HomeMy WebLinkAboutCC 1997-11-26 Marked Agenda•
PRESIDING OFFICER HUMBERTO HERNANDEZ
COMMISSIONER
WIFREDO (WILLY) GORT
COMMISSIONER
J.L. PLUMMER JR.
COMMISSIONER
TOMAS REGALADO
COMMISSIONER
ARTHUR E. TEELE JR.
C OF l� MAYOR XAVIER L. SUAREZ
i
* #
IptppP pplTfp
J p is
CITY COMMISSION AGENDA
MEETING DATE: NOVEMBER 25, 1997 CITY HALL 3500 PAN AMERICAN DRIVE
ANY PERSON WHO ACTS AS A LOBBYIST PURSUANT TO CITY OF MIAMI
ORDINANCE 11469 MUST REGISTER WITH THE CITY CLERK, PRIOR TO
ENGAGING IN LOBBYING ACTIVITIES BEFORE CITY STAFF, BOARDS, AND
COMMITTEES AND THE'CITY COMMISSION. A COPY OF SAID ORDINANCE
IS AVAILABLE IN THE OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK, CITY HALL.
ANY PERSON MAKING IMPERTINENT OR SLANDEROUS REMARKS OR WHO BECOMES
BOISTEROUS WHILE ADDRESSING THE COMMISSION, SHALL BE BARRED FROM FURTHER
AUDIENCE BEFORE THE COMMISSION BY THE PRESIDING OFFICER, UNLESS PERMISSION TO
CONTINUE OR AGAIN ADDRESS THE COMMISSION BE GRANTED BY THE MAJORITY VOTE OF THE
COMMISSION MEMBERS PRESENT. NO CLAPPING, APPLAUDING, HECKLING OR VERBAL
OUTBURSTS /N SUPPORT OR OPPOSITION TO A SPEAKER OR HIS OR HER REMARKS SHALL BE
PERMITTED. NO SIGNS OR PLACARDS SHALL BE ALLOWED /N THE COMMISSION CHAMBERS.
PERSONS EXITING THE COMMISSION CHAMBER SHALL DO SO QUIETLY.
PLANNING&ZONING
C ITYCOM MISS ION ME ETI N G
* THIS MEETING SHALL CONVENE AT 2:00 PM *
THIS PRINTED AGENDA IS DISTRIBUTED AT LEAST FIVE DAYS BEFORE THE MEETING
AND THE MATERIAL IN CONNECTION WITH EACH ITEM APPEARING ON THE AGENDA IS
AVAILABLE FOR INSPECTION DURING BUSINESS HOURS AT THE OFFICE OF THE CITY
CLERK IN CITY HALL.
ANY PERSON WHO SEEKS TO ADDRESS THE CITY COMMISSION ON ANY ITEM
APPEARING IN THE FOLLOWING PORTIONS OF THIS AGENDA: "CONSENT AGENDA",
"PUBLIC HEARINGS", OR "PUBLIC DISCUSSION" IS INVITED TO DO SO AND SHALL AS
SOON AS POSSIBLE INFORM THE CITY CLERK OF HIS/HER DESIRE TO SPEAK, GIVING
THE CITY CLERK HIS/HER NAME. AT THE TIME THE ITEM IS HEARD, THAT PERSON
SHOULD APPROACH THE MICROPHONE AND WAIT TO BE RECOGNIZED BY THE MAYOR
WHO PRESIDES OVER THE CITY COMMISSION MEETING.
* Is * Is Is
Should any person desire to appeal any decision of the Miami City Commission with
respect to any matter to be considered at this meeting, that person shall ensure that
a verbatim record of the proceedings is made including all testimony and evidence
upon which any appeal may be based.
Is
The City Commission has established a policy that the lunch recess will begin at the
conclusion of deliberations of the agenda item being considered at Noon; further,
that Commission meetings will adjourn at the conclusion of deliberations on the
agenda item being considered at 9:00 PM. (Resolution No. 97-115)
THE FOLLOWING ITEMS SHALL NOT BE CONSIDERED
BEFORE 2:00 PM
ITEM PZ 1 RESOLUTION- (J-97451)
REQUEST: Official vacation and closure of a public
right-of-way.
