normal retirement or honorable separation, one hundred seventy three and three tenths (173.3) hours of pay if on a forty (40) hour work week and two hundred and eight (208) hours of pay if on a forty eight (48) hour work week. 18.11 As part and in consideration of benefits provided in this Agreement to the Union and the Union's representation 95- 227 -30- Ar., that they will be able to generate additional revenue to fund this labor agreement and in consideration of the Union's good faith effort to cooperate with the City in the funding of the Agreement, the City has made good faith representations to the Union that it will be able to fund this Agreement. The City hereby knowingly, intelligently and unequivocally waives its right not to fund any year of this Agreement. The only exception to this waiver is in the case of a "true fiscal emergency," which is unanticipated at this time. In order for the City to establish a "true fiscal emergency" so as to lawfully not fund any year or years of this Agreement, the City must demonstrate that there is no other reasonable alternative means of appropriating monies to fund the Agreement for that year or years. Notwithstanding any other article of this Collective Bargaining Agreement, the City hereby specifically agrees that any disputes concerning the application or interpretation of the funding of the contract will be resolved through the grievance arbitration procedure of this Agreement. If an arbitrator determines that the City has breached its funding requirements under this Agreement, the parties jointly confer upon the arbitrator jurisdiction to order the City to appropriate the necessary monies to fund the Agreement. This also applies to any enforcement proceeding under Chapter 682, Florida Statutes. This article applies to any status quo period following the expiration of this contract. 9 r 7 -31- ARTICLE 19 PARITY 19.1 The monthly rates paid employees covered by this Agreement shall be not less than the monthly rates paid comparable ranks of the Miami Police Department. The comparable ranks are as follows: Firefighter - Police Officer Fire Lieutenant - Police Sergeant Fire Captain - Police Lieutenant Chief Fire Officer -- Police Captain 19.2 It is clearly understood that parity extends only to wages between the foregoing classifications of employment and that wages are those that are identified by the official City of Miami Pay Plan. It is further agreed and understood that parity exists exclusively with wages and does not include other terms and conditions of employment: ARTICLE 20 OVERTIME 20.1 All work performed in excess of an employee's normal work day and in excess of an employee's normal work week shall be considered overtime work. Employees performing overtime work shall be paid at the rate of time and one-half at their straight time hourly rate of pay. 20.2 Employees shall be compensated for overtime as set forth below: 95 _ 227 -32- 4.. (a) Employees may be paid for holidays and other overtime as it occurs or, at his option, he may accumulate compensatory time up to a maximum of 200 hours. Prior to November 1 of each year, the employee may elect to be paid for the full accumulation of earned time on the last pay day in November or carry over up to 48 hours for use during the following calendar year. If the employee elects to carry over up to 48 hours of compensatory leave, any additional balance shall be paid on the last pay day in November. (b) An employee may schedule up to 48 hours of compensatory time in conjunction with his vacation. (c) Unscheduled compensatory time may be taken off at the sole discretion of the Fire Chief. Denial of requests to use unscheduled compensatory time shall not be subject to any grievance procedure. (d) In the event a state of emergency is declared due to an act of God and the City Manager grants emergency leave, such leave shall not be included in determining eligibility for overtime. The employee utilizing such leave shall be paid straight time for those hours worked in excess of their normal work day or in excess of their normal work week equal to the number of hours taken as emergency leave, before overtime shall apply. 95- 227 -33- 20.3 The parties agree that overtime hours shall not be used in the computation of arriving at average earnings for purposes of establishing pension benefits. 20.4 The parties agree that assignments of overtime work shall rest solely with the Department Head. 20.5 The parties agree that the assignment of overtime work is on an involuntary basis and any employee refusing assignments of such work is subject to disciplinary action as deemed appropriate by the Department Director. ARTICLE 21 CALL BACK PAY 21.1 All employees covered by the terms of this Agreement who -are called back to work while off duty shall be paid at least three (3) hours minimum, plus one (1) hour's travel time, at the employee's overtime rate provided by Article 20. 21.2 Any employee covered by this Agreement who is summoned to appear as a witness, while off duty as a result of his direct employment as a member of the Miami Fire Department, will be paid four (4) hours minimum at one and one-half times his current hourly rate, excluding travel time, for all such time, provided that the Fire Chief is given prior notification so that he is given an opportunity to schedule such appearance during regular duty hours. In consideration of receiving overtime pay, employee shall promptly assign to the City any witness or deposition fees received, and mileage allowance, if any. This Article shall not apply in legal disputes where one member of the 95- 227 -34- bargaining unit sues another member of the bargaining unit covered by this Agreement. 21.3 Attendance in court in response to a legal order or subpoena to appear and testify in private litigation, not in connection to an employee's official duty, but as an individual shall be taken as EPL, vacation, compensatory leave, or leave of absence without pay. ARTICLE 22 WORKING OUT OF CLASSIFICATION 22.1 The City agrees that any person covered by this Agreement who is required to accept the full responsibilities and carry out the duties of a rank above that which he normally holds shall be paid at the hourly rate and one (1) step above his current rate in his regular classification while so acting, provided he works in that capacity for a minimum of four (4) hours. 22.2 The Fire Chief or his designee may at his sole discretion select the best qualified employee to serve in a classification higher than the classification in which he has Civil Service status. The employee will serve in this capacity for such periods of time as best suits the needs of the Fire Department as determined by the Fire Chief or his designee. -35- 95- 227 4., ARTICLE 23 HO IDAYS.IVACATIOW;—K TIME 23.1 The following days shall be considered holidays: New Year's Day Columbus Day Washington's Birthday Veterans Day Memorial Day Thanksgiving Day Independence Day Day After Thanksgiving Labor Day Christmas Day Martin Luther King's Birthday 23.2 Any additional holidays declared by official resolution of the City Commission shall- be added to the above list. 23.3 New Year's Day, Independence Day, Veterans Day, and Christmas will be on January 1st, July 4th, November 11th, and December 25th, respectively. However, those bargaining unit employees who work 40 hours per week will observe the above four (4) holidays on the same dates as do the non -uniformed employees of the City. 23.4 Any employee covered by this Agreement, in pay status, at the time the holiday occurs, shall at his option, if assigned to a twenty --four (24) hour shift (48 or 52'hour work week), be paid for ten (10) hours at his regular rate of pay or receive ten (10) hours of compensatory time, if assigned to a ten and a half (10.5) hour shift (42 hour work week), be paid for eight and a half (8.5) hours at his regular rate of pay or receive eight and a half (8.5) hours of compensatory time, or if assigned to a forty (40) hour work week be paid for eight (8) 95- 22'7 -36- hours of compensatory time or be paid eight (8) hours at his regular rate of pay. 23.5 It is agreed and understood that effective October 1, 1976, premium pay for work performed on a holiday shall be calculated as one-half of the actual time worked. An employee who works an eight (8) hour shift on which the holiday occurs, shall receive four (4) additional hours as premium pay; an employee who works a sixteen (16) hour shift on a given holiday shall receive (8) additional hours as premium pay; if assigned to a ten and a half (10.5) hour shift on which the holiday occurs, shall receive five and a quarter (5.25) additional hours as premium pay; and all employees whether they are off or on duty on the day on which the holiday occurs shall receive ten (10) hours for the holiday. The ten (10) hours, plus the premium pay as defined above is payable in cash or earned time at the employee's option according to the following: Any additional holiday time declared by the City shall be considered under the holiday option of cash or earned time for the actual amount of time so declared as holiday; premium pay shall be calculated as one-half the actual amount of time worked for such additional holiday time. 23.6 Longevity vacation on the sixth, seventh, eighth, ninth and tenth year of employment will be granted at the rate of ten (10) hours per year longevity vacation. From the eleventh year on it will be granted at the rate of five (5) hours per year, and sick time will be granted at the rate of ten (10) hours per month. 