Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutR-03-0905J-03-694 7/24/03 RESOLUTION NO. 03- 905 A RESOLUTION OF THE MIAMI CITY COMMISSION DIRECTING THE CITY MANAGER AND THE CITY ATTORNEY TO ENGAGE PROFESSIONAL EXPERT SERVICES TO PERFORM AN IN-DEPTH ANALYSIS OF AD -VALOREM TAXATION, COMPARING ASSESSMENTS TO PROPERTY OWNERS OF THE CITY OF MIAMI TO THOSE PROPERTY OWNERS OF UNINCORPORATED MIAMI-DADE COUNTY; DIRECTING THE CITY ATTORNEY TO PROCEED WITH APPROPRIATE APPEAL OR LEGAL ACTION TO PROTECT THE CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS OF CITY OF MIAMI TAXPAYERS; ALLOCATING FUNDS, IN AN AMOUNT NOT TO EXCEED $25,000 PLUS COSTS AND EXPENSES AS APPROVED BY THE CITY ATTORNEY, FROM AN ACCOUNT TO BE IDENTIFIED BY THE CITY MANAGER, FOR THE CITY ATTORNEY'S ENGAGEMENT OF AN ATTORNEY SPECIALIZING IN TAX MATTERS; FURTHER AUTHORIZING THE EXECUTION OF ALL NECESSARY DOCUMENTS, IN A FORM ACCEPTABLE TO THE CITY ATTORNEY, REQUIRED FOR SAID PURPOSE. BE IT RESOLVED BY THE COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI, FLORIDA: Section 1. The City Manager and the City Attorney are directed to engage professional expert services to perform an in-depth analysis of ad -valorem taxation, comparing assessments CITY COMMISSION MEETING OF J U L 2 4 2003 Resolution NO- 03- 905 to property owners of the City of Miami to those property owners of unincorporated Miami -Dade County. Section 2. The City Attorney is directed to proceed with appropriate appeal or legal action to protect the constitutional rights of City of Miami taxpayers, with funds, in an amount not to exceed $25,000 plus costs and expenses as approved by the City Attorney, allocated from an account to be identified by the City Manager for the City Attorney's engagement of an attorney specializing in tax matters. Section 3. The execution of any necessary documents, in a form acceptable to the City Attorney, is authorizedll for said purpose. Section 4. This Resolution shall become effective immediately upon its adoption and signature of the Mayoral 1� The herein authorization is further subject to compliance with all requirements that may be imposed by the City Attorney, including but not limited to those prescribed by applicable City Charter and Code