LOCATION: 1695 N.W. 9m Avenue
APPLICANT(S): Jackson Memorial
Hospital
APPLICANT(S)
AGENT: Eugene Shy, Assistant
County Attorney
APPELLANT(S): N/A.
APPELLANT(S)
AGENT: N/A.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
Community Planning & Revitalization Department: N/A.
Building & Zoning Department: N/A.
Public Works Department: Approval. See supporting documentation.
Plat & Street Committee: Approval. See supporting documentation.
Historic Preservation Board: N/A.
Planning Advisory Board: N/A.
Zoning Board: Recommended approval to City Commission.
Vote of 5-1.
Official vacation and closure of a public right-of-way, being Track
"A" and "B" the portion of N.W. 8t° Avenue between 16" and 17"
Street of Medical Subdivision.
NOTES: CONTINUED FROM CC 10/28/97.
PAGE 2
November 25, 1997
R-97-843
MOVED :
SECONDED:
UNANIMOUS
PLUMMER
GOI T
ITEM PZ 2 RESOLUTION- (J-97-796)
REQUEST: Major Use Special Permit for Yacht Club at
Brickell II
LOCATION: 1155 Brickell Bay Drive (F.K.A. South Bayshore Dr.)
APPLICANT(S): New York Life Insurance Company
APPLICANT(S)
AGENT: Stephen J. Helfman, Esq. .. .
APPELLANT(S): N/A.
APPELLANT(S)
AGENT: N/A.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
Department of Planning & Development: Approval with conditions.*
Building & Zoning Department: N/A.
Public Works Department: N/A.
Plat & Street Committee: N/A.
Historic Preservation Board: N/A.
Planning Advisory Board: Recommended for approval to City
Commission. Vote of 5-0.
Zoning Board: N/A.
Major Use Special Permit for the Yacht Club at Brickell II project to
allow a Residential Development consisting of 355 residential units and
accessory commercial space with 465 parking spaces.
*See backup documentation.
PAGE 3
November 25, 1997
R-97-844
MOVED: PLUMMER
SECONDED: REGALADO
UNANIMOUS
ITEM PZ 3 RESOLUTION- [J-97-696(a) & J-97-696(b)]
REQUEST: Appeal of a Zoning Board decision
LOCATION: 2615 S.W. 20 Street
APPLICANT(S):
APPLICANT(S)
AGENT:
APPELLANT(S):
APPELLANT(S)
AGENT:
Oliver de Campoamor
00".
Oliver de Campoampr
N/A.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
Community Planning & Revitalization Department: Denial.
Building & Zoning Department: N/A.
Public Works Department: N/A.
Plat & Street Committee: N/A.
Historic Preservation Board: N/A.
Planning Advisory Board: N/A.
Zoning Board: Denied the Variance. Vote of 7-0.
Appeal of a Zoning Board decision which denied a Variance as listed
in Ordinance No. 11000, as amended, the Zoning Ordinance of the
City of Miami, Article 4, Section 401, Schedule of District Regulations,
R-1 Single -Family Residential, to permit a structure with a rear yard
setback of 3'-0" (5'-0" required) for an existing addition to a single
family residence; zoned R-1 Single -Family Residential.
NOTES: CONTINUED FROM CC 10/28/97.
PAGE 4
November 25, 1997
APPEAL DENIED BY
R,97=845
MOVED REGALADO
SECONDEDz PLUnMER
UNANIMOUS
ITEM PZ 4 RESOLUTION- [J-97-725(a) & J-97-725(b)]
REQUEST: Appeal of a Zoning Board decision
LOCATION: 315 S.W. 10 Avenue
APPLICANT(S): Felipe & Clara Bouza
APPLICANTS)
AGENT: N/A.