95- 227 -37- ioM 23.7 Effective January 1, 1994, the following changes to the vacation schedule will apply: (a) The vacation time multiplier for scheduling vacations shall be changed to 1.1. (b) The Hazardous Materials Team members shall schedule the vacation under this agreement. 23.8 Effective January 1, 1994, after the accumulation of six hundred (600) hours (four hundred and eighty (480) hours for forty (40) hour week employees) of sick leave, further accumulation shall at the employees option, be: Option 1 - Added to the employees sick time bank Option 2 - Paid for all sick leave hours in excess of sixty (60) hours annually (forty eight (48) hours for forty (40) hour week). Time earned for each calendar year shall be paid the first full pay day in February. Option 3 - Credited to an employee's vacation leave at the rate of five (5) hours vacation leave for each ten (10) hours of sick leave earned. 23.9 Employees covered by this Agreement who retire after October 1, 1993 shall be paid for one hundred percent'(100%) of accumulated sick leave up to twelve hundred (1200) hours and fifty percent (50%) of accumulated sick leave above twelve hundred (1200) hours. Employees whose sick leave payout was limited to fourteen hundred and forty (1440) hours shall have the option of keeping the fourteen hundred and forty (1440) hours limit or selecting the twelve hundred (1200) hours limit with 95- 22'7 payout at one hundred percent (100%) and fifty percent (50%) of accumulated sick leave above twelve hundred (1200) hours. Employees working less than forty eight (48) hours per week shall have their sick leave converted accordingly. 23.10 Effective January 1, 1996 vacations shall be taken by the first payroll period following the last payroll period of the calendar year in which the vacation was credited. The first payroll period ending date for calendar year 1997 is January 4, 1997. Upon ratification of the labor agreement, forty (40) hour and forty two (42) hour employees (or 48 hour and 52 hour employees) shall only be allowed to carryover one hundred and fifty (150) hours (or 180 hours) of the previous year's credited vacation. Any excess vacation over the one hundred and fifty (150) hour (or 180 hours) automatic carryover not taken within the payroll calendar year will be forfeited. Employees who were on disability at the time of their scheduled vacation shall be paid for all excess vacation over one hundred and fifty (150) hours (or 180 hours) at the employee's January 1, hourly rate of pay following the year the vacation would have been scheduled. If an employee is unable to take a previously authorized vacation due to cancellation by his/her_ Department and the vacation cannot be rescheduled within the payroll calendar year, any hours in excess of the one hundred and fifty (150) hours (or 180 hours) which would have been forfeited shall be paid for at the employee's January 1, hourly rate of pay following the year the vacation was scheduled. -39- 95- 22'7 ;far- ARTICLE 24 EARNED PERSONAL LEAVE (FLOATING HOLIDAY TIME 24.1 Effective upon ratification of the labor agreement, it is agreed that the bargaining unit members who have six (6) consecutive months or more of satisfactory service shall be entitled to twenty (20) hours earned personal leave off each calendar year if assigned to a 24-hour shift or sixteen (16) hours if assigned to a 40-hour week (17 hours if assigned to a 42 hour week). The earned personal leave hours may not be taken in less than one (1) hour increments. The earned personal leave hours shall be mutually agreed upon by the employee and his District Chief/Rescue Battalion Captain if on a 24-hour shift or Division Chief if on a 40-hour week consistent with the needs of the. Fire Department. The earned personal leave hours off shall not be accrued; they must be used by the employee during the calendar year or be forfeited. The earned personal leave hours off are not subject to being converted to cash during the employee's employment with the City. There shall be no liability to pay any overtime under this Article unless the employee is qualified to receive overtime as specified under Article 20 - Overtime. 24.2 Effective January 1, 1994, earned personal leave must be requested at least one (1) duty day prior to the date the earned personal leave is to be used, or it will be denied unless all apparatus are staffed and there are extra personnel on duty. This will not apply in the case of an employee who is on duty, requesting leave from duty due to an emergency. Employees who 95- 227 40 ps;, are on duty granted emergency leave from duty shall be charged earned personal leave time that is unscheduled in the employees time bank, prior to being granted other types..o_f time off. 24.3 Effective January 1, 1994, slots available for earned personal leave shall be limited to the scheduled vacation slots on the heaviest vacation day on each respective shift, unless exceeded with the permission of the Fire Chief. ARTICLE 25 FAMILY LEAVE AND LEAVES OF ABSENCE 25.1 The parties to this agreement believe that the terms and conditions set forth in this article meet or exceed the requirements specified within the Dade County Family Leave ordinance and the Family Leave Act of the United States. In the event that they do not, the Dade County Family Leave ordinance and the Family Leave Act will supersede these terms and conditions. 25.2 Effective upon ratification of the labor agreement, bargaining unit employees may take a leave of absence without pay not to exceed ninety (90) days during a twelve (12) month period for the birth or adoption of a child, the serious illness of a family member or the employee's own serious illness. 25.3 Leave without pay for a seriously ill family member or serious illness of the bargaining unit employee may be extended beyond the initially approved ninety (90) days upon approval of the City Manager or his/her designee. -41-- 95- 227 Le, 25.4 Bargaining unit employees are eligible for leave without pay as specified in Section 25.2 if the bargaining unit employee has been employed for at least ninety (90) days. 25.5 Leave without pay for birth or adoption of a child may be taken by the bargaining unit employee intermittently within one (1) year of the birth or adoption, however, such leave may not be taken on a reduced leave schedule. 25.6 Leave without pay for a seriously ill family member or because of a serious illness of the bargaining unit employee may be taken intermittently or on a reduced leave schedule when medically necessary for such arrangements. 25.7 Upon approval of the Fire Chief, with the approval of the City Manager or his/her designee, a leave without pay may be'granted, for the purpose of entering a course of training or study calculated to improve the quality of the employee's service to the City through course work directly related to the employee's job, for a period not to exceed six (6) months. The request for leave without pay may be extended for an additional six (6) months upon approval of the Fire Chief and approval of the City Manager or his/her designee. Employees requesting said leave of absence shall be required to submit evidence of registration upon entering each quarter/semester of school. 25.8 Upon approval of the Fire Chief with approval of the City Manager or his/her designee, a leave of absence without pay may be granted, for a good reason other than mentioned herein, for a period not to exceed ninety (90) days. Approval of said leave is at the sole discretion of the City Manager. -42- 95- 227 25.9 Bargaining unit employees who desire to take a leave without pay for any reason specified in this Article must exhaust all vacation, earned personal leave, and compensatory leave banks prior to taking a leave without pay. 25.10 Bargaining unit employees who desire to take a leave without pay for any reason specified in this Article shall not accrue leave time. At the expiration of the leave of absence without pay, the bargaining unit employee shall be returned to the position or equivalent position vacated when said leave of absence without pay was granted. Leave of absence without pay during the required probationary period of service shall be extend the probationary period the lengthy of time used during said leave of absence without pay. ARTICLE 26 EDUCATION 26.1 All employees covered by this Agreement, who are ordered to attend off -duty courses by the Fire Department shall be paid as provided for in Article 20 - Overtime for all time spent in attendance. 