HomeMy WebLinkAboutR-99-0838J-99-950
11/3/99
'fix
� : , 0
('
RESOLUTION N0. qJ 5 d s8
A RESOLUTION OF THE MIAMI CITY COMMISSION,
WITH ATTACHMENTS, OFFICIALLY ACCEPTING THE
ATTACHED CITY CLERK'S CERTIFICATION AND
DECLARATION OF THE RESULTS. OF THE SPECIAL
MUNICIPAL ELECTION FOR CHARTER AMENDMENT
NO. 3, HELD ON NOVEMBER 2, 1999, IN WHICH THE
CHARTER AMENDMENT TO PROVIDE FOR THE POSITION
AND THE OFFICE OF AN INDEPENDENT AUDITOR
GENERAL WAS APPROVED BY THE ELECTORATE.
BE IT RESOLVED BY THE COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI,
FLORIDA:
Section 1. The City Clerk's Certification and
Declaration of the Results of the Special Election for Charter
Amendment No. 3, attached hereto and made a part hereof, held on
November 2, 1999, in which a charter amendment to provide for
the position and the office of an Independent Auditor General
was approved by the electorate are hereby officially accepted.
PASSED AND ADOPTED this loth day of November , 1999.
This AdKhistrative Act shall
e e effective imme 'atel
C �i
FORMAlf, CITY CLERK
CITY co MNIISSION
MEETING OF
NOV 1 n 1999
Resolution No.
f.) l) SVV
t�
Ml `
CERTIFICATION AND DECLARATION OF RESULTS
SPECIAL REFERENDUM CITY OF MIAMI ELECTION
November 2, I999
STATE OF FLORIDA )
COUNTY OF DADE )
CITY OF MIAMI )
I, Walter J. Foeman, City Clerk of the City of Miami, Florida, do hereby certify that all
necessary legal steps were taken in connection with the conduct of a City of Miami
Special Referendum Election held on November 2, 1999, including, though not limited
to, the following Logic and Accuracy Tests:
On Monday, November 1, 1999:
A) Commencing at approximately 2:30 p.m., the City of Miami Canvassing
Board (hereinafter referred to as "Canvassing Board") convened and the
Miami -Dade County Supervisor of Elections had the tabulating equipment
located in the Elections Department, Stephen P. Clark Center, tested to
ascertain that the equipment would correctly tabulate the precinct and
absentee ballot votes cast for all City of Miami candidates and Charter
Amendments Numbers 1, 2, and 3.
B) Pursuant to Florida Statutes 101.5612 entitled, "Testing of Tabulation
Equipment," the test was conducted by processing a preaudited group of
ballots so produced as to record a predetermined number of valid votes for
each candidate and each measure and included one or more ballots which had
votes in excess of the number allowed by law in order to test the ability of the
automatic tabulation equipment to reject such votes.
C) Test results were compared with the predetermined totals for each question.
and pursuant to requirements established in Section 101.5612, Florida
Statutes, I witnessed and observed the performance and results of all required
tests and verified the correctness of the program, precinct header cards and
test ballots, as well as any replacement of said materials required by and
subject to said tests.
D) At the completion of the preelection test of the automatic tabulation
equipment, approximately 4:15 p.m., sealed boxes (#78425) were
appropriately identified by Miami -Dade County Elections Department to
secure the testing materials' and the program microdisks, which would ensure
the inviolabilit} of the materials in question.
E) The Canvassing Board set the time for opening of the valid absentee ballots
starting at 2:30 p.m., and at 5 p.m. began the canvass of the presumed invalid
absentee ballots cast.
a9 a5
II. On Tuesday, November 2, 1999 (election day):
A) Commencing at 5 p.m.. the Canvassing Board resumed the canvassin�t, of the
absentee ballots. At approximately 6 p.m., the Miami -Dade County
Supervisor of Elections had -the tabulation equipment located in the Elections
Department at the Stephen P. Clark Center tested to ascertain that the
equipment had not been tampered with. and that it would correctly count the
precinct and absentee ballot votes cast for all City of Miami candidates and
Charter Amendment questions.
B) At the completion of the precinct and absentee ballot count the preelection
test of the automatic tabulating equipment was again tested at approximately
7:25 p.m., before the official count of ballots to ascertain that the equipment
correctly counted the precinct and absentee votes cast for all Cit), of Miami
candidates and Charter Amendment questions.