APPELLANT(S): Felipe & Clara Bouza
APPELLANT(S)
AGENT: N/A.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
Community Planning & Revitalization Department: Denial.
Building & Zoning Department: N/A.
Public Works Department: N/A.
Plat & Street Committee: N/A.
Historic Preservation Board: N/A.
Planning Advisory Board: N/A.
Zoning Board: Denied the Variances. Vote of 5-2.
Appeal of a Zoning Board decision which denied Variances from
Ordinance No. 11000, as amended, the Zoning Ordinance of the City of
Miami, Article 4, Section 401, Schedule of District Regulations, R-3
Multifamily Medium -Density Residential, to permit a structure with a
rear yard setback of 5.2' (10'-0" required), to waive one (1) of the
required two (2) oDstreet parking spaces, per Article 9, Section 908.10.1,
to permit a landscape area of 67 sq. ft. or 6.7% (200 sq. ft. 20% required),
and to permit a driveway 2.5' from the side property line in the first 20'
setback (5' required) for existing multifamily units; zoned R-3
Multifamily Medium -Density Residential.
NOTES: CONTINUED FROM CC 10/28/97.
PAGE 5
November 25, 1997
APPEAL GRANTED BY
R-97-846 (AS MODIFIED)
MOVED: PLU494ER
SECONDED: REGALADO.
UNANIMOUS
:7
ITEM PZ 5 RESOLUTION- [J-97-727(a) & J-97-727(b)]
REQUEST: Appeal of a Zoning Board decision
LOCATION: 1673 N.W. 27 Avenue
APPLICANT(S):
APPLICANT(S)
AGENT:
APPELLANT(S):
APPELLANT(S)
AGENT:
Via del Rio Restaurant, Inc.
Virgilio Perez
The neighboring home owners and business
owners within of the 375 ft. radius of 1673
N.W. 27 Avenue.
N/A.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
•
Community Planning & Revitalization Department: Approval with
conditions.
Building & Zoning Department: N/A.
Public Works Department: N/A.
Plat & Street Committee: N/A.
Historic Preservation Board: N/A.
Planning Advisory Board: N/A.
Zoning Board: Granted the Special Exception. Vote of 4-3.
Appeal of a Zoning Board decision which granted a Special Exception as
listed in Ordinance No. 11000, as amended, the Zoning Ordinance of the
City of Miami, Article 4, Section 401, Schedule of District Regulations, to
allow a tavern; zoned C-1 Restricted Commercial.
NOTES: CONTINUED FROM CC 10/28/97.
PAGE 6
November 25, 1997
CONTINUED TO
JANUARY 27, 1998
ITEM PZ 6 RESOLUTION- [J-97-728(a) & J-97-728(b)]
REQUEST: Appeal of a Zoning Board decision
LOCATION: 1837 N.W. 33`' Street
APPLICANT(S): Angel Rodriguez
APPLICANT(S)
AGENT: N/A.
APPELLANT(S): Angel Rodriguez
APPELLANT(S)
AGENT: N/A.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
Community Planning & Revitalization Department: Denial.
Building & Zoning Department: N/A.
Public Works Department: N/A.
Plat & Street Committee: N/A.
Historic Preservation Board: N/A.
Planning Advisory Board: N/A.
Zoning Board: Motion to approve failed thus constituting a
denial. Vote of 3-3.
Appeal of a Zoning Board decision which denied Variances from
Ordinance No. 11000, as amended, the Zoning Ordinance of the City of
Miami, Article 4, Section 401, Schedule of District Regulations, R-2 Two -
Family Residential, to permit a side yard setback (west) of 3'-1" (59-0"
required) and to waive one (1) of the required three (3) offstreet parking
spaces and per Article 9, Section 908.3, Permanent structural projections
from buildings, to permit an overhang to leave V-7" open space from the
required west side yard (3'-0" minimum space required between the edge
of the eave and the interior side property line) for an existing second unit
addition; zoned R-2 Two -Family Residential.
