Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutR-01-0926J -01-'72F3 9112/01 RESOLUT10N NO. 01— 926 A RESOLUTiON OF THE MIAMI CITY COMM:I:SS.; ON APPROVING 'ITIF: CMIEF PROCUREMENT OFFICER'S DECISION 'I'O RF'JFCT THE PROTEST OF MARTTN' S :HAMAR UNIFORMS, INC. AND HER DETERMINATION HAT 'I'HIn' PROTEST IIAS NO MERT.T IN CONNECTION W.T.TH 131D NO. 00-01.-23, FOR THE L)LJRCHASE OF UNIFORM ACCESSORIES FOR THE DEPARTMENT. 3E IT RESOLVED BY THE COMMISSION OF' `11JIF: CITY OF M=AMT FLORIDA: Section 1.. The Chief Procurement Officer's decision to rej ecr_ Laze protesr of Martin's Lamar Uniforms, Inc. and her determination that--- the L)rotest has no morit in connection with Bid No. 00-01.-02.3 for the purchase of uniform accessories for the Deparrment of Police is approved. CITY NEXT SEP 1 3 2001 uAsofutluo Na. 01- 9 2 6 .,. Section 2. Phis Resolution Shall become ef f ective immediately upon its adoption and SigTlatures of t:he Mayor.'/ PASSED AND ADOPTED this 13th — day of —September.—., 2001. JOE CAROLLO, MAYOR i!,, v!" k q. ,hc- PAnvor (Vti ml inclicate anprova"i of .... •.. ul t o: -n ATTEST: J. Rieman, City Clark WALI'ER J. FOEMAN CITY CLEF K APPRO)Je A,5r"'C;'ORM AND,0CeRRECTNESS:e// AJANDRO VILAMEtTIMOT OriTY ATTORNEY W5580:LB:LN:BSS --Ff Lhe Mayor does not sign rhJ.8 Reso'lu�:icn, it shall becollic: effective at. the end of ten calendar days from the date it was passed and , 7 I adopted. Tf the Mayor vetoes t.tlis Resolution, it: shall become 3CCOT ,If._ e. fact - fe ct v immedj.ately upon override (-.)!- Liie veto by Lhe City Commission. Page 2 of 2 ()1. 926 4 CITY OF MIAMI, FLORIDA '0' . 38 INTER -OFFICE MEMORANDUM TO The Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Commission 455 enez FROM:City City Manag RECOMMENDATION: DATE : AUG 2 9 SUBJECT; Resolution of Protest, Police Uniform Accessories REFERENCES: Bid No. 00-01-23 ENCLOSURES: FILE It is respectfully recommended that the City Commission adopt the attached resolution approving the Chief Procurement Officer's decision to reject the protest of Martin Lamar Uniforms in connection with Bid No. 00-01-23 for Police Uniform Accessories. BACKGROUND On November 20, 2000, the City of Miami solicited bids through Invitation for Bids (IFB) Bid No. 00-01-23 to provide uniform accessories for the Department of Police. The awarded bidder, Ander Police Supply defaulted on said contract and the City terminated same for failure to provide delivery of Uniform Accessories in a timely manner and to have a local storefront facility located in the City of Miami as required by Bid No. 00-01-023. Based upon the termination, the City Administration proceeded to recommend the award of the contract for police uniforms accessories to Harrison Uniform Company based upon the application of the 10% local preference. By letter dated July 10 2001, Martin Lamar Uniforms protested that Harrison Uniform Company should not be considered a local vendor and that award should be made to them as the next lowest responsive and responsible bidder. Pursuant to Section 18-99 of the City Code, the Chief Procurement Officer duly investigated the facts and detennined that the protest lacked merit, as detailed in the attached letter. It is therefore, recommended that the City Commission adopt the attached resolution approving the Chief Procurement Officer's decision to reject the protest of Martin Lamar Uniforms Enc. J- 926 CITY OF MIAMI, FLORIDA INTER -OFFICE