C) .At the completion of the election. followed by the post -count Logic and
Accuracy test. all voted ballots, together with their precinct header cards. the
duplicated and the spoiled ballots were appropriately stored in containers
which were sealed (sea] #A 0078422, C 0078224.E 0078410. F 0078333)
and signed off by the Miami -Dade County Supervisor of Elections and the
City Clerk.
III. I further certif}, that all documents concerning these Logic and Accuracy Tests
showed the tabulating equipment to be functioning correctly and that said
documents are presently in the possession of the Supervisor of Elections of Miami -
Dade County, in containers which were sealed (# 0078425) and signed off by the
Supervisor of Elections and the City Clerk.
IV. I further certify and declare that the results of the Citv_ of Miami Special Election
held on November 1999 are as follows:
I
2
N
CITY OF MIAMI SPECIAL ELECTION RESULTS
November 2, 1999
(97 Precincts Processed, plus absentees)
Total Registered Voters in Miami: 122,674 100%
Ballots Cast: 29,005 23.64%
CHARTER AMENDMENT NO. 1, PROVIDING FOR STRONG MAYOR -
COMMISSION FORM OF GOVERNMENT AND MAYORAL ELECTION:
YES: 14,153 53.19°%
NO: 12,455 46.81 %
CHARTER AMENDMENT NO.2, PROVIDING FOR TERM LIMITS FOR
MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSIONERS:
YES: 16,491 72.52%
NO: 6.248 27.48%
CHARTER AMENDMENT NO.3, ESTABLISHING THE OFFICE AND
POSITION OF INDEPENDENT AUDITOR GENERAL:
YES: 14.560 58.89%
NO: 10.164 41.11%
S9- 838
ABSENTEE BALLOT COUNT
TOTAL ABSENTEE BALLOTS CAST: 1.346
CHARTER AMENDMENT NO.1, PROVIDING FOR STRONG MAYOR -
COMMISSION FORM OF GOVERNMENT AND MAYORAL ELECTION:
YES: 614 51.99%
NO: 567 48.01 %
CHARTER AMENDMENT NO.2, PROVIDING FOR TERM LIMITS FOR
MAYOR AND CITY COMMISSIONERS:
YES: 750 71.56%
NO: 298 28.44%
CHARTER AMENDMENT NO.3, ESTABLISHING THE OFFICE AND
POSITION OF INDEPENDENT AUDITOR GENERAL:
YES: 624 55.81%
NO: 494 44.190/0
V. I further certify that the total number of ballots cast. including total number of
absentee ballots counted for said Special Election was 29.005.
VI. I further certify that Charter Amendment No. 1: providing for a strong mayor -
commission form of government and mayoral election was approved by the
electorate.
VII. I further certify that Charter Amendment No. 2: providing for term limits for
mayor and city commissioners was approved by the electorate.
VIII. I further certify that Charter Amendment No. 3: establishing the . Office and
position of Independent Auditor General was approved by the electorate.
4 �tcjc
WITNESS MY HAND and the official Seal of the City of Miami. Florida, this 8"' of November. 1999.
i
AL'
Waite . Foeman. City Clerk
Sworn to and Subscribed before me this 81h day of November, 1999. by Walter J.
Foeman, personally known to me, who did take an oath.
&Ylv�iaLow�man. Notary Public
ROFFICI,y��vor�wrgSYW 4 LpVMNvCOA A""'OM 14 OER CC823844Y COMMON EVIREB
APR. 29 2003
VJ-- 6 05
METROPOLITAN UNTY, FLORIDA
METao•A`a�1.
METRO -DARE CENTER
OFFICE OF THE SUPERVISOR OF ELECTIONS SUITE 1910 Mailing Address:
111 N.W. 1st STREET P O. Box 012241
MIAMI. FLORIDA 33126.1962 Miami. Ronda 33101.2241
(305) 375.5553
CERTIFICATION
STATE OF FLORIDA)
COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE)
I, David C. Leahy, Supervisor of Elections of Miami -Dade County, Florida, do hereby certify that the
hereby attached is a true and correct copy of the precinct and absentee ballot counts of the votes cast for
the municipal candidates and questions below at the November 2, 1999 City of Miami Nonpartisan
Primary and Special Elections.