26.2 The City agrees to pay full tuition for all courses required for an Associate Degree in Fire Service Administration and/or Fire Science Technology provided that prior approval is obtained from the Chief of the Fire Department and provided that the employee receives a grade of "C" or better. Employees who fail to satisfactorily complete said training courses in which they enrolled, shall reimburse the City for tuition advanced in their behalf. 95 " 2 27 -43- 26.3 At the discretion of the Fire Chief, attendance at training courses while on duty shall be allowed and shall be charged to S.A. time. 26.4 Those employees attending classes paid for by the City shall not draw supplemental educational benefits from any other source. Should the employee wish to apply to receive supplemental educational benefits, i.e., G.I. Bill, he or she will not receive educational payments from the City. 26.5 Effective the first full pay period following October 1, 1993, bargaining unit members shall have their base salary increased if certified as specified below by the percentages listed. State Certified E.M.T. (non Paramedics) - 1.5% State Certified Paramedic - 5.0% 26.6 Effective the first full pay period following October 1, 1993, employees who are State Certified Paramedics or State certified EMTs permanently bid into Advanced Life Support positions on ALS apparatus (Rescue or Paramedic pumpers), will have their base pay increased five percent (5%) for Rescue assignment pay. 26.7. The City agrees that any person covered by this Agreement who is required to ride in an ALS position who is not receiving ALS assignment pay (all positions on Rescues, Squads, and ALS positions on paramedic Fire apparatus) shall be paid at one (1) step above their current hourly rate for all hours worked, provided they ride in that capacity for a minimum of four (4) hours. 95- 227 -44- 26.8 Effective the first full pay period following October 1, 1993, employees shall receive an additional increase for using certifications specified below by percentages listed. Effective October 1, 1995, any increases or decreases in the number of positions that receive any of certifications increases listed below shall be agreed upon by the Department and the Union by mutual agreement. Hazardous Materials Technician assigned to the Hazardous Materials Team - 1.5% State Certified Fire Service Instructor assigned to Instructor positions - 1.5% State Certified Fire Inspector assigned to the Fire Prevention Bureau - 1.5% N.A.U.I. or P.A.D.I., certified divers assigned to the Dive Team - 1.5% Employees assigned to the SWAT Team - 1.5% ARTICLE 27 DEATH IN FAMILY 27.1 Any employee covered by this Agreement may, in the case of death in the immediate family, be authorized up to a maximum of forty (40) hours of paid leave (42 hours for employees on 42 hour work week) for any death of a member of the employee's 95- 22'7 -45- immediate family. Said paid leave days shall be taken consecutively by the employee. The immediate family is defined as father, mother, sister, brother, husband, wife, children, father-in-law, mother-in-law, grandparents, spouse's grandparents, stepfather and/or stepmother if they have raised the employee from infancy regardless of place of residence, and may include any other person who was an actual member of the employee's household for ten (10) or more years immediately prior to their death. Within thirty (30) calendar days from the date the employee returns from a death in the family, the employee shall, upon request, file a copy of the death certificate of the deceased family member. Said death certificate will be attached to the form provided by the Office of Labor Relations and submitted to the Personnel Management Department. Failure to produce the death certificate will result in the employee reimbursing the City for any days taken under this Article. Any employee found to have falsified his application for a "K" day will be subject to disciplinary action up to and including dismissal. 27.2 It is understood that under certain circumstances the employee will be unable to obtain a death certificate. In this event, in lieu of a death certificate, the employee shall submit a newspaper account showing the death and the relationship of the deceased to the employee and/or other appropriate criteria as deemed appropriate by the Office of Labor Relations. 27.3 At the request of the employee, the Department Director may authorize the use of accrued vacation or compensatory leave. 9 CJ _ 227 )2rj -46- 49., 27.4 Employees on twenty-four hour tour of duty shall be bound by the above Sections except that they shall be authorized up to two (2) consecutive tours of duty on leave with pay. ARTICLE 28 PHYSICAL EXAMINATIONS 28.1 Employees shall be required to take a physical examination as follows: (a) Employees forty (40) years of age or older - one per year. (b) Employees thirty (30) years of age or older - one every other year. (c) Employees under thirty (30) years of age - one every three years. 28.2 The schedule set forth in Section 28.1 and the content of the present physical examination shall continue, unless changed by mutual agreement of the parties. 28.3 The City agrees to provide physicals that are mandated by State or Federal law, including but not limited to hazardous materials team and dive team physicals. ARTICLE 29 LOSS OF EQUIPMENT 29.1 A bargaining unit employee shall reimburse the City for the repair or replacement cost of lost, stolen, or damaged. City equipment when the City demonstrates that the employee's careless and/or negligent act(s) resulted in the loss, theft, or damage. 95- 227 -47- P,r.. ARTICLE 30 .BLOOD DONORS 30.1 Employees who volunteer as blood donors to contribute to a City supported Blood Donor Organization (Currently South Florida Blood Services) will be authorized the absence necessary to accomplish this purpose. The Blood Donor Organization's personnel will determine what amount of time the donor will need from the point of donation till the City donors are released to go back to work. ARTICLE 31 UBST.ANCE,ALCOHOL -- PERSONNEL SCREENING 31.1 In an effort to identify and eliminate on or off duty controlled substance/alcohol. abuse, urinalysis/blood tests shall be administered as provided herein: Employees refusing to give a blood/urine sample under any of the following conditions will be dismissed. Employees will be advised of their contractual rights relative to expedited arbitration. DOM_SUBSTANCE SCREENIN Effective October 1, 1995, employees meeting any of the criteria below shall be subject to random substance screening. Employees who meet any of the criteria below shall be subject to random substance screenings for a period of one hundred and eighty (180) calendar days from the date the criteria was met. After the period of one hundred and eighty (180) 95- 22'7 4'S., calendar days, if and when employees meeting criterion 1 have accumulated above one hundred and fifty (150) hours of sick leave and employees meeting criterion 3 or 4 have not been late or absent without leave (AWOL) for a one hundred and eighty (180) calendar day period, they shall no longer be subject to random substance screening, unless they meet the criteria again in the future. The City shall be limited to a maximum of two (2) substance screenings in each one hundred and eighty (180) calendar day period the employee is under random screening. RANDOM SCREENING POOL CRITERIA 1) Probationary firefighters are subject to screening until off probation. 2) Employees assigned to a forty eight (48) or fifty two (52) hour work week with less than one hundred and fifty (150) hours of sick leave accumulation. Employees assigned to a forty (40) or forty two (42) hour week with less than one hundred and twenty (120) hours of sick leave accumulation. 3) Employees who are absent without leave (AWOL) twice within a one hundred and eighty (180) calendar day period from the most recent AWOL if on a forty eight (48) or fifty two (52) hour work week or three (3) times within a one hundred and eighty (180) calendar day period if on a forty (40) or forty two (42) hour work week. 4) Employees reporting late (including any incidents of absence without leave) for duty three (3) times within a one hundred and eighty (180) calendar day period if on a forty eight (48) or fifty two (52) hour work week or five 95- 227 _49_ il4r:. (5) times within a one hundred eighty (180) calendar day period if on a forty (40) or forty two (42) hour work week. REASONABLE BELIEF SUBSTANCE SCREENING CATEG R E A) Where a District Chief, or above has a reasonable belief based upon objective factors that the employee has possession or is using, dispensing or selling any illegal drug or controlled substance which is not prescribed by a licensed physician. B) Following any vehicular accident occurring on -duty, on an off -duty detail, traveling to or from same involving employee(s) where a District Chief, or above has a reasonable belief based upon objective factors that the involved employee(s) may be under the influence of alcohol or may have been using, possessing, dispensing or selling controlled substance, unlawful, mind -altering, or non -physician prescribed drugs. C) Where a District Chief, or above has a reasonable belief based upon objective factors 'that the employee is under the influence of alcohol on duty, or on an off -duty detail, or traveling to or from same, or while covered for portal to portal pay for workers' compensation. 