MEMORANDUM TO: Carlos A. Gimenez DATE: August 15t, 2001 FILE City Manager SUBJECT: Rejection of protest received from Martin's Lamar Uniform, Inc. r Sid #00-01-23- Uniform Accessories FROM:+ REFERENCES Judy S. Ca r, (rector PurchaSin&. ent ENCLOSURES: I, hereby, request your approval of my rejection of the protest by Simon Ferro, Esq. on behalf of Martin's Lamar Uniform, Inc. related to the above noted bid for Uniform Accessories. The basis of my decision, as set forth in the attached letter, is the fact that Martin's Lamar Uniform, Inc. protest is without merit. Approved: �/ L.__11 -. - ___- Carlos A. Gimenez City Manager -Al Jandro Vilarel l y Attorney L' i 0j_, Nei 0 0 Titij nrf JUDY S. CARTER Director August 7, 2001 Mr. Simon Ferro Greenberg 'fraurig, P.A. 1221 Brickell Avenue Miami, Florida 33131 Re: Formal Protest: Bid No. 00-01-23 Police Uniform Accessories Dear Mr. Ferro: C:ARLOSA, GIMENEZ City Manager - VIA FAX AND REGULAR MAIL As Chief Procurement Officer of the City of Miami, I have received your formal protest dated July 10, 2001, on behalf of Martin's Lamm Uniforms (Lamar), relative to the above noted bid. Pursuant to my duties under Section 18-99 of the City of Miami Code, Resolution of protested solicitation and awards, I have reviewed the pertinent facts and documents and submit the following in response to your protest concerning the recommendation for award of contract to Harrison Uniform Company (Harrison) in the wake of the default of Ander Police Supply (_Ander): 1. Your protest asserts an entitlement to local preference as prescribed in the City of Miami Charter and Code based upon a trailer Lamar currently occupies on the City of Miami Police Department's property. Although Lamar does possess an occupational license for the trailer, the City has made no written commitment to your client that would permit it to remain at that site for any length of time. In fact, I would argue, but for the current contract for Police Uniforms (Bid No. 00-1-22) requiring Lamar to have either a storefront within the city limits or a trailer on the premises of the Police Department, Lamar would not have a local site, Under prior contracts, pursuant to Bid Nos. 96-97-035 and 96-97-036, the City allowed an informal and temporary trailer arrangement with Lamar to address the City Commission's concern about the loss of productivity and inconvenience to City police officers in traveling to Lamar's facility at 7230 NW 46" Street, As a compromise, the City allowed the sole bidder to locate a trailer on the City's property so that Lamar could better serve the needs of the City. of - DEPARTMENT Of PURCHASING/444 S.W.3nd Avenue, 61h Floor/Miami, Florida 33130/11rJ51416-19004ax: U05/SIG•19.; E -Mail Address: Uurchase4ri.mlami i1mw Wi4isite Adrlrp-w 111trrilri Miami 8 ua/ 9 • Subsequently, in the bid to which you refer (Bid No. 00-01-23), the City offered a similar opportunity to locate a trailer on the City's premises to the successful bidder if the vendor did not have a facility located in the City. This availability to all bidders nullifies the potential for the application of a local preference for this temporary trailer location. Given these realities, I am confident that Lamar cannot produce sufficient documentation to represent any commitment to Lamar beyond the scope of Lamar's contract to provide police uniforms. To suggest Lamar's entitlement to a local preference on the basis of