COMMISSIONER —DISTRICT 1
COMMISSIONER — DISTRICT 2
COMMISSIONER — DISTRICT 4
CHARTER AMENDMENT PROVIDING FOR STRONG MAYOR -COMMISSION
FORM OF GOVERNMENT ,AND MAYORAL ELECTION
CHARTER AMENDMENT PROVIDING FOR TERM LIMITS FOR MAYOR AND
CITY COMMISSIONERS
CHARTER AMENDMENT ESTABLISHING THE OFFICE AND POSITION OF
INDEPENDENT AUDITOR GENERAL
WITNESS MY HAND AND
OFFICIAL SEAL, AT MIAMI,
MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA,
ON THIS 2nd DAY OF NOVEMBER, 1999.
DCL:zd
David C. Leahy
Supervisor of Elections
Miami -Dade County
METROPOLITAN DA i OLINTY, FLORIDA ..
METEtO DADE
OFFICE OF THE SUPERVISOR OF ELECTIONS METRO•DADE CENTER
SUITE 1910
11i N.W. 1st STREET Melling Address:
MIAMI, FLORIDA 33128•1962 P. 0. 8oz 012241
(305) 375.5553 Miami, Florida 33101.2241
CITY OF MIAMI
1VIIAMI-DADS COUNTY, FLORIDA
NONPARTISAN PRY AND SPECIAL ELECTIONS
NOVEMBER 2, l 999
and
GENERAL MUNICIPAL ELECTION
NOVE MER 9, 1999
CERTIFICATION
I, the undersigned, City of Miami City Clerk, member of the City of IMami
Canvassing Board, do hereby order that all valid absentee ballots for these elections
be opened starting at 2:30 p.m. on the Monday prior to each election. may
CITY OF MIAMI CANVA SING BOARD:
Walter Foeman
City Clerk
� z
o
C)
Z
N
c-n
1999 Pall Municipal Lions 0
Miami -Dade County, odda November Z 1999
CERTIFICATION
PUBLIC LOGIC AND ACCURACY TEST
OF THE TABULATION EQUIPMENT
We, the undersigned City Canvassing Boards' representatives appointed to
act during the municipal elections to be held on November 2, 1999, do, by our
signatures hereto, certify that to the best of our knowledge:
1. On November 1, 1999, commencing at approximately 2:30 p.m., the Supervisor of
Elections had the tabulating equipment based in the Elections Department at the
Stephen P. Clark Center tested to ascertain that the equipment will correctly count
the precinct and absentee ballot votes cast for all candidates and questions.
2. The undersigned compared the test results with the predetermined totals for each
choice and pursuant to the requirements established in Section 101.5612, Florida
Statutes, observed the performance and results of all required tests and verified the
correctness of the program, precinct header cards and test ballots, as well as any
replacement of said materials required by said tests, subject to said tests.
3. At the completion of this public logic and accuracy test, the verified logic and
accuracy report, ETNet log, program microdisk (seal s;-i'4Ntiy ) and test ballots
with precinct header cards were placed in the custody of the Supervisor of Elections
under seal number r<n%li z 5
ANVASSING BOARD REPRESENTATIVES:
City 4lerka—niel F. De oath
City of laieah l
�l/�
City Clerk Walter Foeman
City of Miami
City Clerk Robert Parcher
City of Miami Beach
Pa(9P s of 3
0 J U e►''V
0 1999 pan Municipal +coons
Miami -bade County, Florlde November 2, 1999
CERTIFICATION
LOGIC AND ACCURACY TEST PERFORMED
PRE- AND POST- PRECINCT AND ABSENTEE BALLOT COUNTS
We, the undersigned City Canvassing Boards' representatives appointed to act
during the municipal elections to be held on November 2, 1999, do, by our signatures
hereto, further certify that to the best of our knowledge:
4. On November 2, 1999, commencing at approximately 6:00 p.m., the Supervisor of
Elections had the tabulating equipment based in the Elections Department at the
Stephen P. Clark Center tested to ascertain that the equipment will correctly count
the precinct and absentee ballot votes cast for all candidates and questions.
Seal number 047 g .7 ±11�y , used to secure the testing materials and seal
0 0 7 g c4Z S , used to seal the program microdisk, were broken in our
presence and the contents were used following the procedures of paragraph (2), to
complete this pre -count logic and accuracy test.