provisions. If the Mayor does not sign this Resolution, it shall become effective at the end of ten calendar days from the date it was passed and adopted. If the Mayor vetoes this Resolution, it shall become effective immediately upon override of the veto by the City Commission. Page 2 of 3 03 905 PASSED AND ADOPTED this 24th day of ATTEST:,,,-`-"' ,- PRISCILLA A. HO P ON CITY CLERK AP NDR(TVILARELLO ATTORNEY W7432:BSS CORRECTNESS Page 3 of 3 July , 2003. /NUEL A. DIAZ, MAYOR 03- 905 C'Tt#ir of fflia i, �Flvri a F JOHNNY L. WINTON INCOX�-OWED COMMISSIONER rd�co¢� Real Estate Tax Analysis P.O. BOX 330708 MIAMI, FL 33233-0708 (305) 250-5333 FAX (305) 579-3334 ■ To show the percentage change in Miami -Dade County and City of Miami taxes from 2001 to 2002 ■ 600+ samples taken from Unincorporated Dade, City of Miami, Coral Gables, Miami Beach and Hialeah Criteria: Single Family Homes with Homestead Exemption - only Method: (Property Taxes 2002 divided by property taxes 2001 minus 1 ) x 100 = Percentage change in property taxes from 2001 to 2002 SUM: Sum of all the terms in row MODE: The most frequently occurring value MEAN: ( Sum of values without an * ) divided by ( number of values without an *) (For verification, see attached highlighted items) Our sample shows beth the mean and the mode of the percentage change from 2001 to 2002 The County column is significantly lower in Unincorporated Areas as compared to Incorporated Areas The modes and means of the percentage change from 2001 to 2002 on the County column in Unincorporated Areas ranged from 2.5 % to 3.7% versus a range of 6.7% to 14.8% on incorporated areas; such as, City of Miami, Coral Gables, Hialeah, Miami Beach. Data compiled by intern Alejandro Diaz from Commissioner Johnny Winton's office 03- 905 fid -Valorem 7axAnafysis }''ear 2002 Unincorporated Dade Properties Property % Change County % Change Unincor . Area C-10 2.5 2.4 C-11 2.3 2.5 C-12 2.4 2.4 C-13 2.9 3.6 C-14 2.4 2.45 C-15 2.7 2.2 C-16* -27.0 -53.6 C-17 2.3 6.6 C-18 2.3 2.6 C-19 2.5 2.4 C-20 2.7 2.4 C-21 2.8 2.2 C-22 2.55 2.5 ,C-23 * -7.9 -12.85 C-24 3.1 2.0 C-25 2.9 2.2 C-26 2.9 2.2 C-27 2.8 2.2 C-28 2.8 2.3 C-28 2.8 2.2 C-30 2.7 2.3 C-31 2.8 2.2 C-32 2.9 2.2 03-- 905 C-33 3.0 2.1 C-34 2.8 2.3 C-35 2.7 