a temporary trailer location on the City's property that was available to any successful bidder, betrays the substance and the spirit of the local preference law. Both Lamar and Harrison completed Primary Office Affidavits to claim eligibility for the local preference. That form notes, "the intention of this section (18-52.1(h) of the City Code] is to benefit local bona fide bidders/proposers to promote economic development within the corporate limits of the City of Miami (emphasis added)." Particularly, in that context, it is clear that a trailer located on the City's property is not equal to a bricks and mortar facility operated by Harrison at 3850 North Miami Avenue that predates a contract award from the City. In my estimation, a temporary trailer located on the City's property does not position Lamar to make an economic development contribution in the City. 2. Contrary to your contention regarding the City Commission's role in determining "nonlocal vendor" or "primary office," I direct your attention to Section 18-79(h) of the City Code, which notes, "the city manager... may submit recommendations to the city commission." The city commission will make the final determination as to whether the local preference will apply to this contract. Whether that requires a public hearing will be a decision for the city commission when the city manager submits his recommendation for award to the city commission. Nothing has occurred or was planned to derail the process set forth in the city code. Upon award of contract, the appropriate written notice would have been sent; however, such notice is not appropriate until the commission's award has been made. As you note, Section 18-90 acknowledges the role of the chief procurement officer prior to the city commission's award; however, no adverse decision regarding Lamar's responsibility has been made to warrant the notice that you claim to have been denied. The Code (Sections 18-78 and 18-90) is very specific on the definition and, scope of responsibility and it does not contemplate a question of locality. Hence, notice is not ripe until the city commission has awarded a contract and is only required under Section 18-79(h) • 0 to the lowest responsive and responsible bidder. Again, such an award has yet to occur. 3. With regard to your question regarding the sufficiency of Harrison's Miami facility as a "primary office", you should be aware that this situation is one that the City has encountered previously. You should note that the precedent has been established by the City Commission to recognize an established facility such as Harrison Uniform's facility. The relative establishment of other facilities nationally or regionally has not been relevant to the City Commission's determinations in the past. In conclusion, I must reiterate that the "award" to Harrison is a recommendation at this point. At the next regular commission meeting, the recommendation will be submitted to the City Commission for a final determination. Having carefully considered and investigated all allegations and arguments, I hereby reject the formal protest filed in behalf of Martin's Lamar Uniforms. The City Manager and City Attorney have concurred with my decision to reject the protest. This matter will be considered by the City Commission at its meeting of 1'hursday, September 13, 2001, to be held at 3500 Pan American Drive, Coconut Grove. The meeting will begin at 9:30am. Respectfully submitted, Judy Carted �� t C S� Procurement Officer Encl. c: Carlos A. Uimenez, City Manager Alejandro Vilarello, City Attorney Rafael O. Diaz, Assistant City Attorney Robert J. Nachlinger, Assistant City Manager Raul Martinez, Police Chief Jorge Manressa, Major 0...