95- 227 -50- SUBSTANCE SCREENING PROCEDURES 31.2 Employees shall give either a blood sample, for suspected alcohol use or a urine sample for suspected substance abuse as determined by the City at either a hospital or accredited testing lab, as chosen by the City. The hospital or accredited testing lab shall include sufficient safeguards to ensure that a proper chain of custody is enforced. When a sample is taken under any of the above circumstances, a portion of the first sample shall be retained. All positive tests for a controlled substance will be confirmed using the employee's separate second sample if given or the reserve portion of the initial sample, by Gas Chromatography/Mass Spectrometry (G.C.M.S) or better testing. Testing procedures shall be under a reliable state licensed clinic laboratory. 31.3 Should the employee wish to give a separate second sample it shall be performed at either a hospital or accredited testing lab, as chosen by the City, within four (4) hours from the time of giving the initial sample. In the event an employee declines to offer a second sample for the separate second test, or is unable to give a second sample within the four (4) hour time period, the reserved portion of the first sample will be utilized. Employees shall be notified of a positive result within twelve (12) hours from the time a sample was given. Notice to the employee of the first test being positive shall be considered to have been served upon the employee by verbal notification or by a representative of the Department delivering a notice to the employee's last known residence as shown on the Department's personnel roster. 9 _ 227 -51- 31.4 If an employee is ordered back to duty for testing, the provisions of Article 21 (Call Back Pay) will apply. 31.5 Where a bargaining unit member alleges that an order made under this article is not consistent with the criteria cited herein, he/she shall comply with the order, and may simultaneously file a protest with the communicator of the order. 31.6 Disputes arising as to whether there was reasonable belief shall be arbitrable under the Expedited Arbitration Rules of the American Arbitration Association. All other issues involving grievances shall be processed as outlined within Article 15 - Grievance Procedure. 31.7 The employee(s) shall not be disciplined until a positive test result is communicated to the City. However, if the. employee's conduct in connection with the substance/alcohol abuse amounts to conduct for which the City may otherwise discipline the employee, the City may take action prior to knowing of a positive test result. 31.8 The I.A.F.F. will be advised of passed or failed tests to the extent that the releasing of such data is not inconsistent with Federal or State laws regarding the privacy of said test or if the individual involved does not want his test results released to the I.A.F.F. 31.9 The following cutoff concentrations shall be applicable for determining whether specimens are negative or positive for the following drugs or classes of drugs for the initial or confirmatory test procedures. A positive result shall be a concentration in excess of those listed below. -52- 95- 227 two, Cannabinoid (Marijuana) Cocaine Opiates Phencyclidine Amphetamines Methaqualone Methadone Initial Test Level (na/ml)_ 50 100 300 25 500 100 300 Propoxyphone 300 Tricyclic Antidepressants 300 EXPEDITED ARBITRATION 31.10 It is anticipated as soon as possible after ratification of the labor agreement between the City of Miami and IAFF, Local 587, the President of the Local and the City Labor Relations Officer will pick two (2) area permanent umpires to hear employee drug grievances. The two Umpires will alternate hearing only grievances where the bargaining unit member alleges a violation of Article 31.1 A, B or C. Said grievance will be limited to whether or not there was reasonable belief based on objective factors to require the grievant to take the Alcohol/Controlled Substance test. 31.11 Samples taken under Reasonable Belief Substance Screenings shall not be tested if the employee grieves the test under expedited arbitration until the umpire rules that there was reasonable belief to test the employee. 31.12 The cost of the Umpire's decision will be borne by the employer if the umpire rules there was not reasonable belief 95- 227 --53- E 1 to require the employee to take the test. If the umpire rules there was reasonable belief to require the employee to take the test, the Union will pay the cost of the umpire if the Union processed the grievance. If the grievant processed the grievance on his/her behalf, he/she will pay the cost of the Umpire. 31.13 It is anticipated that an expedited hearing would , be held before the Umpire under the American Arbitration Association rules of expedited arbitration and no post hearing briefs would be filed. The drug grievance will be submitted directly to arbitration and will be heard no later than five (5) calendar days after the employee was required to take the Alcohol/Controlled Substance test. The Umpire will rule at the close of the hearing and an oral response from the umpire will be sufficient to settle the grievance. 31.14 The two Umpires shall serve from year to year and shall be appointed by a letter jointly signed by the Union President and the Labor Relations Officer. Should either the City or the Union wish to drop an Umpire the Umpire shall be notified and the parties shall agree on a replacement. if they are unable to agree, each party will put two (2) names into a hat and the name drawn will be the replacement for one (1) year. 31.15 If the bargaining unit member remains silent and/or does not indicate that he/she desires the test results in accordance with Article 31.3, it shall be presumed that he/she has elected to go to expedited arbitration. 31.16 If the employee grieves the test, said grievance must be in writing and submitted by fax or hard copy to the Labor 95-- 22'7 -54- Relations Office on the same day as the test or no later than the next regularly scheduled work day of the Labor Relations Officer. The test sample will be thrown out, if the Umpire rules there was no reasonable belief to test the employee. If the umpire rules there was reasonable belief to test the employee, the test sample(s) shall be tested and the results released as outlined in this article. REHABILITATION 31.17 In the event that the results of the urinalysis/blood test are positive, the following criteria will apply: A) The employee at his/her own cost shall, within seventy two (72) hours of a positive test notification (excluding weekends and holidays), enter and remain in a substance/alcohol program approved by the City and the Union until the approved program administrator is able to state that he/she has successfully completed the program, including aftercare. While in the program, the employee will be allowed to return to work if the program administrator approves; if not, the employee may be suspended until the program administrator approves return to work. Such suspension shall not exceed six months. If the employee can not return to their regularly assigned position after six (6) months they shall be dismissed. If the employee does not successfully complete the program including 95- 227 -55-- ifs" aftercare, he or she will be dismissed. Employees shall not be permitted to work in combat positions until program administrators feel certain there is no possibility they are using drugs and submit this opinion in writing to the City. If and when the employee successfully completes the in -patient portion of the program, as determined by the program administrator, the employee shall be allowed to return to work. B) Upon being notified of a positive test, the employee will be immediately relieved of duty. If relieved of duty, the employee, if eligible, will use all of his/her earned time, vacation time, and sick time, and then he/she will go off the payroll. C) If the employee fails to enter, participate in and/or successfully complete any part of the rehabilitation program, including any aftercare program, the