HomeMy WebLinkAboutM-03-0166AON IS THE ONLY RESPONSIVE PROPOSER
Brown and Brown, Summit Global and Gallagher are
Non -Responsive
RFLI, SUBMISSION REQUIREMENTS SECTION XVII:
Brown and Brown:
•
Did not provide requested information regarding
outstanding claims;
•
Did not provide examples of management information
reports or actuarial service reports;
•
Did not provide a complete response to exposure
identification and evaluation assistance;
•
Did not specifically identify its access to many markets;
•
Did not provide Addendum No. 1;
LU
or
�1
Summit Global:
"�
0
L.L..
O
•
Did not provide verified references;
0
0
•
Did not identify specific markets;
}--
0�0
•
Did not identify specific experts
Z
0
Z
in each coverage area;
Q
U
O
•
Did not provide examples of management reports;
LU
W
•
Did not include description of exposure identification;
Q_'
U
Gallagher:
J
•
Did not provide marketing strategy;
an
!-
1''0
---�
Er �...�
•
Did not identify market expertise with respect to
y.
coverages lifted in Appendix A.;
•
Did not provide specific tools and procedures to identify
and evaluate City's exposure;
•
Did not provide Addendum No. 1;
"Failure to provide each of the above may be cause to deem your
Response non-responsive."
"This Addendum is to be signed and dated by Proposers and
submitted as proof of receipt with the submission of responses."
03- 166
EVALUATION
MAX
RATER
BROWN &
SUMMIT
ARTHUR 3.
AON RISK
CRITERIA
POINTS
BROWN
GLOBAL
GALLAGHER
SERVICES
Proposer's overall professional qualifications
Elliot Fixler
6
5
7
2
& experience, including key staff & account
20
John Petillo
7
4
7
2
representative
Stuart Myers
6
5
7
2
Overall strategy to represent the City; risk
Elliot Fixler
4
4
5
2
identification; & use of computerized
15
John Petillo
4
4
4
3
system(s)
Stuart Myers
4
4
4
3
Elliot Fixler
7
10
8
5
Proposer's marketing expertise
30
John Petillo
9
9
9
3
Stuart Myers
8
8
10
4
Elliot Fixler
1
2
2
0
Outstanding 9 claims against Broker
5
John Petillo
1
1
2
1
Stuart M ers
1
1
2
1
Elliot Fixler
10
9
6
5
Financial Proposal
30
John Petillo
12
9
5
4
Stuart Myers
14
9
4
3
100
OF 300
94
84
82
40
TOTAL POINTS
AVERAGE
100
31.33
28.00
27.33
13.33
RANK
1
1
1 2
3
4
SUBMITTED INTO THE
PUBLIC RECORD FOR
ITEM( -,A DON 2-/3-03,