-w 9ti6 6flEENB�flG A T T 0 R N P. 1'. S A T 1. A 1flflGflIG Simon Ferro (305) 579-0644 Direct Fax: (305) 961-5644 E -Mail: ferrosLgtlaw.com July 10, 2001 VIA HAND -DELIVERY Ms. Judy S. Carter, Director Purchasing Department City of Miami Miami Riverside Center 444 S.W. 2"d Avenue, 6" Floor Miami, FL 33130 Re: Formal Protest: Bid #00-01-23• Uniform Accessories Dear Ms. Carter: Our office represents Martin's Lamar Uniforms, a division of Superior Uniform Group, Inc., a Florida corporation (Martin's) in the above described bid/contract process. It is our understanding that the above-described bid/contract was originally awarded to Anders Police Supply (Anders) and that subsequently the City of Miami (City) revoked and nullified Anders' rights under the bid/contract on the basis of non- performance. Our client, the second lowest bidder in the process, has further informed us that, pursuant to Sec. 18-79 (h) of the Charter and Code of the City of Miami, the City intends to award the above described bid/contract to Harrison Uniform Company (Harrison), the third lowest bidder. If so, such a decision would require a determination by the City that Harrison is a "responsible and responsive bidder whose primary office is located in the city", and that Martin's would not meet those qualifications. If the above facts are true, we respectfully request that you review and reconsider the City's decision and, based on the following facts and arguments, award the bid/contract to Martin's : If the Anders contract has in fact been cancelled or revoked, then Martin's, as the next lowest responsive and responsible bidder, should be awarded the contract and, in accordance with Sec. 15-79 (h), should be notified in writing, with reasonable promptness, of the award. Subsection (h) further states that if said lowest responsive and GREFNRUIIC TRAURIC 11OFFMAN LIPOI'F ROSF.N & QUENTEI., P.A. 1221 1tHIf.KELL A1'FNI1I: MIAMI, FLORIDA 33131 305.579-0500 FAX 305-579-071 7 MIAMI NEw YORK WASIIINGTON, D.C. PHILADELPHIA SAO PA111.0 Fowr LAUDERDALE WEST PALM REACH Om.ANUo TALLARASSFF BOCA RATON 0 0 Ms. Judy S. Carter, Director July 10, 2001 Page 2 responsible bidder is nonlocal, the city commission may offer the contract to another responsive and responsible bidder whose primary office is located in the city. However, we believe that the determination of what constitutes a "nonlocal vendor" or a "primary office" is a question of fact for the City Commission to make in a public hearing with due notice to all parties concerned and an opportunity for Martin's to defend its rights under the contract . It is our belief that a determination by a person or agency other than the City Commission as to who is or not a "nonlocal vendor" or what constitutes a "primary office located within the city" has the same effect on a potential bidder as a determination of nonresponsibility pursuant to Sec. 18-90, and that the same rights to proper notice and rebuttal before the determining person or agency should be given. No such opportunities have been accorded Martin's. We further respectfully submit that Harrison's Miami office cannot be considered a "primary office" as contemplated by Sec. 18-79 (h). According to the enclosed copies of the Florida Department of State, Division of Corporations, Public Inquiry, Harrison's principal address is 4545 Malsbary Rd., Cincinnati, Ohio. Harrison's Registered Agent is CT Corporation System, located at 1200 S. Pine Island Road, Plantation, Florida. Harrison's officers and directors all reside in Cincinnati, Ohio. In addition, Harrison has longer -established Florida offices located in Jacksonville, St. Petersburg and Orlando, Florida. Martin's is a wholly owned subsidiary of Superior Uniform Group, Inc., whose principal address is in Seminole, Florida ar..d whose corporate officers and directors all reside within the State, as evidenced by the enclosed copies of Superior's corporate papers. Martin's has a City office address located upon the grounds of the City of Miami Police Station at 400 N.W. 2 Avenue, Miami, Fl., as evidenced by the attached copy of the City of Miami occupational license. The City office is a legally permitted trailer established at said location at the request and for the convenience of the City of Miami police. Martin's has an additional office.located at 7230 N.W. 46 Street, Dade County, Florida. If Harrison's Miami office is determined to qualify as a "primary office" then, applying the same criteria, Martin's Miami office should qualify as well. If Martin's Miami office fails to qualify as a "primary office" then, applying the same criteria, Harrison's Miami office should fail to qualify as well. Under either of the above two scenarios, the above contract should be awarded to the next lowest bid after Anders, which would be Martin's. Although it is unclear whether this Formal Written Protest is required by the bid regulations or City code, we respectfully submit it in an over -abundance of caution and to preserve any and all rights our client Martin's may have in this process. Enclosed is a Gner;rqsr.Nc TRAURlG, P.A. Ms. Judy S. Carter, Director July 10, 2001 Page 3 check in the amount of $3,487.06, representing the bond required under Sea 18-99(f) of the City of Miami Code. If you have any questions, please do rte+ hesitate to call me. %\MIA-SRVO1 \FerroS1132328Ov051sd1sORDOM 10/01 GREFNRER(: TRAURIC, P.A. h l . 5. 2001 t:,bPM • Martin's Uniforms Jury a, cool Clty of Mlsmi Purchasing departn+ent Miami Rhnralde Center 4" DW 2"e Avenue, 0 floor Miami, FL 33130 Atte. Judy S. Carter, Direobr X10.6D0 P. 2 This letter will asrva of official notification of Martin's Unlforme Intent to file a written prWAW In compliance with Part 11 The Coda, Chapter 10 Finance, Article III Purchasing Contreah Generally, fta.18414 Resolution of probated sollcltellons and award, psrWeph (a) Right to Probst; and based on the Inbnded decision to award old Number 00-0143 Uniform Accessories to Harrison uniforrns. •Ineerat TVIapner aidant; arketino Martin's Uniforms This will owe u confirmation of *-mail tent on July So 2001. :320 Wac 1 il/rborough Avenue • Tampa, F. 33603 Cwtomer 5avice (800) 627.8467 a Phore (81;1) 877-0511 ♦ Fax (819) 879.0107 _ 9 2 t1 Vebrira wvrw.rrirrWkwihrmw.eoa% • e -ma; e�rncletineetl�unnilorcM.eom .An %mKlw Soadc Pjah p Wad Company � �� ' • �.`.-a`;` �•i;�;-•-� �2°r,. s�. � .u��r.{•• Nflfr •iy :ar •s .�ali�i {_ -' ;�: T}E'OPEF�A?W . ;;;: t..`" i►T �i ••i•• •'rn 'Y•i •.f- Dl. :� .<'' .i- 4J 1•-�..v. .1.�' • -1. .f: '/� - .1 7 . _ ! Ir 1.: �j•t'. �,. •.i-• .+., ,y.cc.