2.3 C-36 2.7 2.0 C-37* 13.4 18.4 C-38 2.9 2.2 C-39 2.95 3.9 C-40 3.0 2.1 C-41 2.7 2.35 C-42 2.65 2.4 C-43* 14.2 18.5 C-44 2.65 2.4 C-45 2.8 2.2 C-46 2.7 2.3 C-47 2.9 2.2 C-48 3.1 2.0 C-49 2.75 2.3 C-50 2.3 2.0 C-51 2.0 2.0 C-52 2.2 2.0 C-53 2.2 2.8 C-54 2.0 3.0 C-55 2.2 2.0 C-56 1.65 2.0 C-57 3.0 2.0 C-58 -3.35 -6.6 C-59 3.1 2.0 C-60 3.2 1.9 sum 111.55 74.65 MODE 2.8 12.2 03- 905 MEAN 12.52 12.21 1 03- 905 fid -valorem 7axAnafysis )''ear 2002 Unincorporated Dade Properties Property % Change County % Change Unincor . Area C-61 3.1 2.0 C-62 2.3 2.0 C-63 1.7 2.1 C-64* 1.5 2.1 C-65 2.1 1.95 C-66 2.4 2.0 C-67 2.1 2.1 C-68 1.9 2.15 C-69 1.7 2.0 C-70 2.9 2.1 C-71 12.5 14.0 C-72 14.3 17.2 C-73 3.1 2.0 C-74 3.1 2.0 C-75 3.1 2.0 C-76 3.1 2.0 C-77 3.1 2.0 C-78 3.0 2.1 C-79 3.0 2.1 C-80* 34.1 47.2 C-81 3.1 2.0 C-82 3.2 2.0 C-83 3.0 2.1 03- 905 C-84* -6.1 -10.2 C-85 3.0 2.1 C-86 3.15 2.0 C-87 2.8 2.2 C-88 3.0 2.05 C-89 3.2 1.9 C-90 3.1 2.0 C-91 3.15 2.0 C-92 3.1 2.0 C-93 3.12.0 C-94 3.1 _ 2.0 C-95 3.0 2.1 C-96 3.0 2.1 C-97 3.1 2.0 C-98 3.1 2.0 C-99 3.0 2.1 C-100 12.5 15.2 C-101 10.9 12.1 C-102 5.45 4.7 C-103 3.1 2.0 C-104 2.9 2.1 C-105 3.1 2.0 C-106 2.9 2.15 C-107 3.0 2.1 C-108 3.1 2.0 C-109* 17.2 21.2 C-110 3.0 2.1 SUM MODE MEAN 220.35 3.1 3.775 207.2 2.0 3.19 03- 905 Ad-Naforem 7aXAnafysis Year 2002 Unincorporated Area Property % Change if proposed budget change is made- County % Change if proposed budget change is made- City % Change if no budget change is made- County % Change if no budget change is made- City C-111* 17.62 15.0 7.2 8.5 C-112 4.9 2.5 -4.4 -3.3 C-113 -15.2 -22.4 -20.4 -26.8 C-114 3.0 -2.1 -3.3 -3.7 C-115 3.2 3.5 -1.9 2.35 C-116* -19.1 -31.1 -23.15 -35.0 C-117 8.11 8.6 0.9 2.4 C-118 4.5 2.1 -4.8 -3.7 C-119 2.542.4 -2.4 -3.4 sum 9.57 _ -21.5 MODE MEAN 1.57 -0.77 03- 905 old -valorem 7aXAnaCysis Year 2002 Unincorporated Area Property % Change Count % Change Cit C-120 3.0 2.7 C-121 2.9 2.1 C-122 1.5 0.0 C-123* -15.2 -22.4 C-124 3.0 2.1 C-125 3.0 2.1 C-126 3.0 2.1 C-127* 12.7 16.9 C-128 2.9 2.1 C-129 3.5 3.8 C-130 3.2 3.5 C-131* -19.1 -31.1 C-132 3.2 1.95 C-133 5.8 3.4 C-134* 17.6 15.0 C-135 4.9 2.5 SUM 35.9 6.75 MODE 3.0 2.1 MEAN 3.325 2.36 033- 905 Ad -Valorem 7aXAnafysis Year 2002 City of Miami Property % Change