employee shall be terminated from his/her employment with the City. D) Effective upon ratification of the labor agreement, employees cleared to return to work by rehabilitation administrators, shall be subject to substance screenings at management's discretion for a period of two (2) years from the date the employee returned to work, The City will be limited to a minimum of three (3) and a maximum of five (5) screenings per twelve (12) month period. Employees 95- 22'7 -56- tested shall be entitled to a second test as outlined in Article 31.3. Employees who decline to offer a sample shall have the reserve portion of the first sample utilized as outlined in 31.3. Employees who test positive to confirmatory test shall be terminated from employment with the City. E) Effective upon ratification of this Agreement, employees will be entitled to one chance at a successful rehabilitation during their employment with the City. Employees who have been through at least one (1) rehabilitation program, who are screened shall be entitled to a separate second test as outlined in 31.3. Employees whose sample tests positive on confirmatory test shall be terminated from employment with the City. ARTICLE 32 HOURS OF WORK 32.1 The work week shall be as follows: 24 hours on duty, 48 hours off duty. A day off, now known as an "R" day, shall be granted once every seven (7) scheduled tours. This schedule will effect a 48 hour work week. Any changes in this schedule shall be subject to negotiations between the parties. 32.2 An "R" day shall be defined as a regular day off as scheduled by the Fire Chief or his designee and must be taken on the day so designated. An employee may not have the choice to substitute any other official accumulated time or any official 95- 22'7 -s7- ,zt:. time as provided by the City of Miami unless approved by the Fire Chief or Deputy Chief. 32.3 Effective the first full pay period following October 1, 1995, an optional fifty two (52) hour work week will be established as follows: twenty four (24) hours on duty, forty eight (48) hours off duty, a day known as an "R" day, shall be granted once every fourteen (14) scheduled tours. This schedule will affect a fifty two (52) hour work week. Employees working this schedule shall be paid at the same hourly rate as they would on a forty eight (48) work week. Time accumulations shall be based on a forty eight (48) hour work week. Only those volunteering for a fifty two (52) hour work week shall be assigned to it. The number of positions and seniority bidding will be negotiated by the parties. Wages shall be those specified in the appropriate salary schedule contained within this Agreement (See Appendices). 32.4 Effective the .first full pay period following October 1, 1995, a new work week shall be established for a limited number of personnel staffing emergency apparatus as follows: Monday through Thursday, from 0730 to 1800 hours. This schedule will effect a forty two (42) hour work week. Time accumulations and banks will be based upon a forty two (42) hour work week (prorating 48 hour week time accumulations to forty two (42) hour work week). Wages shall be those specified in the appropriate salary scheduled contained within this Agreement (See Appendices). Personnel will bid for these positions, with the senior qualified bidder being assigned. If there is not a 95- 227 amm sufficient number of personnel bidding for the assignments, the least senior qualified personnel may be assigned. ARTICLE 33 PERSONNEL ALLOCATION 33.1 The City agrees to provide minimum staffing for firefighting apparatus in active service. In order to provide a minimum level of safety to personnel in the bargaining unit, apparatus in service shall be staffed with no less than; 1. 4 persons per aerial unit 2. 4 persons per quint unit 3. 4 person per pumper unit 4. 3 persons per rescue unit 5. 2 persons per squad unit 6. 1 person per air truck 33.2 If, in the future, new types of apparatus are placed in service, which are -not covered above, the City and the Union will meet to negotiate a minimum staffing level for the new types of apparatus. If agreement is not reached within thirty (30) days, the dispute shall be submitted to arbitration consistent with the grievance procedure contained in Article 15. 33.3 The Union agrees that this article has no effect on the City's rights under Article 6, Management Rights, except as outlined above. Specifically, the City has the sole authority, whether exercised or not, to determine the number and kinds of firefighting/rescue apparatus needed to fulfil the Fire Department's mission. Such Management decision will not be grievable or arbitrable. 9 5" 227 -59- ARTICLE 34 EMPLOYEE RIGHT TO REPRESENTATION 34.1 Where an investigation is initiated by the Management of the City of Miami Fire Department against an employee covered by this Agreement concerning criminal charges and where a formal statement under oath is elicited from the accused employee, the interrogation shall be conducted under the following conditions: (a) The interrogation shall be conducted at a reasonable hour, preferably while the accused is on duty, unless the seriousness of the investigation is of such degree that an immediate action is required. If the accused is off duty at the time of the interrogation, the accused shall be entitled to overtime. However, if he or she is eventually found guilty of the charges through the applicable administration processes, any overtime shall be forfeited in addition to any penalty imposed for the violation. If it occurs while on duty, a commanding officer or a supervisor of the accused' shall be notified of the interrogation. (b) If the interrogation is conducted by or for the Department, it shall take place in the Miami Fire Department building. If the interrogation is to be conducted by or for another investigating City agency, it shall be conducted at either the 95- 227 Imm investigative agency's City office or at the Miami Fire Department. (c) The accused shall be informed of the rank, name and command of the officer in charge of the , investigation, the interrogating party and all persons present during the interrogation. All questions directed at the accused shall be asked by and through one interrogator at any one time. (d) The accused shall be informed of the nature of the investigation prior to any interrogation, and given the names of all known complainants. (e) Interrogations shall be for reasonable periods and shall be timed to allow for such personal necessities and rest period as are reasonably necessary. (f) The accused shall not be subjected to abusive or offensive language or threatened with transfer, dismissal or other disciplinary actions. No promise, reward or threat or action shall be made as an inducement to answering any questions. (g) The complete interrogation including when, recesses are taken shall be recorded, and there shall be no unrecorded questions or statements. (h) The accused shall not be obligated into giving a second statement concerning the same facts elicited in an original interrogation. This will not preclude an investigator from asking questions at a 95- 22'7 MOSE later time that were not covered by the first statement. (i) No mechanical device, including, but not limited to, polygraph, psychological stress evaluator, et al., shall be forced onto an accused, nor shall disciplinary action be taken against an accused who refuses to submit to such testing. (j) If the accused is under arrest, or is likely to be arrested as a result of the interrogation, he shall be fully informed of his or her legal rights prior_ to any interrogation. (k) At the request of the accused, he or she shall have the right to be represented by counsel or any other representative of his or her choice during the entire interrogation. (1) Where an attorney or employee representative is requested but cannot be present within four (4) hours of notification, the employee shall be required to obtain another employee representative or counsel. When an employee representative or counsel is present, he shall be only an advisor and shall not have the right of cross examination. 