•� .t.� :.'`r•�r,;ytd•'....- iri 1 .. .. t. .ri-, ta'• 'la.�-� �•1.!` %��� ra":,:� .��=� '.furl• '� •.•: �ir,f':i`! ieSN'rpi:vti' _.,:f - :.;' -' :/- nw'w;: ;' :ar x..l-��;:� ��.�"= ;,.. ►;.. �• ,�.:;. 'l` 5 �t.T a _ is - •t ..r .i. y. Vii. Jl- _ 1 ,+.-'!::'.. � ,{.-IF"4,'r;�;!�•:rl�a:.r�.i.�:?fix .��• 5►:.. :1«�:%' � •.K •�.tl.;�;::� .l .tr •.a. s- '•� ! j.. a- T- Lli:��• •� �� - - :�.. � �r .. t -I • •.c: .�'1� � - .. � 1. -. '• "� . ti, Irl,'.•{.. •�.'ic: _ ..�•. - • _�' ><!•. %_ j '; ':r>.rr. 1� .S'• -Tri _ 'm AfW . S-: • ,.:'. � � : W :firms:. _ jj y...:. Z. -71 i, z- -71 i, 7 0 0 - Registered Agent Name & Address BENSTOCK, MICHAEL 10099 SEMINOLE BLVD SEMMOLE FL 33772-2539 71 _ Nam Cbanbed: 04121/1998 Address Changed: 04/21/1998 Officer/Director Detail Florida Profit F- Name & Address SUPERIOR UNIFORM GROUP, INC. V ip SCHIVARTZ,ALAN 10099 SEMINOLE BLVD PD PRINCIPAL ADDRESS 10099 SEMINOLE BLVD SEMINOLE FL 33772-2539 Changed 04/21/1998 MAILING ADDRESS PO BOX 4002 SEMINOLE FL 33775-0002 Changed 03/29/1999 Document Number FEI Number Date Filed P97000046412 111385670 05/27/1997 State Status Effective Date FL ACTIVE NONE Last Event Event Date Filed Event Effective Date CORPORATE MERGER 05/19/1998 NONE Registered Agent Name & Address BENSTOCK, MICHAEL 10099 SEMINOLE BLVD SEMMOLE FL 33772-2539 71 _ Nam Cbanbed: 04121/1998 Address Changed: 04/21/1998 Officer/Director Detail 01-9 w ) F- Name & Address Title BENSMCK,PETER 10099 SEMINOLE BLVD SEMINOLE FL 33772 r V ip SCHIVARTZ,ALAN 10099 SEMINOLE BLVD PD 01-9 w ) SEMINOLE FL 33772 SEHECHTEK SAUL 10099 SEMiNOLE BLVD SEMINOLE FL 33772 Filed Date J1 Intangible Tax BENSTOCK, MICHAEL 10099 SEMINOLE BLVDSEMINOLE FL 33772 BENSTOCK, GERALD M 10099 SEMINOLE BLVD r 03/29/1999 _ Y SEMINOLE FL 33772 I DEMOTT, ANDREW D JR10099 r oa/IOnODI Y SEMINOLE BLVD =]CF SEMINOLE FL 38772 Annual Renorts Re ort Year Filed Date J1 Intangible Tax 1999 r 03/29/1999 _ Y 2000 �r-05/ISn000 I 2001 r oa/IOnODI Y View Events No Name ^History Information Vew_DocumentImages) THIS IS NOT OFFICIAL RECORD; SEE DOCUMENTS IF QUESTION OR CONFLICT 0 01- 926 SUPERIOR UNIFORM GROUP, INC. Document Number Date Filed Effective Date Status P97000046412 05/27/1997 None Active EVENT TYPE FILED EFFECTIVE DESCRIPTION DATE DATE ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ CORPORATE MERGER 05/19/1996 MERGING : 623515 MERGED INTO : P970 00046412 AND RESTATED 04/21/1996 S THIS IS NOT OFFICIAL RECORD; SEE DOCUMENTS IF QUESTION OR CONFLICT 01 926 2000 UNIFORM •USINEGG REPOMIUDR1 • am DOCUMENT #� P9700004"I2 PILED 1. rwvm .... I.. May 15, 2000 8:00 surIr�irnForwlraAOlm, INC. Secretary of State 03-13.2000 9D203 020 •••150.00 plfdpa lLudf�NerM IAeMmp Atlr'M fm lewmf D:w PO IN 4w www FL Stmax sLmmu k JJt/S�t 00 NOT WN1I M flab WACE a. rrv*" 9adwi.rr s 4AympA00reo S,Ar. AOL i. it S.r. MI• S. 210. c fa D A Ch a Eine 4L iE1 nr or 11.1 16610 ~ip6e0 Nei zip. �iY ZAP Canlry f. Cr14sA d 9:A11w Oni.d r) ie•ari "ft W M i. IIAmr �/ aeiN. M hm O�ISTOM Iwr;M Name SVW AWISW In O. Da kk~ r Na Aauran 10 011 5 9 6 01E OLVO SEWME FL 7!772.330 a. Tfr.uorr nmrd ray rerwy 1w MAtarrrA for mo pv1� d dr^9np a nyllw.d dila a niiarriA iOi^1, d omt n h Sur d i1aWe. 81GNATIaE � r� A.rq O......