County % Change City C-217 6.8 0.6 C-218 6.9 0.6 C-219 7.1 0.6 C-220 6.8 0.6 C-221 7 0.6 C-222 7.2 0.7 C-223 7 0.6 C-224 6.8 0.6 C-225 7.2 0.6 C-226 8.6 0.8 C-227 8.3 0.8 C-228* 69.2 17.6 C-229 9.9 0.8 C-230 9.1 0.8 C-231 7.1 0.6 C-232 6.8 0.5 C-233 19.4 11.8 C-234* 6.7 0.5 C-235 6.7 0.5 C-236 6.7 0.5 C-237 6.8 0.5 C-238 6.9 0.6 C-239 6.7 0.5 03- 905 C-240 6.7 0.5 C-241 * 49.4 35 C-242 6.7 0.5 C-243 43.3 30.7 C-244 6.7 0.5 C-245 6.7 0.5 C-246 6.7 0.5 C-247 6.9 0.6 C-248 6.8 0.5 C-249 6.7 0.5 C-250 6.75 0.5 C-251 6.8 0.5 C-252 6.68 0.5 C-253 6.7 0.5 C-254 6.7 0.5 C-255 6.75 0.5 C-256 6.8 0.5 C-257 6.8 0.6 C-258 9 1.2 C-259 7.25 0.6 C-260 7.3 0.7 C-261 7.2 0.6 C-262 9.6 1.3 C-263 7.3 0.7 C-264* -39.6 -24.3 C-265 9.5 1.3 SUM 459.83 98.3 MODE 6.7 0.5 MEAN 8.31 1.54 03. 905 old -valorem 7aXAna(ysis Year 2002 City of Miami Property % Change Count % Change Cit C-266 8.6 1.2 C-267 7.3 0.65 C-268 7.2 0.6 C-269 7.2 0.6 C-270 7.4 0.7 C-271 7.1 0.6 C-272 9.4 1.3 C-273 7.2 0.6 C-274 7.3 0.6 C-275 7.5 0.7 C-276 7.5 0.7 C-277 12.3 1.5 C-278 9.9 1.3 C-279 7.1 0.6 C-280 8.0 1.0 C-281 7.5 0.7 C-282 7.4 0.7 C-283 9.7 1.3 C-284 7.4 0.7 C-285 10.4 0.9 C-286 7.1 0.6 C-287 7.2 0.65 C-288 7.4 0.7 03- 905 C-289 7.3 0.5 C-290 7.0 0.5 C-291 7.1 0.5 C-292 7.2 0.5 C-293 7.3 0.5 C-294 9.0 1.2 C-295 7.3 0.7 C-296* -25.0 -13.6 C-297 13.4 2.3 C-298 10.7 1.9 C-299 10.3 1.7 C-300 9.0 1.2 C-301 7.5 0.6 C-302 7.5 0.7 C-303 8.8 1.2 C-304* 99.0 22.3 C-305 1.5 0.75 C-306 10.6 1.3 C-307 7.3 0.7 C-308 7.1 0.6 C-309 7.0 0.6 C-310 10.1 1.35 C-311 10.7 1.4 C-312 7.3 0.65 C-313* 109.5 42.4 C-314 7.7 0.5 C-315* 0.0 0.0 C-316 7.8 0.7 SUM 565.1 92.55 MODE 17.3 0.6 03- 905 MEAN 18.11 10.88 03- 905 fid -valorem TaxAnafysis Year 2002 City of Miami Property % Change Count % Change Cit C-317 7.7 0.4 C-318 12.2 4.5 C-319 10.3 2.7 C-320 8.1 0.7 C-321 13.35 0.9 C-322* -15.9 -10.9 C-323* -24.7 -21.5 C-324 16.7 3.9 C-325 12.6 4.7 C-326 16.2 4.2 C-327 17.7 3.6 C-328* 96.9 51.9 C-329* 961.3 168.2 C-330 10.8 0.8 C-331 10.8 0.8 C-332 61.6 0.9 C-333 13.1 1.5 C-334 15.7 4.5 C-335 3.6 0.5 C-336 10.3 2.7 C-337 15.9 4.7 C-338 7.3 0.7 C-339 7.2 0.5 03- 9o5 SUM 1288.75 230.9 MODE 10.8 0.7 MEAN 14.27 2.27 03- 905 Ad -Valorem 7aXAnafysis Year 2002 City of Miami Property % Change if proposed