5. At the completion of this pre -count logic and accuracy test, all precinct and absentee
ballots cast were counted. Except as otherwise specifically set forth and declared in
this Certification, in our presence and sight, no ballot card was removed from or
added to any ballot card container, ballot card tray or other segregation of ballots,
and no ballot card was in any manner altered or tampered with by any person, and
no person touched any ballot card container, ballot card tray or ballot card, except a
person authorized to do so pursuant to Section 101.5614, Florida Statutes,
6. At the completion of the precinct and absentee ballot counts, the automatic
tabulating equipment was again tested to ascertain that the equipment correctly
counted the precinct and absentee votes cast for all candidates and questions.
7. At the completion of this post -count logic and accuracy test, all voted ballots with
their precinct header cards, and duplicated and spoiled ballots, were stored in
cabinets with seal numbers _ A oO7B4.t Z
F ov�83�3 ,
- 1 1
1 1
' 1 1
1
Page 2 of 3
1999 pall Municipal - t tions
Miami -Dade Coun ride November 2 1999
tY� ,
Similarly consigned and sealed were the verified logic and accuracy reports, ETNet
log, program microdisk (sealvr,: ), broken seals, and. the test ballots with
precinct header cards and stored under seal number oo-, a-35 s
All items, sealed as described above, were placed in the custody of the Supervisor
of Elections of Miami -Dade County, Florida, for subsequent delivery to the
respective City Clerks.
CANVASSING BARD REPRESENTATIVES:
City Clerk D6niel F. Dko-kh
Ci Hi leap
4t�
City Clerk Walter Foeman
Cft of Miami
_[� &'�_ e"_ - pa't' jt"�
Cify Clerk Robert Parcher
City of Miami Beach
Page 3 of 3
�J
S90a
r
CUMULATIVE FINAL MUNICIPAL PRIMARY, GENERAL, AND SPECIAL EL ONS Page 1
10:02pm Nov 2 1999 MIAMI-DARE COUNTY, FLORIDA
NOVEMBER 2, 1999
CITY OF HIALEAH
Precincts counted
Absentee Precincts Counted
Registered voters
Ballots Cast
COUNCILMEMBER - GROUP II
Rene Garcia
Evelio Medina
Luis M. Sorondo
COUNCILMEMBER - GROUP IV
Carmen Caldwell
Roiy More
Julio Ponce
COUNCILMEMBER - GROUP V
Raymundo Barrios
Esteban Bovo
Angel "Omar" Fajardo
HIALEAH QUESTIONS
CHARTER AMENDMENT
Yes
No
NON -BINDING STRAW BALLOT QUESTION
Yes
No
CITY OF MIAMI BEACH
Precincts counted
Absentee Precincts Counted
Registered Voters
Ballots Cast
MAYOR
Mike Calhoun
Neisen Kasdin
Leslie Martinez-Botet
Martin Shapiro
COMMISSSIONER - GROUP V
Joe Fontana
Luis Garcia
Charles Schaab
Richard L. Steinberg
Manny Warszayski
Lee Weiss
COMMISSIONER - GROUP VI
Matti Herrera Bower
Liliam Lopez
Mike Thompson
MIAMI BEACH QUESTIONS
RENAMING OCEAN BEACH PARK
Yes
No
BOND ISSUE FOR IMPROVEMENTS TO
NEIGHBORHOOD INFRASTRUCTURE
For bonds
Against bonds
BOND ISSUE FOR IMPROVEMENTS TO
PARKS AND BEACHES