�. gr•.MA titi,.A.. Voar�..A.......,.....ap a1i61: dimerin i MpIBr W iANif1 M e lr Yale cy„rana F9.! NOYFIII m 19:110.00 • la c�eRonCampea lNa�c+ p 13.00 wr w .reset. r aew MW WAY 1, =1 Faa 00 b 11F000 rm,a:rwcmia�or+ ❑ Aaewrre. tss.ca�l.meeelu o rWlaChldlFgitlite0gl1w1wIa11Wi 11. a+#( t9 T 1L A0 XTA7NW ANDES TO 300 ANO 011E 011 ' n 0tl1° o p• r r3— w.i grlb: OH1810CK`PETEN , w a "uM 00193a91UIM SWPAW s mv•n•w 69NW FL 337M u1•i+•e , o o.rr o a.n1 v MIM 1 1: O WARM ALAN +w f1AiRA00i(fi 100N89U1O 000 mmMawa an.ST.ai ! E FL 337Mic"41-W an•n•r — r "d _.. _1011 0 0ea1 q Arum ma WA MIT— 10011 Sa191= ILW tn•n•ar SE1QIOlE FL 32Man•:1.Ir ❑ 0rr1 l7 Aigm awt E915i0 k MCH R A� :w1*— M0WS91M101EBLVD$1-woowss aT.v.Tr SBSWW FL 331Marr.il•Ir lft tmt p u.al ❑ AWhm MrOCK GUM M WAS + Imp SOME VDsw ooma a^`•A•s S9AIOLE FL 337Man•a•ri Iml CFO ❑ a.ql ❑ Ae9aa WK OmTr. AtOlrttill 0 �i -L MWAr I= SEIL9101E OLVOfwi)AOdiC � R•� UMNO E FL 31M fi 1 P096V aMiN aelir YJormA►ma�pAp� .nn Ni, IVImliCafeEn W due M gLwfYbvw"ww Om.WU-sawom/1107 xi iWWN swkAw l Mfereeft fair CA&Mm m -0001! WaAoplUlarYalfepolbYlriMW aDCIRer a•1ifa Ary ww"m" WW Nnr f�A�dlect es Rrrrpeyprpipy p,pl rnn iiow ar dlecb W=I. it rea►rr ar Yutta.r100.rAd w Aaitur fti rWd1 s+ w7W W N Chow q7. NpYi6rMa: rr01hO mY rW1r epPWA M Dioct 11 r &ft& 1=1 dwpi0.dOn N.aACmM.P W1 r.O . rfegafW GYe MpawsW. SIGNATURE: =- - A�e.Ai S10nwH ArIW� DAt•10 rrAP .IAIAAI. L� N' 2S 1oF 111: 9r if AMr f�rwwr♦� 11 u Florida Profit HARRISON UNIFORM COMPANY PRINCIPAL ADDRESS 4545 MALSBARY RD CINCINNATI OH 45242 _.. _ _..__...._._......_.._ ... _..-_..... ------ -- MAILING ADDRESS 4545 MALSBARY RD CINCA` NATI OH 45242 Document Number FEI Number Date Filed 373946 591323123 01/21/1971 State Status Effective Date FL ACTIVE NONE Registered Agent ddress IN SYSTEM \ND ROAD FL 33324 )7102/1992 07/02/1992 Officer/Director Detail Name & Address Title BOSSART, JEANNE C 4545 MALSBARY RD S CINCINNATI OH KINSTLER, BRAD FF 4545 MALSBARY RD p CINCINNATI OH 45242 HELDMAN, FRED 4545 MALSBARY VP 11 CINCII4NAT1 OH 45242 Annual Reports Report Year Filed Date Intangible Tax t999 05/05/1999. 2000 � 04r26r2000 2001 ----JF- 04/2512001 N fru t `Nexfi Ali EON - 6- 11 No Events No Name History Information View Document Imaged . I -- --------- —.- - OWLS) THIS IS NOT OFFICIAL RECORD; SEE DOCUMENTS IF QUESTION OR CONFLICT f 2000 UNIFORM RUEINESS REPOtf IRR) DOCUMENT # 375946 ' I. FJYryflM Apr 26, 2000 8:00 am wUN+M UWORM COI MY Secretary of State 0446.2000 90058 006 •••150.00 >' ?N FlscebArmen WkVAdlrsu �fb IIAIjAAl11 b 4w MALSMY SD 000"T1 ON.Brit CIMC44YIA ON Ay71tJ� leis �1 m leis a n.cwin.e•aew,.N Aeewtl DO NOT WRItf N1M5 SFrCE 51W,AW. •, Me Sue•. AOL �. r:O.. cer a Sir. cnr a slat• •. TN -ow 59-1323123Fd JPWAWe•bl• Lo caunMy xp Cowry e. C•rtt0srM9rwOnIN p F"s••7 oaNjww sM AMwNMQ>rrnt Mwr - _ _ 1. o,r Arr•r et/hr Nam CT CORPORATION SYSTEM S1M•I A"&U (P.O. a" tanmr • Nd ACCOWAM) 1200 S. FIR 15111N0 ROAD KWfATWN Fl. =24 CeJ Ft Ip Cada 0. Ttr aWw wmd wt*y Wemm 014 •rrtrM W w pKWPM a pri 9 kl w94.pad alto a OgWlmod mWt n boft in w SWa a FbrWS. SKWMVURE syrw,M�ur Mr,+++rq�e•e•nrr,rerMrr,r now'Aae�aew•w�++.�r�+—•a rem L TM vo mum Is 60bw lr 09.11 U 1%"bw FILE NOWIII FEE 19 $150A - 1C EAectrn csrwtpn F.Wtlnp iS.DO wr w Tu (6V roquvo rw •nO d.ys n W so. At* MAY 1, 7M0 Fee wIA M $040 "I Fuad Cm•AsAbn Cl ANO b Fe" Is" Virls m b•cU 0 WkO CMtll ayrMs b ppMMtr to ftsL• tT. OrmamANDCiRECTORS TL AnonIONSICl1AN0ESr00aF1CFlgAN IN 11 trti ❑ Orub tau [low ❑ 44"m wm BOSM. JEANNE C rll• nwom t 454 KUSBW VD STW AD"m Gn•axM CNC "Tj ON en -41 -up -- ea, P �~ lDlorm mu President 000W EES am BYIME,PAYM will Brad Kinstler lttataooaOt 45451M1OMFID 4545 Malsbary Road ao•st•s 1D1CANNATI ON 15242 an.sl s tmtVP -•-- - Dorm -mu-, O.Chww OA"don »rr NEIDMAK FRED WA teutAm•ss 4515 YILLSBARY [MOAN" M.P.