NOTES: CONTINUED FROM CC 10/28/97.
PAGE 7
November 25, 1997
APPEAL GRANTED BY
R-97-847 (AS MODIFIED)
MOVED: GORT
SECONDED: TEELE
ABSENT: PLTMMER
REGALADO
ITEM PZ 7 SECOND READING ORDINANCE - (J-97-723)
REQUEST: To Amend Ordinance No. 10544, from
Duplex Residential to Restricted Commercial
to change the Future Land Use element of the
Comprehensive Neighborhood Plan
LOCATION: 2734 S.W. 16 Street 1.
APPLICANT(S): Alfredo Hidalgo, President of ARCCA inc.
APPLICANT(S)
AGENT: N/A.
APPELLANT(S): N/A.
APPELLANT(S)
AGENT: N/A.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
Department of Planning & Development: Approval.
Building & Zoning Department: N/A.
Public Works Department: N/A.
Plat & Street Committee: N/A.
Historic Preservation Board: N/A.
Planning Advisory Board: Recommended approval to City
Commission. Vote of 5-2.
Zoning Board: N/A.
Consideration of amending Ordinance No. 10544, as amended, the
City of Miami Comprehensive Neighborhood Plan by amending the
Future Land Use Map by changing the land use designation of the
property located at 2734 S.W. 16 Street from "Duplex Residential' to
"Restricted Commercial".
NOTES: PASSED FIRST READING ON OCTOBER 28, 1997,
MOVED BY: GORT, SECONDED BY: GIBSON, ABSENT:
CAROLLO AND PLUMMER. THIS IS A COMPANION ITEM TO
PZ-8.
PAGE 8
November 25, 1997
ORDINANCE 11576
MOVED: GORT
SECONDED: REGALADO
UNANIMOUS
r
ITEM PZ 8 SECOND READING ORDINANCE - (J-97-697)
REQUEST: To Amend Ordinance No. 11000, from R-2
Two -Family Residential to C-1 Restricted
Commercial, to change the Zoning Atlas
LOCATION:
APPLICANT(S):
APPLICANTS)
AGENT:
APPELLANT(S):
APPELLANT(S)
AGENT:
2734 S.W. 16 Street
Alfredo Hidalgo, President of ARCCA Inc.
N/A.
N/A.
N/A.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
Department of Planning & Development: Approval.
Building & Zoning Department: N/A.
Public Works Department: N/A.
Plat & Street Committee: N/A.
Historic Preservation Board: N/A.
Planning Advisory Board: N/A.
Zoning Board: Recommended approval to City
Commission. Vote of 7-0.
Change of Zoning as listed in Ordinance No. 11000, as amended, the
Zoning Ordinance of the City of Miami, Article 4, Section 401, Schedule
of District Regulations, from R-2 Two -Family Residential to C-1
Restricted Commercial.
NOTES: PASSED FIRST READING ON OCTOBER 28,1997, MOVED
BY: GIBSON, SECONDED BY: GORT, ABSENT: PLUMMER.
THIS IS A COMPANION ITEM TO PZ-7.
PAGE 9
November 25, 1997
ORDINANCE.11577
?MOVED GOET
SECONDED: TEELE
UNP.NTMOUS
E
ITEM PZ 9
REQUEST:
LOCATION:
APPLICANT(S):
APPLICANT(S)
AGENT:
APPELLANT(S):
APPELLANT(S)
AGENT:
SECOND READING ORDINANCE - (J-97-616)
To Amend Article 6 of Zoning Ordinance 11000
N/A.
City of Miami, Department of Plan mi g
& Development
N/A.
h/"
N/A.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
Department of Planning & Development: Approval.
Building & Zoning Department: N/A.
Public Works Department: N/A.
Plat & Street Committee: N/A.
Historic Preservation Board: N/A.
Planning Advisory Board: Recommended for denial to City
Commission. Vote of 7-0.
Zoning Board: N/A.