34.2 The above shall not apply to investigations and review of infractions of non -criminal City and Departmental Rules and Regulations provided, however, any employee covered by this Agreement who is disciplined as the result of the alleged violation of City or Departmental Regulations, Rules or Policies 95- 22'7 -62- yH\ shall have the right to have Union representation present if he or she desires it. If such meeting occurs between 9:00 a.m. and 5:00 p.m. on normal Monday through Friday business days the employee shall be allowed two (2) hours to have Union representative present. If such meeting occurs at times other than those described above, the employee shall be allowed four (4) hours to secure Union representation. The Union representative shall be an advisor to the employee and shall not have the right to cross examination. ARTICLE 35 RESIDENCY 35.1 It is agreed that while residency is not a condition of employment a candidate that is otherwise equally qualified will be given, at time of hire, preference for employment in order of domicile as follows: (1) City of Miami resident, (2) Dade County resident, (3) resident outside of Dade County. ARTICLE 36 SHIFT STRENGTH 36.1 The City agrees to budget the Fire Department for six hundred and two (602) uniform firefighters for each fiscal year during this Agreement (FY'96, 97 and 98), in addition to civilian positions and operating expenses. Each of these six hundred and two (602) uniform positions (including vacancies) shall be fully funded for each of the fiscal years ('96, 97 and 98). Of these six hundred and two (602) positions, a minimum of 95- 22'7 -63- is., five hundred and thirty six (536) (including vacancies) will be assigned to the Emergency Response Division to provide emergency services. 36.2 During the time this Agreement is in effect, if there are any vacancies of the six hundred and two (602) uniform positions (retirement, termination, quit, etc.) the salary and cost of fringe benefits of the vacant position or vacating employee(s) will accumulate at the rate of sixty two thousand dollars ($62,000) on an annual basis per vacancy. This money shall be accounted for in a budget line entitled "salary reserves." "Salary reserves" shall be used to pay personnel cost in maintaining a minimum of one hundred and twenty (120) uniform personnel on duty per shift. These personnel costs include the costs of overtime, increased work hours under Article 32.3, Hours of Work, or the hiring of new firefighters. If at any time there are no funds within the "salary, reserves" line of the budget, service shall be provided- with those on duty and overtime personnel shall not be hired for staffing unless approved by the City Manager or his designee. If due to an emergency (hurricane, riot, etc.) the City puts more personnel on duty than one hundred and twenty (120), the cost for the excess personnel (those over the 120) will not be paid from the "salary reserves" line of the budget. 36.3 Starting October 1, 1995, the Fire Chief shall see that a monthly report is faxed to the Union Office, consisting of all uniform vacancies, date of each vacancies, "salaries reserves" balances, overtime used, any other payments from the 'salary reserves," etc. 9 5 - 227 -64- 9 14 ot., 36.4 The funds accumulating from the vacancies may be used only for purposes stipulated within this Article. Any remaining funds not used shall accumulate during the life of this Agreement. If any funds remain at the expiration of this Agreement, they will be shared equally between bargaining unit employees and the City. All bargaining unit personnel shall receive an equal share in the form of a cash bonus. The bonus shall not be included as pensionable compensation. ARTICLE 37 STATION COMMANDERS 37.1 All Station Commanders shall receive a one percent (1%) increase in wages. Openings for Station Commander after this Agreement becomes effective shall be filled in the following order: A) The senior in grade Captain assigned to the station requesting the assignment. B) If no requests are made, the least senior in grade Captain assigned to the station shall be the Station Commander. ARTICLE 38 TOTAL AGREEMENT 38.1 The parties agree that this Collective Bargaining Agreement represents the total agreement during the life of this contract, and no requests shall be made to increase the cost of wages, hours and working conditions through the Civil Service 95- 22'7 -65- X19-1 Board, City Manager, or the City Commission during the life of this Collective Bargaining Contract. ARTICLE 39 REPRESENTATION OF THE CITY 39.1 The City shall be represented by the City Manager, or a person or persons designated in writing to the Union by the City Manager. The City Manager shall have authority to execute an agreement on behalf of the City upon being directed by official resolution of the City Commission. 39.2 It is understood that the City representative or representatives are the official representatives of the City for the purpose of negotiating with the Union. Negotiations entered into with persons other than those as defined herein, regardless of their position or association with the City, shall be deemed unauthorized and shall have no weight of authority in committing or in any way obligating the,City. ARTICLE 40 EPRESENTATION OF THE UNION 40.1 The bargaining unit shall be _represented by the President of the Union or by a person or persons designated in writing to the City Manager by the President of the Union. The identification of representatives shall be made each year prior to April 1. 40.2 The President of the Union, or the person or persons designated by said President, shall have full authority to 95- 227 conclude a collective bargaining agreement on behalf of the Union subject to a majority vote of those bargaining unit members voting on the question of ratification. 40.3 It is understood that the Union representative or representatives are the official representatives of the Union for the purpose of negotiating with the City. Such negotiations entered into with persons other than those as defined herein, regardless of their position or association with the Union, shall be deemed unauthorized and shall have no weight or authority in committing or in any way obligating the Union. 40.4 It shall be the responsibility of the Union to notify the City Manager or designee in writing of any changes in the designation of the President of the Union or of any certified representative of the Union. ARTICLE 41 AGREEMENT IN -THE EVENT OF TRANSFER 41.1 The City agrees that in the event of a transfer of the Fire Department or its functions to Metropolitan Dade County, all the rights and benefits of the transferred employees guaranteed under this Agreement shall be continued for the term of this Agreement. ARTICLE 42 SAVINGS PROVISION 42.1 If this Agreement or any provision, section., subsection, sentence, clause, phrase or word of this Agreement is 95- 227 -67- declared invalid by a court of competent jurisdiction, the remainder of the Agreement shall remain in full force and effect. The parties will meet, promptly, to negotiate replacement language in accordance with Chapter 447, Part II, Florida Statutes. 42.2 During the term of the Agreement, the parties agree the City may take reasonable steps to comply with the provisions , of the Americans with Disabilities Act. ARTICLE 43 PENSION 43.1 COLA Distribution - The COLA will be disbursed in future years consistent with the methods agreed upon by the parties named herein: A) A representative of IAFF, Local 587 B) A representative of FOP, Lodge No. 20 C) The City Manager's designee and the Labor Relations Officer D) A representative of the FIPO Pension Board 43.2 Employees eligible for service retirement under Section 40-212 (A) and (B) of the Code shall be entitled to: A) Retirement Allowance. Upon retirement, an employee shall be entitled to receive a retirement allowance equal to 3% times years of creditable service of the employee's average final compensation. B) Deferred Retirement Option Plan (DROP) 1)." Effective October 1, 1995 a deferred retirement 95- 227 4. option plan (DROP) is hereby created. 2) Eligibility. Any firefighter who has reached age fifty (50) with ten (10) years of creditable service or who has attained a combination of age plus years of creditable service equal to seventy (70) shall be eligible to participate in the DROP plan. 3) Maximum participation. The maximum period of participation in the DROP is thirty six (36) months. 4) Election to participate. Upon election of participation in the DROP plan, by using a form and procedures as prescribed by the Board of Trustees, a firefighter's creditable service, accrued benefits and compensation calculation shall be frozen and shall be based on the singlQ highest year preceding participation in the DROP as the basis of calculating the DROP plan payment. Upon commencement of participation in the DROP plan, the employee contribution and the City contribution to the Retirement System for that employee shall cease as the employee will be earning no further service credit. The employee shall not acquire additional pension credit for the purposes of the pension plan but may continue City employment for up to a maximum of thirty six (36) months. . • 95- 227 Its, 5) Creation of individual account. For each person electing participation in the DROP, an individual defined contribution account shall be created. Payment shall be made by the retirement plan into the employee's DROP account in an amount equal to the regular monthly retirement benefit which the member would have received had the member separated from service and commenced the receipt of benefits from the system. The amount of the monthly benefit shall be determined based on the creditable service, average final compensation, and retirement option selected in accordance with Section 40-212(L) of the Miami City Code. Upon conclusion of a period of participation in the DROP not to exceed the maximum set forth in Section 3, the member shall terminate employment with the City of Miami. 