& CtUM71 ON 45242 tm•s•� __ D GI's b Aur. mu ❑ Pnm tial ..� wr ma mum wu s•atac AM 771.61•!! DIT•r-ir VU ❑Ct" ❑A6L- loll ..-._.•__❑L.M ewll mw MAW= 61e1li ILP•Sf Gndt.tM tlndl•t>r rm[ O Oros Cl AWM mu 4 Dow wrr elle muuwl•ss 6rm amass Gtr.n.s 7n•n s ta, Iia �iamwiN•�,•n�alor�a ae.•G•. CMQd. 0 04 GA SMrMn.IWPwN +eta SIGNATURE: :o ill h.:e we a:rr rpr ilu"ciiin sm uneroe Fww"0 VAXh I aa.A 12 CrIww eo7, nolo. eu•sw: as Mrf wy nen • •rvww .91x1 110 a oca to a ID iir6 at11t.A.6 W., (O.t 1 01 926 20O1 UNIFORM BU8088 REPORT (lldR) FILED DOCUMENT # 375946 Apr 25, 200108:00 AM 1. ,ntrtyName Secretary of State HAMS014 UNIFORM COMPANY principal Place of Business Mailing Address 4644 MAL:MRY ND - 4545 NAL6eARV RD _ CINCINNATI on CiNC1NNATi ON - 40242 45245 00 NOT WRITE IN THIS SPACE Z Prinolpal Place of Business 3. Mailing Address Suite. Apt. 0. etc. Suite. Apt. III, etc. City & State City & State 4. FEI Number AppEed Far 59-1 23123Na Appr�at: zipCountry == I Zip I Country si. CerUiicate of Status Desired Q $8.76 AdWkwW O. Name and Address of Current Registered Agent 7. Name and Address of Now Realliterred A ant Name CT CORPORATION SS'STEM - Street Address (P.O. Box Number is Not Acceptable) IlM S. PINE ISLAND ROAD PLANTATION tI. 33324 City FL I zp coda S. The above nerved entity submits_tUs statement for the purpose of changing its registered olfice or registered agent. or both. in the State of Mori" - 04/25/2001 Srt3NATURB • E-ra"W rwaro* adWNa'msauNbfo"Wd we I awkew. WMPAOowe 9. This corpotatlon is eilgible to satisfy Its Intangible Tax filing requirement and elects to do so." -HLE:H0- MJ111'Z'�6b� ea ' Q `" r � 10. Erection CampaIgn Ffnarncinj; $5.00 mly at •^'`40 tr"" ' TrM Fund Contribuii im CI Added to Faea (See criteria on back CI, ascneat aariti�,atq it. OFFICERS AND aAECTWIS sz Aoainn?JQie+AN69 TO OFFICERS AM DIRECT M IN 11 WLE VP ❑ Dlkb Tnu ❑ C&V D Ad6* NAIL FIRT MAN FRED NAME STI WAOD1iES5 4545 MAIABARY S1111W)DDAESS CRY-ST•Zp CINCINNATI on 43242 CITY -sr -bp TITLE t © Ddde TRI£ P ® cww C3 Addb WAS BYRNE PATRLCK NAME WINSTLER BRAD STWADM 4545MALSBARYRD STNEhT=KU 4545MAIABASLYRD OTY-ST-rep CINCINNATI OH 45242 Cv-ST-Dp CINCWNA77 Oil 45242 T e ❑ IhI* Tru a cww (3«do NAItE $OSSART, JEANNE C NAME STFfIETADO= 4545MAIABARYRD STA&TADDRESS arr-ST-Ir CINCINNATI OH CRY -ST -211, TIILE ❑ Delete TIRE ❑ CJhm ❑ AM NAME fum SM917ADDIIEW aTWAODIIlSS CRY•st-vp ATY•ST•ilp TITLE ❑ Dente TITLE ❑ Ow* O Ad& NMR NAME SMWADwiss STIIFFTAODDESS CRY -ST -IIP NETT-sT•ilp mix 17 Delete TIRE p Marge ❑ A00 INANE NAME SnWADOMM 5IAffTADDIM CRY -W -NP CITY -ST -ZIP 13. 1 he certily Mt the Intormallon supplied wRh this int V does not quality fde the exemption %%W in Section 119.07 3)(i). Florida Statutes. I hunter tardy that Nle information indicated on this report or supplemental report is true and accurate and that my signature shall have the same legal a ect as It made under oath; that 1 am an officer or dlreefor of the corporation or the receiver or trustee empowered to execute this report as required by Chapter GO?, Florida Statutes; and that ny name appetus in Blade t T or B3 xk 12 i changed, or on an attachment with an address. with all other like empowered. SIGNATURE: FREDHRLI)M" VP 041M001 ^� 'i -- g `20 ` _ 3IOMNLINANDT"IMoRPAW= OAM99FWowaorpleaT0111D ecroa t1rr. o.wnwnwe