Consideration of amending Ordinance 11000, as amended, the Zoning
Ordinance of the City of Miami, by amending Article 6, Section 602
"Coconut Grove Central Commercial District" in order to modify
Section 602.10.4 entitled "Off -site Parking", to include that portion of
the adjacent G/I District bounded by Main Highway, Charles Avenue
and William Avenue; also in order to correct and clarify certain
language in the section.
NOTES: PASSED FIRST READING ON SEPTEMBER 23, 1997,
MOVED BY: PLUMMER, SECONDED BY: GIBSON,
UNANIMOUSLY. CONTINUED FROM CC 10/28/97.
PAGE 10
November 25, 1997
CONTINUED TO
JANUARY 27, 1998 BY
M-97-842
MOVED: PLUMMER
SECONDED* TEELE
UNANIMOUS
ITEM PZ 10
REQUEST:
LOCATION:
APPLICANT(S):
APPLICANTS)
AGENT:
APPELLANT(S):
APPELLANT(S)
AGENT:
FIRST READING ORDINANCE - (J-97-665/1)
To Amend Articles 9 and 11 of Zoning
Ordinance 11000
N/A.
City of Miami, Department of Planning
& Development
N/A.
N/A.
N/A.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
Department of Planning & Development: Denial.
Building & Zoning Department: N/A.
Public Works Department: N/A.
Plat & Street Committee: N/A.
Historic Preservation Board: N/A.
Planning Advisory Board: Recommended approval to City
Commission. Vote of 4-3.
Zoning Board: N/A.
Consideration of amending Ordinance 11000, as amended, the Zoning
Ordinance of the City of Miami, by deleting subsections 1104.4 through
1104.4.1 from article 11 in their entirety and substituting in lieu thereof
new subsection 926.15.2, to allow a maximum of ten outdoor advertising
signs (billboards) city wide, subject to approval as a Special Exception
with certain standards and conditions.
PAGE 11
November 25, 1997
WITHDRAWN
ITEM PZ 11 FIRST READING ORDINANCE - (J-97-665/2)
REQUEST: To Amend Articles 9 and 11 of Zoning
Ordinance 11000
LOCATION: N/A.
APPLICANT(S): City of Miami, Department of Planning
& Development
APPLICANT(S)
AGENT: N/A.
APPELLANT(S): N/A.
APPELLANT(S)
AGENT:. N/A.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
Department of Planning & Development: Denial.
Building & Zoning Department: N/A.
Public Works Department: N/A.
Plat & Street Committee: N/A.
Historic Preservation Board: N/A.
Planning Advisory Board: Recommended denial to City Commission.
Vote of 4-1.
Zoning Board: N/A.
Consideration of amending Ordinance 11000, as amended, the Zoning
Ordinance of the City of Miami, by deleting subsections 1104.4 through
1104.4.1 from Article 11 in their entirety and substituting in lieu thereof
new subsection 926.15.2.1 to Article 9, and amending subsection
926.15.2, to allow a maximum of ten outdoor advertising signs
(billboards) citywide, with certain standards and conditions.
PAGE 12
November 25, 1997
FIRST READING ORDTNANCE`
MOVED: REGA.LADO
SECONDED: PLUMMER
UNANTMOUS
•
ITEM PZ 12 FIRST READING ORDINANCE - (J-97-617)
REQUEST: To Amend Article 6 of Zoning Ordinance 11000
LOCATION: N/A.
APPLICANT(S): City of Miami, Department of Planning
& Development
APPLICANTS) TM.
AGENT: N/A.
APPELLANT(S): N/A.
APPELLANT(S)
AGENT: N/A.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
Department of Planning & Development: Approval.
Building & Zoning Department: N/A.
Public Works Department: N/A.
Plat & Street Committee: N/A.
Historic Preservation Board: N/A.
Planning Advisory Board: Recommended for denial to City
Commission. Vote of 4-3.
Zoning Board: N/A.