6) Earnings on DROP account. The Board of Trustees of the -Retirement System shall establish, by administrative rule, a series of investment vehicles which may be chosen by participants in the DROP plan. Any losses incurred on account of the option selected by the participant shall not be made up by the City of Miami or the FIPO trust fund, but any such loss shall be borne by the participant only. Upon participation in the DROP, the member shall make an irrevocable selection of -70- 95- 227 ��r the earnings program. All interest shall be credited to the employee's DROP account. 7) Distribution of DROP benefits. Upon termination of employment, a member may receive payment from the DROP account in the following manner: a. Lump sum distribution; b. periodic payments; C. an annuity; d. rollover of the balance to another qualified retirement plan. A member may defer payment until the latest date authorized by Section 401(a)(9) of the Internal Revenue Code. 8) Disability or death during DROP participation. For pension purposes only, if a member dies or becomes permanently and totally disabled, thq member shall be treated the same as a retired member and the pension benefit shall be made according to the option selected. Pension benefits shall begin on the date of death or permanent and total disability. This article shall not effect any other death or disability benefit provided to a firefighter under federal law, state law, City ordinance, or this Agreement. 9) COLA participation. Eligibility for payments for cost of living adjustment (COLA) shall not commence until a member has actually separated -71- 95- 22'7 it&' from employment with the City. COLA service years shall be based upon creditable years of service in calculating the employee's pension. For the purpose of complying with Section H(3)(m) of the Amended Final Judgment in Gates, the employee's "Date of Retirement" shall be the date of actual termination of employment as a firefighter with the City of Miami and not the date of election to DROP. C) Leave Balance Payoff Options. Employees electing to retire may select one of the two following leave balance payoff options: 1) Payment of leave balances upon retirement as currently specified under the labor agreement and/or leave payoff practices. 2) The City shall fund up to a maximum of three (31 whole creditable service years for the employee based upon the value of the employee's available leave balance at time of retirement less required withholding taxes at present value as actuarialy determined for each individual employee. Upon exhausting the value of the leave balances, employees may purchase the remainder of the three (3) years by payment of cash to the Pension Trust. The hourly rate for calculation of the leave balances shall be as specified under the labor agreement and or leave payoff practices. The 95-- 227 —72— to., purchase of service years under this option may not be utilized for service Rule of 70 retirement eligibility. If in the future the constructive receipt issue can be satisfactorily resolved, this benefit shall be available using pre-tax value of employees' leave banks. ARTICLE 44 �E-VE�g INCENTTtt� PAY Revenue Production During the term of this Agreement bargaining unit members agree to produce new revenues to offset the cost services. of Fire/Rescue Medical Transports _ The Union projects that additional emergency medical transportation fees of $2,025 000 for Year 1996, and Fiscal $2,700,000 for Fiscal Year 1997 will be generated and collected through g medical transports. This projection is based on increased transports and an increase in trans Inspections port fees. - Bargaining unit members the Finance De also agree to assist Department in generating g an additional four hundred an ($400,000 through certificate ' inspections, etc. This shall be °f use of by assigning seven (7) additional inspectors to the inspectors currentl the Fire Prevention Bureau for this 1' assigned to Purpose. Other Revenues The Fire Department and the Union agrees to seek out other sources of revenue existin r and attempt to increase 9 ones for the general fund. New revenues including but 95- 227 -73- not limited to, other fees generated or produced, return of taxes I used for transport from Dade County, user fees, service contracts, etc. will count towards future increases in the "revenue incentive" pay. New revenues shall not include grants. Revenue Measurement and Goal I Revenue Goal - A goal of $2,025,000 of total new revenue is established for Fiscal Year 1995-96. The goal for Fiscal Year I 1996-97 shall be $2.7 million. Goals include all new revenues as a total, except certificate of use fees, if any falls short others can make up for it. Measurement of Revenue The Union and the City shall meet prior to December of 1996 and December of 1997, to determine if the goal has been met or exceeded for the past fiscal year, as specified below. Collected revenue will be rounded to the nearest hundred thousand ($50,000 and above shall be rounded up). Transports - Fiscal Year 1995-96: The $2,025,000 of new transport fees shall be in addition to $2 million current Department collections projected for ALS transports. Fiscal Year 1996-97: The $2,700,000 million of new ftransport fees shall be in addition to the $2 million base the Department collects each year for ALS transports. i The City shall agree to purchase a minimum of ten (10) new ALS transport apparatus and have them service ready by I October 1, 1995. If this is not accomplished any units unable to transport due to being out of service for more than eight (8) hours, shall have a pro rata share credited to revenues, the unit I 95- 227 -74- %4*4 would have generated for each twenty four (24) hour period at the end of the year. Inspections - It is anticipated that through mutual cooperation the Fire Department and the Finance Department shall increase certificate of use fees an additional four hundred thousand dollars ($400,000) for each fiscal year during this Agreement. Other Revenues - The Department and the Union through the labor/management process, shall document by letter for approval by the City Manager other new revenues the Fire Department will be seeking to collect. Revenue Incentive Pair For their efforts in generating this new revenue, bargaining unit members shall receive a "revenue incentive" wage increase of two and one-half percent (2.5%) effective the first full pay period in January 1996 through the pay period prior to the first full pay period in January 1997. Starting in January 1997, revenue incentive pay will be determined for the following year, based upon the amount of revenue generated as outlined below. After the revenue has been calculated and agreed upon each year, the revenue incentive pay will be adjusted as outlined within the appropriate Table effective the first full pay period in January 1997 and January 1998, respectively. This increase shall be segregated on the employees paycheck stub so employees realize the pay is based upon their performance. -75- 95- 22'7 Par, Revenue incentive pay for the last quarter of 1998 will be considered to be earned in Fiscal Year 1997-1998, and shall continue to be paid biweekly through the pay period prior to the first full pay period of January 1999. Revenue incentive pay adjustments for Fiscal Years 1997 and 1998 shall be those specified in Table 1 and Table 2 attached to this Agreement. The Revenue Incentive Pay adjustments can range from a minimum of zero percent (0%) to a maximum of seven percent ARTICLE 45 TRANSITION 45.1 Effective October 1995 the Fire Department will be modifying the Department's emergency deployment system. Personnel must be reassigned to accommodate this transition. Some plus item positions will be eliminated and some new plus item positions will be created. Due to the massive impact this will have on bargaining unit employees assigned shift work within the Emergency Response Division, Management agrees to reallocate personnel based upon one of the following concepts as 'chosen by bargaining unit employees by majority vote at the contract ratification meetings: Division Wide Bid - All 48 hour personnel assigned to the Emergency Response Division will bid for all positions within the Division by qualifications and. seniority. -76- 95-- 227 Station and Shift Bid - Personnel assigned to each station and shift would have preference by qualifications and seniority, for all positions with their respective station and shift, prior to other personnel being able to bid for the assignments. The procedures for whichever process is chosen shall be agreed to through the labor/management process. 