For bonds
Against bonds
BOND ISSUE FOR FIRE SAFETY
39
100,00%
FACILITIES AND EQUIPMENT
1
100.00%
For bonds
S,379 68.S1%
68.709
100.00%
Against bonds
2,472
31.49%
16,385
23.85%
CODE AMENDMENT REDUCING RESORT TAX
ALLOCATION
9.438
66.54%
Yes
S,117
66.3S%
4,145
29.22%
No
2,59S
33.6S%
602
4.24%
CHARTER AMENDMENT INCREASING
SALARIES OF COMMISSIONERS AND MAYOR
6,032
41.32%
Yes
3,260 4132%
729
4.99%
No
4,592 S8.48%
7,839
S3.69%
CHARTER AMENDMENT TO PENSION FUNDS
FOR FIREMEN AND POLICEMEN
3,280
22.69%
Yes
5,341
69.33%
8,024
S5.51%
No
2,363
30.67%
3,1S2
21,80%
GENERAL EMPLOYEES' PENSION BOARD
PRUDENT PERSON STANDARD
4,938
47.89%
Yes
No
3,967
54.84%
5,374
52.11%
3,267
4S.16%
CITY OF MIAMI
8,797
61.69%
MIAMI COMMISSIONER - DISTRICT 1
S,462
38.31X
Precincts Counted
21
100.00%
Absentee Precincts Counted
1
100.00%
Registered Voters
20,740
100.00%
32
100.00%
Ballots Cast
4,891
23.58%
1
100.00%
MIAMI COMMISSIONER - DISTRICT 1
32,977
100.00%
Wifredo (Willy) Gort
3,00S
66.31%
9,876
29.9S%
Liliana Ros
1,527
33.69%
MIAMI COMMISSIONER - DISTRICT 2
269
4,693
2.86%
49.94%
Precincts Counted
Absentee Precincts
32
100.00%
543
5.78%
Counted
Registered Voters
1
100.00%
3,893
41.42%
Ballots Cast
28,433
100.00%
7,332
25.79%
2,177
24.54%
MIAMI COMMISSIONER - DISTRICT 2
3,091
34.84%
Rene Diaz
J. L. Plummer, Jr.
529
7,52%
1,062
11.97%
Jason Walker
2,S29
34.52%
1,678
18.91%
Johnny Winton
335
4.28%
625
7.04%
3,33E
54.76%
239
2.69%
MIAMI COMMISSIONER - DISTRICT 4
Precincts Counted
20
100.00%
4,S4S
50.57%
Absentee Precincts Counted
Registered Voters
1
100.00%
2,960
32.93%
Ballots Cast
28,549
100.00%
1,483
16.SO%
8 ,964
31.40%
MIAMI COMMISSIONER - DISTRICT 4
Agustin "Gus" Garcia
1,247
14.42%
4,719
59.86%
Tomas Regalado
Manolo Reyes
4,4S8
S1.SS%
3,165 40.14%
2,943
34.03%
MIAMI QUESTIONS
Precincts Counted
Absentee Precincts Counted
97 100.00%
4,283 S4.18%
Registered Voters
4 100.00%
3,622 4S.82%
Ballots Cast
122.674
100.00%
29,005
23.64%
CHARTER AMENDMENT FOR STRONG MAYOR
Yes
4,507 56.94%
No
14,153
S3.19%
3,408 43.06%
12,455
46.83X
'
CHARTER AMENDMENT FOR TERM LIMITS
Yes
No
16,491
72.52%
6,248
27.48%
Page 2
MUNICIPAL PRIMARY, GENERAL, AND SPECIAL E DNS
a CUMULATIVE FINAL �MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA c
ii"D
10:020ey Nov 2 1999af4` NOVEMBER 2, 1999
CHARTER AMENDMENT ESTABLISHING
INDEPENDENT AUDITOR GENERAL 14,560 58.89%
Yes 10,164 41.11.%
NO
1
0
CUMULATIVE !2
07:24pm Nov 2 1999
CITY OF HIALEAH
Precincts Counted
Absentee Precincts Counted
Registered Voters
Ballots Cast
COUNCILMEMBER - GROUP II
Rene Garcia
Evelio Medina
Luis M. Sorondo
COUNCILMEMBER - GROUP IV
Carmen Caldwell
Roly More
Julio Ponce
COUNCILMEMBER - GROUP V
Raymundo Barrios
Esteban Boyo
Angel "Omar" Fajardo
HIALEAH QUESTIONS
CHARTER AMENDMENT
Yes
NO
NON -BINDING STRAW BALLOT QUESTION
Yes
No
CITY OF MIAMI BEACH