budget change is made- County % Change if proposed budget change is made- City % Change if no budget change is made- County % Change if no budget change is made- City C-340 33.0 24.0 0.5 -6.1 C-341 64.6 45.8 36.3 28.3 C-342 36.0 27.0 0.5 -6.0 C-343 -0.7 -6.7 4.1 -2.6 C-344 7.02 -5.02 0.8 -6.6 C-345 6.79 -5.4 0.5 -6.0 C-346 6.76 -5.4 0.6 -7.0 C-347 7.19 -5.0 0.9 -6.3 C-348 7.09 -5.1 0.9 -6.45 C-349 7.18 -5.1 0.9 -6.3 C-350 6.97 -5.2 0.6 -5.1 C-351 7.3 -4.9 0.7 -3.95 C-352* 96.9 74.4 51.0 42.4 C-353 10.8 -0.2 0.8 -0.7 C-354* 961.2 840.15 168.2 153.6 C-355* -24.7 -32.9 -21.5 -25.6 C-356* -15.9 -25.5 -10.9 -14.2 C-357 8.1 -4.2 0.7 -2.35 03- 905 SiJM 1225.6 900.73 MODE 7.2 0.7 MEAN 14.86 3.18 Ad-Naforem 7aXAnafysis Year 2002 City of Miami Property % Change if proposed budget change is made- County % Change if proposed budget change is made- City % Change if no budget change is made- County % Change if no budget change is made- City C-340 33.0 24.0 0.5 -6.1 C-341 64.6 45.8 36.3 28.3 C-342 36.0 27.0 0.5 -6.0 C-343 -0.7 -6.7 4.1 -2.6 C-344 7.02 -5.02 0.8 -6.6 C-345 6.79 -5.4 0.5 -6.0 C-346 6.76 -5.4 0.6 -7.0 C-347 7.19 -5.0 0.9 -6.3 C-348 7.09 -5.1 0.9 -6.45 C-349 7.18 -5.1 0.9 -6.3 C-350 6.97 -5.2 0.6 -5.1 C-351 7.3 -4.9 0.7 -3.95 C-352* 96.9 74.4 51.0 42.4 C-353 10.8 -0.2 0.8 -0.7 C-354* 961.2 840.15 168.2 153.6 C-355* -24.7 -32.9 -21.5 -25.6 C-356* -15.9 -25.5 -10.9 -14.2 C-357 8.1 -4.2 10.7 -2.35 03-r 905 SUM 1225.6 900.73 MODE 7.2 0.7 MEAN 14.86 3.18 03- 905 Ad-Vaforem 2"aXAnafysis Year 2002 City of Miami Beach Property % Change Count % Change Cit C-400 74.9 66.9 C-401 * 5.0 0.0 C-402 99.6 89.7 C-403 5.0 0.0 C-404 26.8 20.8 C-405* 99.6 89.7 C-406 12.6 7.3 C-407 21.3 15.6 C-408 7.5 2.45 C-409 7.0 2.0 C-410 7.3 2.3 C-411 7.1 2.05 C-412 7.3 2.3 C-413 7.4 2.4 C-414 6.9 1.9 C-415 7.0 2.0 C-416 7.3 2.3 C-417 7.5 2.5 C-418 7.0 2.0 C-419 7.1 12.1 C-420 7.1 2.1 C-421 7.6 2.5 C-422 16.9 1.9 03- 905- C-423 7.6 2.5 C-424 6.7 1.7 C-425 6.8 1.8 C-426 6.85 1.8 C-427 6.7 1.7 C-428 6.7 1.7 C-429 6.75 1.7 C-430 6.7 1.8 C-431 6.9 1.9 C-432 6.8 1.8 C-433* 219.8 4.8 C-434 37.9 31.4 C-435 7.0 2.0 C-436 6.9 1.9 C-437 6.9 1.9 C-438 6.75 1.7 C-439 6.7 1.7 C-440 6.75 1.75 C-441 6.7 1.7 C-442 6.7 1.7 C-443 6.75 1.7 C-444 6.8 1.8 C-445 6.8 1.8 C-446 