Consideration of amending Ordinance 11000, as amended, the Zoning
Ordinance of the City of Miami, by amending Article 6, to add a new
Section 602.4.1.3. entitled "Sales display and service activities within
open or partially open space", to modify the existing provisions and
allow certain components of said uses by Special Exception or Class H
Special Permit within open space for the SD-2 Coconut Grove Central
Commercial District.
NOTES: CONTINUED FROM CC 10/28/97.
PAGE 13
November 25, 1997
CONTINUED TO
JANUARY 27, 1998 BY
M-97-848
MOVED: PLUMMER
SECONDED: GORT
UNANIMOUS
n
11
ITEM PZ 13
REQUEST:
LOCATION:
APPLICANT(S):
APPLICANTS)
AGENT:
APPELLANT(S):
APPELLANT(S)
AGENT:
FIRST READING ORDINANCE - (J-97-619)
To Amend Article 9 of Zoning Ordinance 11000
N/A.
City of Miami, Department of Planning
& Development
N/A.
N/A.
N/A.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
Department of Planning & Development: Denial.
13uilding & Zoning Department: N/A.
Public Works Department: N/A.
Plat & Street Committee: N/A.
Historic Preservation Board: N/A.
Planning Advisory Board: Recommended for denial to City
Commission. Vote of 7-0.
Zoning Board: N/A.
Consideration of amending Ordinance 11000, as amended, the Zoning
Ordinance of the City of Miami, by amending Article 9, Section 920.2.2
"Parking or storage of major recreational equipment as an accessory use
in residential districts", in order to set forth regulations allowing storage
of said vehicles in front yards, conditionally.
NOTES: CONTINUED FROM CC 10/28/97.
PAGE 14
November 25, 1997
CONTINUED TO
,J.ANUARY27' 1998 BY
M,97�849
MOVED PLLTKMER
SECONDED,, GORT
UNANIMOUS
0
ITEM PZ 14
REQUEST:
LOCATION:
APPLICANT(S):
APPLICANT(S)
AGENT:
FIRST READING ORDINANCE - (J-97-694)
To introduce a new Chapter 15 in the City Code
N/A.
City of Miami, Department of Planning
& Development
N/A.
APPELLANT(S): N/A.
APPELLANT(S)
AGENT: N/A.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
Department of Planning & Development: Approval.
Building & Zoning Department: N/A.
Public Works Department: N/A.
Plat & Street Committee: N/A.
Historic Preservation Board: N/A.
Planning Advisory Board: Recommended for approval to City
Commission. Vote of 6-0.
Zoning Board: N/A.
Consideration of amending the Code of the City of Miami to introduce a
new Chapter 15 to be entitled "Exterior Facade Code" setting forth
standards concerning all exterior building surfaces of residential
neighborhoods and commercial and business districts.
PAGE 15
November 25, 1997
FIRST READING ORDINANCE
MOVED: PLUMMER
SECIINDER GORT
UNANIMOUS
ITEM PZ 15 FIRST READING ORDINANCE - (J-97-804)
REQUEST: To Amend Chapter 62 of the City Code
•LOCATION: N/A. a
APPLICANT(S): City of Miami, Department of Planning
& Development
APPLICANTS)
AGENT: N/A.
APPELLANT(S): N/A.
APPELLANT(S) '
AGENT: N/A.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
Department of Planning & Development: Approval.
Building & Zoning Department: N/A.
Public Works Department: N/A.
Plat & Street Committee: N/A.
Historic Preservation Board: N/A.
Planning Advisory Board: N/A.
Zoning Board: N/A.
Consideration of amending Chapter 62, Article IX of the Code of the
City of Miami, Florida, as amended, pertaining to the Urban
Development Review Board thereby reducing the number of members
required for a quorum and voting. .
PAGE 16
November 25, 1997
EMERGENCY ORDINANCE 11578
(AS MODIFIED)
MOVED: PLUMMER
SECO'.\?DED : GORT
UNANIMOUS