45.2 Bargaining unit employees bidding for and receiving assignments on a shift different than the shift they are currently assigned to, may have their "R" day rescheduled for the last quarter of Fiscal Year 1995. 45.3 The Union agrees that bargaining unit members may be used in lower classifications to provide emergency service when necessary. ARTICLE 46 TERMINATION AND MODIFICATION 46.1 After a majority vote of those bargaining unit members voting on the question of ratification, and thereafter upon its ratification by an official resolution of the City Commission ratifying the Agreement and authorizing the City Manager to sign the Agreement on behalf of the City, then the Agreement, upon being signed by the appropriate Union representative and the City Manager, shall become effective October 1, 1995, except where otherwise stipulated. This Agreement shall continue in force until September 30, 1998, provided, however, that the parties shall meet no later than May -77- 95- 22'7 4.f 1, 1997 to reopen negotiations to discuss Article 18 - Wages. 46.2 On or before April 1, 1998, the Union shall notify the City in writing of its intention to renegotiate the Agreement in force and attached thereto shall include a list of proposals which shall inform the City of the items which they desire to negotiate, together with specific language describing its , proposals. The changes indicated in the proposals shall be designated with a strike through of deleted language and new language will be underlined. 46.3 On or before April 1, 1998, the City shall present the Union with a list of proposals it desires to negotiate together with specific language describing its proposals. The changes indicated in the proposals shall be designated with a strike through of deleted language and new language will be underlined. 46.4 Initial discussions shall thereafter and no later than May 1, 1998, be entered into by the City and the Union. 46.5 Such discussions shall be concluded by the signing of a proposed agreement pursuant to Florida law. Agreed to this day of , 1995 by and between the respective parties through an authorized representative or representatives of the Union and by the City Manager. 95- 227 4 ATTEST: INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF FIREFIGHTERS, AFL-CIO, LOCAL 587 President ATTEST: ON THE PART OF THE CITY OF MIAMI, MIAMI, FLORIDA City Manager CITY CLERIC APPROVED AS TO FORM AND CORRECTNESS CITY ATTORNEY --79- 95- 227 io.'. APPENDIX "A" Class, Code nM22er Salary Title R t to to to to Step 1st Lng 2nd Ling s._-Class 3rd Lng 4th Lng _ s_ 40 Hr. Fire Fighter 24B 30,437 31,974 33,648 35,298 37,062 38,871 40,839 42,851 45,067 46,194 48,504 42 Hr. 30,437 31,974 33,648 35,298 37,062 38,871 40,839 42,851 45,067 46,194 48,504 48 Hr. 30,437 31,974 33,648 35,298 37,062 38,871 40,839 42,851 45,067 46,194 48,504 52 Hr. 32,973 34,639 36,452 38,240 40,151 42,110 44,242 46,422 48,823 50,044 56,546 40 Hr. Fire 27B 35,298 37,062 38,871 40,839 42,851 45,067 47,238 49,612 52,145 53,449 56,121 42 Hr. Lieutenant 35,298 37,062 38,871 40,839 42,851 45,067 47,238 49,612 52,145 53,449 56,121 i 48 Hr. 35,298 37,062 38;871 40,839 42,851 45,067 47,238 49,612 52,145 53,449 56,121 52 Hr. 38,240 40,151 42,110 44,242 46,422 48,823 51,175 53,747 56,491 57,903 60,798 40 Hr. Fire Captain 30B 40,839 42,851 45,067 47,238 49,612 52,145 54,768 57,437 60,354 61,862 641956 42 Hr. 40,839 42,851 45,067 47,238 49,612 52,145 54,768 57,437 60,354 61,862 641956 48 Hr. 40,839 42,851 45,067 47,238 49,612 52,145 54,768 57,437 60,354 61,862 64,956. 52 Hr. 44,242 46,422 48,823 51,175 53,747 56,491 59,332 62,223 65,383 67,018 70,369 40 Hr. Chief Fire 33B 47,238 49,612 52,145 54,768 57,437 60,354 63,429 66,595 69,874 71,621 75,202 42 Hr. Officer 47,238 49,612 52,145 54,768 57,437 60,354 63,429 66,595 69,874 71,621 75,202 48 Hr. 47,238 49,612 52,145 54,768 57,437 60,354 63,429 66,595 69,874 71,621 75,202 52 Hr. 51,175 53,747 56,491 59,332 62,223 65,383 68,715 72,144 75,697 77,589 811469 w *Firefighter/probationary Salary: 27,393 C.Tc (Entry level Firefighters are paid 10% less than Step 1 for a period of 6 months.) APPENDIX "B" Class, 1st 2nd 3rd 4th 5tt Code Salary Lng Lng Lng Lng Ln( Class Titleto t 2 - Sten 3 S= 4 top- 5 Step 6 Stgp 7 10 2 40 Hr. Fire Fighter 24B 31,654 33,253 34,994 36,710 38,545 40,426 42,472 44,565 46,870 48,042 50,444 5117 42 Hr. 31,654 33,253 34,994 36,710 38,545 40,426 42,472 44,565 46,870 48,042 50,444 5117 48 Hr. 31,654 33,253 34,994 36,710 38,545 40,426 42,472 44,565 46,870 48,042 50,444 5117 52 Hr. 34,292 36,025 37,910 39,770 41,757 43,794 46,012 48,279 50,776 52,046 54,648 5610 40 Hr. Fire 27B 36,710 38,545 40,426 42,472 44,565 46,870 49,128 51,597 54,231 55,587 58,366 59,& 42 Hr. Lieutenant 36,710 38,545 40,426 42,472 44,565 46,870 49,128 51,597 54,231 55,587 58,366 59,8: p 48 Hr. 36,710 38,545 40i426 42,472 44,565 46,870 49,128 51,597 54,231 55,587 58,366 59,8: 52 Hr. i 39,770 41,757 43,794 46,012 48,279 50,776 53,222 55,897 58,751 60,219 63,230 64,8: 40 Hr. Fire Captain 30B 42,472 44,565 46,870 49,128 51,597 54,231 56,959 59,734 62,768 64,337 67,554 69,2, 42 Hr. 42,472 44,565 46,870 49,128 51,597 54,231 56,959 59,734 62,768 64,337 67,554 69,2' 48 Hr. 42,472 44,565 46,870 49,128 51,597 54,231 56,959 59,734 62,768 64,337 67,554 69,2i 52 Hr. 46,012 48,279 50,776 53,222 55,897 58,751 61,705 64,712 67,998 69,699 73,183 7510: 40 Hr. Chief Fire 33B 49,128 51,597 54,231 56,959 59,734 62,768 65,966 69,259 72,669 74,485 78,210 80 lE 42 Hr. Officer 49128 51597 54231 56959 59734 62768 65966 69259 72669 74485 78210 80 V 48 Hr. 49,128 51,597 54,231 56,959 59,734 62,768 65,966 69,259 72,669 74,485 78,210 80, 52 Hr. 53,222 55,897 58,751 61,705 64,712 67,998 71,464 75,030 78,725 80,693 84,728 86,b� *Fi.refighterfprobationary Salary: 28,489 � (Entry Ylevel Firefighters are paid 10% less than Step 1 for a period of 6 months.) CITY OF MIAMI, FLORIDA IWER-OFFICE MEMOIMNOUM 19 4. MAR 2 0 1995 TO: Honorable Mayor and Members of the ity Commission FROM : Cesar H. Odio City Manager DATE : FILE : SU6JECT : Resolution Ratifying 1995- 1998 Labor Agreement Between the City of Miami and IAFF, REFERENCES. LOC81 587 ENCLOSURES: It is recommended that the City Commission adopt the attached Resolution authorizing the execution of a labor agreement between the City of Miami and the employee organization known as the International Association of Firefighters, AFL-CIO, Local 587 (IAFF) for the period of October 1, 1995 - September 30, 1998. Under Florida Statutes, Chapter 447, the City is required to bargain collectively with the certified bargaining representatives of the IAFF, Local 587. In conjunction with the Retirement Incentive Program, the City and IAFF, Local 587 have reached a successor labor agreement acceptable to both sides. As a result of those negotiations, the City and IAFF, Local =87 have a agreed to a three year labor agreement. This agreement provides for a 0% across-the-board increase for fiscal year 1995- 96, a 4% across-the-board increase in January 1997 and a reopener on wages for fiscal year 1997-98. Employees will also receive a 2.5% transport incentive p-%r supplement in January 1996. The transport incentive pay supplement will be supported by a projected additional $2.7 million in revenue generated from transport fees. A 3% pension benefit multiplier for all years of service and the purchase of up to three whole years of service with leave balances upon retirement would become permanent benefits. A deferred retirement option plan (DROP) will also be available to - bargaining unit members. Under DROP an employee may, upon Service or Rule of 70 retirement, elect to continue working for the City, in their same classification and with the same benefits, for up to a maximum of three years. 95- 227 Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Commission RE: Ratifying IAFF Labor Agreement Page 2 of 2 Other benefits negotiated include funding issues to be submitted to arbitration if the City is unable to fund benefits for the second and third year of the labor agreement; budgeting for 602 positions with accumulated salary savings to be shared with employees on a 50/50 ratio; 5%,.pay supplement if assigned to an advance life support (ALS) system position for more than four hours; 5% rescue assignment pay if assigned to an ALS squad; employment preferenge in order of City residency first, county residency• .second and thereafter residency outside'of the county; and 52 aie... 42 hour work week options if positions are available. It is requested that the City Manager be authorized to enter into the attached labor agreement for 1995-1998 between the City of Miami and IAFF, Local 587. cc: Manohar Surana, Assistant City Manager A. Quinn Jones, City Attorney Ramon Irizarri, ,sistant City Attorney 95- 227