6.8 1.8 C-447 6.8 1.8 C-448 6.75 1.75 C-449* 6.7 11.7 SUM 880.8 404.1 MODE 6.7 1.7 MEAN 111.95 6.69 03_ 905 Ad -Valorem 7aXAnafysis Year 2002 City of Miami Beach Property % Change Count % Change Cit C-450 6.8 1.8 C-451 6.75 1.75 C-452 6.8 1.8 C-453 6.7 1.7 C-454 6.8 1.8 C-455 6.75 1.75 C-456 6.7 1.7 C-457 6.7 1.7 C-458 6.9 1.9 C-459 6.7 1.7 C-460 6.7 1.7 C-461 * 181.8 168.6 C-462 6.8 1.8 C-463 6.7 1.7 C-464 6.8 1.8 C-465 6.8 1.8 C-466 6.8 1.75 C-467 6.7 1.7 C-468 6.7 1.7 C-469 6.7 1.7 C-470 6.7 -0.5 C-471 6.85 1.8 C-472 6.8 1.8 03- 90. C-473 6.9 1.9 C-474 6.6 1.6 C-475 6.7 1.7 C-476 6.6 1.6 C-477 6.7 1.7 C-478 6.7 1.7 C-479* 105.2 95.6 C-480 37.7 31.3 C-481 6.7 1.7 i C-482 6.6 1.6 C-483 6.7 1.7 C-484 6.65 1.65 C-485 6.6 1.6 C-486 5.2 2.9 C-487 4.9 1.7 C-488 4.7 1.7 C-489 4.6 1.7 C-490 4.75 1.7 C-491 4.7 1.7 C-492 4.9 1.7 C-493 4.5 1.7 C-494* 4.3 1.7 C-495 4.8 1.7 C-496* 4.45 1.7 C-497 5.0 1.65 C-498 4.65 1.7 C-499 5.9 3.1 C-500 4.5 1.7 SUM 618.65 378.35 MODE 6.7 1.7 09_ 905 MEAN 6.87 1 2.36 03- 905 Ad -valorem 7aXAnafysis Year 2002 City of Cora(Gadles Property % Change Count % Change Cit C-501 23.8 18.0 C-502 7.5 2.5 C-503 6.7 1.7 C-504* 71.9 63.8 C-505 6.8 1.8 C-506 6.8 1.8 C-507 6.7 1.7 C-508 6.6 1.6 C-509 4.9 0.0 C-510 7.6 2.6 C-511 7.8 2.8 C-512 7.7 2.7 C-513* 4.9 0.0 C-514 7.25 2.2 C-515 7.25 2.2 C-516 4.9 0.0 C-517 7.2 2.1 C-518 8.6 3.5 C-519 7.15 2.1 C-520 7.15 2.1 C-521 7.15 2.1 C-522 7.7 26.3 C-523 16.0 10.5 03- 905 C-524 7.6 2.5 C-525 7.6 2.5 C-526 7.1 2.0 C-527 7.0 2.0 C-528 7.2 2.2 C-529 7.2 2.2 C-530 7.2 2.2 C-531* 92.3 83.3 C-532 16.9 11.45 C-533 22.8 17.0 C-534 6.8 1.8 C-535 6.9 1.85 C-536 6.8 1.8 C-537 9.7 4.5 C-538 8.9 3.8 C-539 9.1 14.3 C-540 7.2 2.2 C-541 7.2 2.2 C-542 7.2 2.2 C-543 7.2 2.15 C-544 7.2 2.1 C-545 7.2 2.2 C-546* 4.9 0.0 C-547 7.2 2.2 C-548 7.2 2.2 C-549 7.2 2.2 C-550 7.2 2.2 SUM 558.05 331.35 MODE 7.2 2.2 MEAN 8.34 4.00 03. 905 Ad-Vaforem 7aXAnafysis Year 2002 City of CorafCjadfes Property % Change Count % Change it C-551 8.3 3.25 C-552 6.8 1.8 C-553 9.5 4.4 C-554* 16.3 10.9 C-555 7.4 2.3 C-556 8.8 3.7 C-557 7.6 2.6 C-558 8.5 3.4 C-559 8.15 3.1 C-560 8.0 2.9 C-561 8.0 2.95 C-562* 57.4 50.0 C-563 7.8 2.8 C-564 8.0 2.9 C-565 7.9 2.85 C-566* 4.9 0.0 C-567 8.1 3.05 C-568* 4.9 0.0 C-569 7.5 