Precincts Counted
Absentee Precincts Counted
Registered Voters
Ballots Cast
MAYOR
Mike Calhoun
Neisen Kasdin
Leslie Martinez-Botet
Martin Shapiro
COMMISSSIONER - GROUP V
Joe Fontana
Luis Garcia
Charles Schaab
Richard L. Steinberg
Manny Warszayski
Lee Weiss
COMMISSIONER - GROUP VI
Matti Herrera Bower
Liliam Lopez
Mike Thompson
MIAMI BEACH QUESTIONS
RENAMING OCEAN BEACH PARK
Yes
No
BOND ISSUE FOR IMPROVEMENTS TO
NEIGHBORHOOD INFRASTRUCTURE
For bonds
Against bonds
BOND ISSUE FOR IMPROVEMENTS TO
PARKS AND BEACHES
For bonds
Against bonds
MUNICIPAL PRIMARY, GENERAL, AND SPECIAL.+, IONS
MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA.`'#
NOVEMBER 2, 1999
ABSENTEE
BOND ISSUE FOR FIRE SAFETY
0 0.00% FACILITIES AND EQUIPMENT
0 0.00% For bonds
0 0.00% Against bonds
0 0.00%
CODE AMENDMENT REDUCING RESORT TAX
ALLOCATION
0 0.00% Yes
0 0.00% No
0 0.00%
CHARTER AMENDMENT INCREASING
SALARIES OF COMMISSIONERS AND MAYOR
0 0.00% Yes
0 0.00% No
0 0.00%
CHARTER AMENDMENT TO PENSION FUNDS
FOR FIREMEN AND POLICEMEN
0 0.00% Yes
0 0.00% No
0 0.00%
GENERAL EMPLOYEES' PENSION BOARD
PRUDENT PERSON STANDARD
Yes
0 0.00% No
0 0.00%
CITY OF MIAMI
0
0.00%
MIAMI COMMISSIONER - DISTRICT 1
0
0.00%
Precincts Counted
Absentee Precincts Counted
Registered Voters
Ballots Cast
0
0.00%
1
100.00%
MIAMI COMMISSIONER - DISTRICT 1
0
0.00%
Wifredo (Willy) Gort
484
---.--%
Liliana Ros
MIAMI COMMISSIONER - DISTRICT 2
22
5.02%
Precincts counted
176
40.18%
Absentee Precincts Counted
15
3.42%
Registered Voters
225
51.37%
Ballots Cast
MIAMI COMMISSIONER - DISTRICT 2
89
20.79%
Rene Diaz
103
24.07%
J. L. Plummer, Jr.
51
11.92%
Jason Walker
91
21.26%
Johnny Winton
54
12.62%
40
9.35%
MIAMI COMMISSIONER - DISTRICT 4
Precincts Counted
Absentee Precincts Counted
215
51.07%
Registered Voters
96
22.80%
Ballots Cast
110
26.13%
MIAMI COMMISSIONER - DISTRICT 4
Agustin "GUS" Garcia
Tomas Regalado
186
59.62%
Manolo Reyes
126
40.38%
MIAMI QUESTIONS
Precincts Counted
Absentee Precincts Counted
163
51.58%
Registered Voters
153
48.42%
Ballots Cast
CHARTER AMENDMENT FOR STRONG MAYOR
Yes
190
56.72%
No
14S
43.28%
CHARTER AMENDMENT FOR TERM LIMITS
Yes 16
No
Pacc
228 70.8n
94 29.194
226 68.28%
1.0S 31.72%
120 36.92%
20S 63.08%
213 67.41%
203 32.59%
134 45.42%
161 S4.58%
0 0.00%
1 100.00%
0 0.00%
243 -- .--%
155 72.77%
58 27.23%
0 0.00%
1 100.00%
0 0.00%
310---.--%
18 6.41%
101 3S.94%
18 6.41%
144 51.25%
0 0.00%
1 100.00%
0 0.00%
437 -- ,--%
47 11.5S%
205 SO.37%
1SS 38.08%
0 0.00%
4 100.00%
0 0.00%
1,346 -- .--%
614 S1.99%
S67 48.01X
750 71.56%
298 28.44%
r0t
1
CGMULATIVE #2 MUNICIPAL PRIMARY, GENERAL, AND SPECIAL IONS Vaar
07:24pm NOV 2 1499 MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA'
NOVEMBER 2, 1999
CHARTER AMENDMENT ESTABLISHING
INDEPENDENT AUDITOR GENERAL
Yes 624 S5.81%
No 494 44.19%
0
v ("
� _ C� eS U