2.5 C-570 7.3 12.3 C-571 7.3 2.3 C-572 4.9 0.0 C-573 7.35 2.3 03- 905 C-574 8.6 3.5 C-575 8.6 3.5 C-576 7.3 2.3 C-577 7.3 2.3 C-578 7.5 2.45 C-579 7.5 2.45 C-580 5.1 0.0 C-581 14.2 8.9 C-582 7.2 2.2 C-583 7.2 2.2 C-584 4.9 0.0 C-585 7.1 2.1 C-586 8.1 3.0 C-587 8.1 3.1 C-588 7.9 2.8 C-589 8.0 3.0 C-590 7.1 2.1 C-591 7.2 2.15 C-592 7.2 2.2 C-593 7.2 2.2 C-594 7.1 2.1 C-595 7.0 2.0 C-596 7.0 2.0 C-597 7.0 2.0 C-598 7.0 2.0 C-599 7.0 2.0 C-600 7.3 2.3 SUM 433.4 179.15 MODE 7.0 2.0 MEAN 7.6 2.57 03- 905 old-Naforem 2"aXAnafysis Year 2002 City of Jfiafeak Property % Change Count % Change Cit C-601 7.15 2.6 C-602 7.1 2.55 C-603 7.0 2.5 C-604 7.05 2.5 C-605 6.9 2.4 C-606* 4.4 0.0 C-607 7.25 2.7 C-608 7.1 2.5 C-609 7.05 2.5 C-610 65.1 58.1 C-611 7.05 2.5 C-612* 39.7 33.7 C-613 7.15 2.6 C-614 6.9 2.4 C-615 7.0 2.5 C-616* 3.0 94.4 C-617 7.15 2.6 C-618 7.1 2.55 C-619 7.1 2.5 C-620 6.9 2.4 C-621 7.0 2.45 C-622 7.1 2.55 C-623 7.15 12.6 03- 905 C-624 7.0 2.5 C-625 7.1 2.5 C-626 7.15 2.6 C-627 7.05 2.5 C-628 7.0 2.5 C-629 7.0 2.4 C-630 7.15 2.6 C-631 7.1 2.5 C-632 7.2 2.6 C-633 7.1 2.5 C-634* 38.45 32.6 C-635 7.1 2.5 C-636 7.1 2.55 C-637 7.1 2.5 C-638 7.25 2.7 C-639 7.1 2.6 C-640 7.2 2.7 C-641 7.3 2.7 C-642 7.1 2.5 C-643 7.2 2.7 C-644 7.0 2.5 C-645 7.1 2.6 C-646 7.1 2.5 C-647 7.1 2.5 C-648 7.1 2.6 C-649 7.25 2.7 C-650 7.0 2.5 SUM 469.8 333.25 MODE 7.1 2.5 MEAN 8.35 3.75 03- 905 Ad-Vaforem 7aXAnafysis Year 2002 City of Jfiafeah Property % Change Count % Change Cit C-651 7.3 2.7 C-652 6.95 2.4 C-653 7.1 2.6 C-654 7.15 2.6 C-655 7.0 2.5 C-656 7.3 2.7 C-657 7.25 2.7 C-658 7.1 2.5 C-659 7.1 2.6 C-660 7.25 2.7 C-661 7.25 2.7 C-662 7.05 2.5 C-663 7.0 2.5 C-664 7.2 2.7 C-665 11.9 7.2 C-666* 65.1 58.1 C-667 7.1 2.5 C-668 7.2 2.7 C-669* 4.4 0.0 C-670* 4.4 10.0 C-671 7.2 2.6 C-672 7.1 2.6 C-673 17.1 2.6 03- 905 C-674 4.4 0.0 C-675 4.4 0.0 C-676 7.3 2.7 C-677 6.6 2.1 C-678 6.7 2.1 C-679 6.8 2.2 C-680 6.5 1.9 C-681 6.6 2.1 C-682 6.7 2.3 C-683 6.6 2.1 C-684 6.5 2.0 C-685 6.75 2.2 C-686 6.8 2.3 C-687 7.15 2.6 C-688 7.0 2.5 C-689 42.9 36.8 C-690 7.15 2.6 C-691 7.1 2.55 C-692 7.15 2.6 C-693 7.2 2.7 C-694 7.0 2.5 C-695* 53.9 47.9 C-696 6.9 2.4 C-697 6.9 2.4 C-698 6.9 2.3 C-699 6.9 2.5 C-700 7.15 2.6 SUM 485.45 253.65 MODE 7.1 2.6 MEAN 7.775 3.21 03- 905